Are SAKs Multi Tools
-
Noun
multitool (plural multitools)- A portable hand tool that combines several individual functions in a single assembly, such as a Swiss Army knife.
from here
multi tool is anything with multiple tools, a SAK is just a sub type of multi-tool.
to put it another way:
all SAKs are multitools
however not all multitools are SAKs. -
Noun
multitool (plural multitools)
- A portable hand tool that combines several individual functions in a single assembly, such as a Swiss Army knife.
from here
multi tool is anything with multiple tools, a SAK is just a sub type of multi-tool.
to put it another way:
all SAKs are multitools
however not all multitools are SAKs.And if that's how you classify them, then good on ya. I just don't.
-
@Benner said:
Well although I wrote what you are referring to :D, I thought I'd chime in anyway.For me, no they are not. A SAK is a SAK just like a MT is a MT. You wouldn't call a PST a SAK would ya? So I wouldn't call a Swisschamp for example a multitool either.
In our world we all know better than your average Joe so IMO we "define" differently. Just the same as we would never imagine calling all plier based tools leathermans (like we commonly hear), I see no reason why we should classify SAK's the same either.
I agree with Benner, when I think multitool, I think Leatherman PST and it's many variations. To me a SAK is a knive with other functions
-
I view Multitool as the superset of tools with multiple functional units.
They can then be subdivided into SAK style multitools, "Leatherman Style" multitools and miscellaneous multitools.
SAK style is fairly self explanatory
"Leatherman Style" are all the myriad ways of making a pliers/scissors based multitool (ala PST heritage). I include Swisstools, SOGs, Gerbers, CRKT Zilla tools, Leathermans, Kobalt, Schrade and the like
Miscellaneous includes CRKT Guppie, Flux, Some of the novel Gerber tools, One piece tools, Utilikeys etc.
That's just how I mentally break down the category MULTITOOL.
-
Don't most Victorinox boxes have the word Multi tool on them ?

Dunc
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
I view Multitool as the superset of tools with multiple functional units.They can then be subdivided into SAK style multitools, "Leatherman Style" multitools and miscellaneous multitools.
SAK style is fairly self explanatory
"Leatherman Style" are all the myriad ways of making a pliers/scissors based multitool (ala PST heritage). I include Swisstools, SOGs, Gerbers, CRKT Zilla tools, Leathermans, Kobalt, Schrade and the like
Miscellaneous includes CRKT Guppie, Flux, Some of the novel Gerber tools, One piece tools, Utilikeys etc.
That's just how I mentally break down the category MULTITOOL.
I agree entirely with that Mr W.

-
It was a cheap shot, so it was obvious I was going to take it. :D
-
LOL

Actually They do Stain-less. Vic just lied. :D
-
Actually They do Stain-less. Vic just lied. :D
Before this goes totally OT. ::) ;)I agree with Yud that in all ways a SAK meets the definition of a multitool and I don't think anyone can realistically disagree. However in the interests of clarity I think it is easier to have distinctions. So a pliers based multitool is a MT, a Swiss Army Knife is a SAK, an Atwood is a One Piece Tool etc.
So is a SAK a multitool? Yes, without a doubt.
Will I be calling it a SAK or a MT? It's a SAK of course.
-
LOL

Actually They do Stain-less. Vic just lied. :D
Before this goes totally OT. ::) ;)I agree with Yud that in all ways a SAK meets the definition of a multitool and I don't think anyone can realistically disagree. However in the interests of clarity I think it is easier to have distinctions. So a pliers based multitool is a MT, a Swiss Army Knife is a SAK, an Atwood is a One Piece Tool etc.
So is a SAK a multitool? Yes, without a doubt.
Will I be calling it a SAK or a MT? It's a SAK of course.
What Gareth said about sums it up

@Mike, Lord of the Spammers! said:
Don't most Victorinox boxes have the word Multi tool on them ?

Dunc
They also claim to have phillips drivers, but look how those turned out.

Beat the heretic >:(

Ooh can we all join in :D
Hey Ben

-
What Gareth said :)
-
Like Bob, I agree with Mr. W.
Best - Joe
-
I vote yes. All SAKs are multitools,however not all multitools are SAKs. :D Nice,Magnus

-
A SAK is definitely a multitool, whether it has pliers or not. Claiming that to be called a multitool the tool must have pliers, and that excludes SAKs makes no sense because:
a) Some multitools have folding scissors (or, hopefully soon, side-cutters), and are accepted as multitools
b) Many SAKs have small pliers
c) Wenger's NewRanger series have "full-size" folding pliers as a layer.
There was a half-reasonable classification by Benner which stated that, since SAKs are a category of its own, the definition of "multitool" is actually "miltitools that are not SAKs". I do not subscribe to this convention, but if others like it, so be it. -
Also IF multitool the tool must have pliers what do you do with something like a Swiss Card
-
A swiss champ has pliers :D surly its in the name MULTI (TOOLS) :-\ nothing about MULTI + pliers ??? surly there is room for the good old SAK
and there is a high percentage saying yes,although i can see what folk mean, i call my SAK a SAK not a multitool, but then i call my LM a LM not a multi tool , if i had a sog i would call it a sog, this is confusing and now on brain overload 
paul
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login