Full body scanners
-
Yeah pretty much. Will it be a bit more effective than what we have now? Maybe. Certainly can't be any worse that's for damn sure. If it even keeps the level of security equal to now, and speeds up efficiency, that's a good thing. And really i think it is more effective than what we have now in some regards. It's hard to really fully "search" every passenger effectively, as we've all seen of late. Guards get lazy, or apathetic. Streamlining the process for them may very well make it less likely they'll make mistakes. Can they miss something? Of course they can. But they are less likely to miss a fairly obvious image on the scanner than they are to miss something during a half-assed search of the belongings and person of everyone through the gate.
-
I'm not sure I understand the point of this when they let some wannabe bomber on the known blacklist on a plane anyway.... am I missing something basics here?

It seems too easy to get past what they consider to be high security measures anyway, and it's certainly not going to prevent those who are determined to cancel their plans it is?
-
Does banning knives in the UK stop people from getting stabbed left and right?
-
@thebullfrog said:
Does banning knives in the UK stop people from getting stabbed left and right?Depends who you ask!
-
I really don't think that scanners will make much if any difference in security. However, given the potential for added safety I'm willing to give it a try. The (hopefully) improvement in efficiency could be a a huge benefit. Added speed and efficiency, combined with the possibility of at least slightly increased security? I think I'm okay with that.
-
@thebullfrog said:
I really don't think that scanners will make much if any difference in security. However, given the potential for added safety I'm willing to give it a try. The (hopefully) improvement in efficiency could be a a huge benefit. Added speed and efficiency, combined with the possibility of at least slightly increased security? I think I'm okay with that.That's exactly the type of attitude that will turn the entire world into 1984, and as one of the founding member of your nation said, those who give up their liberty for more security neither deserve liberty nor security.
-
Yeah, but I f***king hate queuing in airports - it drives me mental.
-
If they were actually serious about improving security, they'd hire Israeli security personel and then give them free rein.
Imaging may be marginally useful, but probably falls more into the category of "Security Theater."
.
-
I really don't think that scanners will make much if any difference in security. However, given the potential for added safety I'm willing to give it a try. The (hopefully) improvement in efficiency could be a a huge benefit. Added speed and efficiency, combined with the possibility of at least slightly increased security? I think I'm okay with that.
That's exactly the type of attitude that will turn the entire world into 1984, and as one of the founding member of your nation said, those who give up their liberty for more security neither deserve liberty nor security.
Okay first of all, you're making a pretty damn big jump here. There are a LOT of things this country does in the name of "security" that I don't agree with. Including a certain war we started a few years ago. But that's a different rant. I fully 100% agree that giving up a liberty for security is wrong. But you are failing to see that this is not giving up a liberty. What liberty is it giving up? Walking through a glorified X-ray machine is a lot less invasive than having to strip half my freaking clothes off in public in front of a thousand people, being patted down by a complete stranger at least once, and if he's having a bad day, being hauled off and strip searched. And what about women? How do they feel about being strip searched and patted down by these "security" personnel? If I were a woman I'd much rather walk through that scanner than suffer the indignities that so many women deal with every time they board a plane. How many stories have we heard of women being improperly searched. Like the story of the woman who's underwire kept setting off the detectors so they strip searched her. Or another one where she was told she wasn't allowed to wear her bra onto the plane? The scanner sounds a Hell of a lot more liberating if you ask me.
-
But you are not getting any real security! They even admitted that the guy who prompted the FBS wouldn't be caught with it. And privacy is part of civil liberty.
-
You're right, it wouldn't have caught him. But they sure as Hell didn't catch the guy with strip searches and pat downs either did they?
Yes I fully realize that privacy is a civil liberty. A liberty that goes right out the damn window when I have to remove half my clothing, and be felt up by some guy. And WTF privacy do you have being locked into a room, forced to remove all of your clothes in front of a bunch of strangers, while be video taped by the way, and then after being ogled and fondled, being told you can enjoy your vacation, but you're not allowed on the plane wearing your bra? Yeah, that sounds waaaaaaaay more private to me.
-
That's the big point- this isn't going to make things any safer than they are now. Long lineups and pushy, uptight security people at the airport are there to harass people, and make it look like something is being done, when in fact, it doesn't really accomplish anything. I could see if there was some actual merit to this system, but honestly, as a security speSmurfpillst with a degree in investigations and criminal law, plus about 15 years' experience, I really don't see this as actually doing anything but submitting people to a new indignity in hopes of convincing them that something is being done. It's like putting a band aid on a screaming kid's knee- it doesn't do anything but they think everything is ok and move on with their lives.
As for pointing micro cameras into people's houses for a voyeur thrill, that is actually illegal, and not condoned by the government, unlike these body scanners.
Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
That's the big point- this isn't going to make things any safer than they are now. Long lineups and pushy, uptight security people at the airport are there to harass people, and make it look like something is being done, when in fact, it doesn't really accomplish anything.All true, but with Full Body Scanners I'll probably get an extra half hour in bed on the mornings that I catch flights

-
Tragically, I doubt that, but in a week or so I will be waltzing through one or more of these machines on my way to SHOT and I'll make certain to report back on how much faster I made it through, and how much safer I truly felt! :P
Def
-
And these scanners are great for averting a terrorist with a stinger missile or one with a private plane crashing into the terminal
-
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Security_theater
@thebullfrog said:
You're right, it wouldn't have caught him. But they sure as Hell didn't catch the guy with strip searches and pat downs either did they?Yes I fully realize that privacy is a civil liberty. A liberty that goes right out the damn window when I have to remove half my clothing, and be felt up by some guy. And WTF privacy do you have being locked into a room, forced to remove all of your clothes in front of a bunch of strangers, while be video taped by the way, and then after being ogled and fondled, being told you can enjoy your vacation, but you're not allowed on the plane wearing your bra? Yeah, that sounds waaaaaaaay more private to me.
You are just exaggerating.
@DaveK said:
All true, but with Full Body Scanners I'll probably get an extra half hour in bed on the mornings that I catch flights
Do you honestly think that's gona happen? They'll find a way to make up get up half hour early if anything.
-
Well it should be quicker, and if some pervert wants to look at my junk as payment for that, well.... that's a bonus :D
-
More likely when they see you coming they'll switch it off, so how does that make everyone safer? :P
Def
-
-
Dave is just all about not standing in line lol.
And Def I get you're point about the camera being illegal, but I said that in response to your saying that these images would wind up on the internet. That would be just as illegal and not condoned by the government.
I reread some of what I said and do need to clarify something: To an extent my arguments are playing devils advocate. I do not really believe that the scanners are a better system. Nor are they really going to be significantly safer. I really don't. But when I feel my liberties are being violated as it is by the way airport security is run, I'd rather make the tradeoff for (as def put it) one indignity for the other. I'm basically being violated one way or the other. But in theory this MAY increase security in some situations, and be more efficient, and I won't be getting groped and having remove half the crap I'm wearing in front of a whole airport. I don't see the scanners as better per se, but I don't think it's any WORSE than what we have now. More efficiency, less or the same invasion of privacy depending on your point of view, and maybe, just maybe an ever so slightly plane. It really doesn't seem that bad to me. I don't like it, but it isn't any worse than the crap they pass off as security now. And at least nobody is grabbing at my junk.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



