Are SAKs Multi Tools
-
I said yes, as a SAK has lots of tools , (multi)
paul
-
Well although I wrote what you are referring to :D, I thought I'd chime in anyway.
For me, no they are not. A SAK is a SAK just like a MT is a MT. You wouldn't call a PST a SAK would ya? So I wouldn't call a Swisschamp for example a multitool either.
In our world we all know better than your average Joe so IMO we "define" differently. Just the same as we would never imagine calling all plier based tools leathermans (like we commonly hear), I see no reason why we should classify SAK's the same either.
-
I say a multi needs pliers to be a real tool, so I said no. :D
-
I vote yes . They seem to have multiple tools , last I checked . Multi's don't have to be plier based . Watch out for Benner , he'll be along with the big red button any moment now !
Chris
-
@Styerman said:
I vote yes . They seem to have multiple tools , last I checked . Multi's don't have to be plier based . Watch out for Benner , he'll be along with the big red button any moment now !Chris
:D
This really is all up to interpretation. No right or wrong answers here. The classification above is what I use when I refer to things.
-
I agree with Ben. If you can't use the terms interchangeably, ie a LM Kick can be called a SAK and a climber can be called a LM (universal name for MT's for the uninformed ie people not on this forum :D) then SAK's are not MT's. They are multi functional, yes, but "multitool" or "leatherman" is used to describe most plier based tools, at least where I come from. If people see a multi function knife (like the Columbia one I got for Christmas) they say "hey you've got a swiss army knife" not "hey, nice multi tool". It just doesn't go both ways. I suppose that puts a fine point on things and in the grand scheme of things probably really doesn't matter, but that's my $0.02.
-
Nope a sak is definitely not an MT imo :)
-
@Benner said:
Well although I wrote what you are referring to :D, I thought I'd chime in anyway.For me, no they are not. A SAK is a SAK just like a MT is a MT. You wouldn't call a PST a SAK would ya? So I wouldn't call a Swisschamp for example a multitool either.
I look at it this way "All dogs are not labs, but all labs are dogs"
-
Noun
multitool (plural multitools)- A portable hand tool that combines several individual functions in a single assembly, such as a Swiss Army knife.
from here
multi tool is anything with multiple tools, a SAK is just a sub type of multi-tool.
to put it another way:
all SAKs are multitools
however not all multitools are SAKs. -
Noun
multitool (plural multitools)
- A portable hand tool that combines several individual functions in a single assembly, such as a Swiss Army knife.
from here
multi tool is anything with multiple tools, a SAK is just a sub type of multi-tool.
to put it another way:
all SAKs are multitools
however not all multitools are SAKs.And if that's how you classify them, then good on ya. I just don't.
-
@Benner said:
Well although I wrote what you are referring to :D, I thought I'd chime in anyway.For me, no they are not. A SAK is a SAK just like a MT is a MT. You wouldn't call a PST a SAK would ya? So I wouldn't call a Swisschamp for example a multitool either.
In our world we all know better than your average Joe so IMO we "define" differently. Just the same as we would never imagine calling all plier based tools leathermans (like we commonly hear), I see no reason why we should classify SAK's the same either.
I agree with Benner, when I think multitool, I think Leatherman PST and it's many variations. To me a SAK is a knive with other functions
-
I view Multitool as the superset of tools with multiple functional units.
They can then be subdivided into SAK style multitools, "Leatherman Style" multitools and miscellaneous multitools.
SAK style is fairly self explanatory
"Leatherman Style" are all the myriad ways of making a pliers/scissors based multitool (ala PST heritage). I include Swisstools, SOGs, Gerbers, CRKT Zilla tools, Leathermans, Kobalt, Schrade and the like
Miscellaneous includes CRKT Guppie, Flux, Some of the novel Gerber tools, One piece tools, Utilikeys etc.
That's just how I mentally break down the category MULTITOOL.
-
Don't most Victorinox boxes have the word Multi tool on them ?

Dunc
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
I view Multitool as the superset of tools with multiple functional units.They can then be subdivided into SAK style multitools, "Leatherman Style" multitools and miscellaneous multitools.
SAK style is fairly self explanatory
"Leatherman Style" are all the myriad ways of making a pliers/scissors based multitool (ala PST heritage). I include Swisstools, SOGs, Gerbers, CRKT Zilla tools, Leathermans, Kobalt, Schrade and the like
Miscellaneous includes CRKT Guppie, Flux, Some of the novel Gerber tools, One piece tools, Utilikeys etc.
That's just how I mentally break down the category MULTITOOL.
I agree entirely with that Mr W.

-
It was a cheap shot, so it was obvious I was going to take it. :D
-
LOL

Actually They do Stain-less. Vic just lied. :D
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login