Ebay feedback?
-
I recently bought a few SAK's from an ebay member, and I had a less than perfect experience. I'll start from the beginning. I purchased a knife that he called a Tourist. Not that I needed a Tourist, it was just relatively cheap. Not Felinevet cheap, but close. When I got the knife, I immediately saw why I should only shop at Felinevet's shop for used stuff. I swear someone melted gum and drizzled it into the knife. I actually disassembled the whole thing and had to soak all the metal pieces in acetone for an hour to get that gunk off. There was no cleaning the knife while it was put together. And to top it off, it was not a Tourist, it was a sportsman! No biggie, I like all SAK's so I didn't fuss too much, and I left him a small message to help in the future with id'ing these little knives.
He responds back by apologizing and telling me to ship it back, and to order another knife and he'll inlude a free classic to show is sincerity. I am into collecting classics, so I ordered a black one and told him so he would remember to include the offered freebie. I paid $7.50 for this new order. It took two weeks to arrive, and when it did, it arrived alone. I was a little peeved, as I had been enticed to order thinking I would get two.
After all this, I left positive feedback on the first knife, and neutral on the second. He already has a 98% rating. He sends me a nastygram saying I could have emailed him instead of leaving a neutral. I it just me or is he lucky to get a neutral? Emailing him would not have changed the experience, he still lied to me. Call it forgetting, I ordered a knife on a promise and that promise was not fulfilled. I am not a harsh judge of business sense, hell, I forgave a mislabel and a really poor condition knife, didn't I? Am I wrong here?
-
You're not wrong and I'd be annoyed as well. That said if he's a busy seller I can see how he could forget to pop the Classic in for you.
.... However a good seller would instead of sending the nastygram have contacted you to apologise and offer to send the Classic on to you and then perhaps ask nicely if you'd forgive them and consider removing the neutral.
So all in all I'd say he had the neutral coming.
-
That's what I thought, and that's what was hoping he would do, seeing that I didn't burn him by leaving negative feedback. I replied to his nastygram with an explanation of my method. I hope this is the last I hear from him, I am not fond of nasty emails, anyone can write them and they take no guts. I have a 100% rating on ebay, and I realize that sometimes it is hard to maintain, but I always make my buyers happy. I guess it stems from working in Hospitality, but I genuinely like seeing people thrilled with their purchase.
-
Ok, I just got nastygram #2, this time he has turned hostile and blocked me.
This is his ebay name: dbaumgarten3266
Here is the list of messages:
His first:
instead of leaving a neutral you could have emailed and told me I
forgotMy reply:
It wouldn't have changed the experience, and I shouldn't have had to. That is why I left a neutral, instead of negative. I didn't feel you deserved a bad review considering I got the one knife, but you forgot a promise so you didn't get a good review either. I just had a sale that was forced into two shipments, and the buyer was angry. She still received all her items, but to apologize I shipped out two accessories at my expense. It's good business. I didn't forget her, and I got a rave review. No offense intended at all, it was just an ok experience.
his reply:
that is ok , do as you wish , if i remember i did not miss ship , just
miss identify, sorry i cant keep up to your standards so i blocked you
from further auctions to save the confusion and passed the
experience on to a few other knife sellers ( we work together) have a
great dayI informed him that I was passing this on to other knife buyers (we work together too!)
All this over NEUTRAL feedback!
-
@gadgetguy35 said:
Ok, I just got nastygram #2, this time he has turned hostile and blocked me.This is his ebay name: dbaumgarten3266
Here is the list of messages:
His first:
instead of leaving a neutral you could have emailed and told me I
forgotMy reply:
It wouldn't have changed the experience, and I shouldn't have had to. That is why I left a neutral, instead of negative. I didn't feel you deserved a bad review considering I got the one knife, but you forgot a promise so you didn't get a good review either. I just had a sale that was forced into two shipments, and the buyer was angry. She still received all her items, but to apologize I shipped out two accessories at my expense. It's good business. I didn't forget her, and I got a rave review. No offense intended at all, it was just an ok experience.
his reply:
that is ok , do as you wish , if i remember i did not miss ship , just
miss identify, sorry i cant keep up to your standards so i blocked you
from further auctions to save the confusion and passed the
experience on to a few other knife sellers ( we work together) have a
great dayI informed him that I was passing this on to other knife buyers (we work together too!)
All this over NEUTRAL feedback!
I hate when I misidentify that briefcase with $1million dollars as one that has $1million monopoly dollars too... ::)
I think neutral is fair, given the experience you had.
-
This guy won't stop, I just got another from him. I am blocking his future messages because he is talking out of his arse now. AVOID this ebay member!
-
I disagree!
You should post up his email! :D
AND you should email him back and send him a link to this thread so he can see his ebay name and nastygrams!
:D
-
My very first E-bay buy was not a good experience,
Very annoying as it made me think I had done something wrong :ahhhSounds to me that you were more than fair!

+1 with Mr Whippy
-
I think feedback is over-complicated sometimes tbh. If you're pissed off - let the bugger know it!
Personally, I'll always give a seller chance to redeem himself, but if I've had poor service then I expect above average service to balance things up. In your case, I'd have expected him to take extra special notice of whether he'd included the promised Classic, which he clearly didn't.
-
I made it very clear to him that all he needed to do was send on the knife and I would be done with it, I would even withdraw the neutral feedback as a show of appreciation. I also informed him that I was posting on here and will be posting on knifeforums if I get a chance. He replied by asking who the hell MT.O is and what is knifeforums. I told him that we were a group of knife and tool enthusiasts that (because of Chako) account for a large majority of used SAK sales! he said so what, so I sent him a link to Felinevet's shop and informed him that I would be shopping exclusively within SOSAK and MT.O to get my future SAK's. No response to that, he seems to be thinking.
-
@gadgetguy35 said:
I made it very clear to him that all he needed to do was send on the knife and I would be done with it, I would even withdraw the neutral feedback as a show of appreciation. I also informed him that I was posting on here and will be posting on knifeforums if I get a chance. He replied by asking who the hell MT.O is and what is knifeforums. I told him that we were a group of knife and tool enthusiasts that (because of Chako) account for a large majority of used SAK sales! he said so what, so I sent him a link to Felinevet's shop and informed him that I would be shopping exclusively within SOSAK and MT.O to get my future SAK's. No response to that, he seems to be thinking.Remind me not to cross you - will you? :D
-
It would seem that I got through to him, as he has now offered to send on the knife he promised plus a couple classics for my friends. I guess he means you guys! If I actually get these knives, I will spread the joy!
-
I made it very clear to him that all he needed to do was send on the knife and I would be done with it, I would even withdraw the neutral feedback as a show of appreciation. I also informed him that I was posting on here and will be posting on knifeforums if I get a chance. He replied by asking who the hell MT.O is and what is knifeforums. I told him that we were a group of knife and tool enthusiasts that (because of Chako) account for a large majority of used SAK sales! he said so what, so I sent him a link to Felinevet's shop and informed him that I would be shopping exclusively within SOSAK and MT.O to get my future SAK's. No response to that, he seems to be thinking.
Remind me not to cross you - will you? :D
I really do come off like an arse don't I? :D
I wasn't mad at all, that's why I left neutral instead of negative, I just wanted him to learn from the experience and I didn't really expect a free knife, but I was ok with it. Then he went off on me and that was all she wrote. >:D
-
I'm only kidding. I'm a firm believer that you should use any feedback system the way you, yourself feel you should. Most people don't, and that kind of devalues the whole thing I think.
-
GG35
You sound good to me (I think I would have used rude words)
He was the one starting with the threats!
He sounds like a tosser and I would still not deal with him myself! >:(Will we all get one each?

-
The whole problem with eBay is the "feedback system". The owner say it works? Hogwash! When 2 people rely on photos to subjectively judge what the condition is of an item there are almost always going to be differences of opinion. Opinions are like @$$*&%$$, everyone has one.
If you want to know what kind of person you are dealing with just read through some of their feedback comments made and you should get a good idea.
The only way to make eBay really work is by using the PayPal system and forcing a return with refund. Think about it, if sellers have to take returns more often due to their ineptitude they will get the point and start to work with that system. Also buyers will start to rely only on more dependable sellers.
I have a short list of very dependable sellers that I use quite often. Now I will bid with other sellers that are new or have less than a stellar feedback number sometimes as well but I have been stung several times by real losers.
I also have a list of sellers who I will not deal with no matter what they are selling.
To me eBay is the largest "Flea Market, Yard Sale, Garage Sale" website in the world. Until their is a competitor that has a similar audience there will only be "fleaBay".
-
@sparky415 said:
GG35
You sound good to me (I think I would have used rude words)
He was the one starting with the threats!
He sounds like a tosser and I would still not deal with him myself! >:(Will we all get one each?

I told him there were over 600, just to be funny. I have no idea what the real number is. He would go bankrupt!
-
BTW, that seller you mentioned "dbaumgarten3266", I have investigated before and is on my list of not trustworthy sellers. I found some shill bidding and feedback manipulation going on between him and another seller who I still use although not as much now. Turns out they both live within a half hour drive and both end up selling the same things back and forth sometimes. It is not that hard to tell when 2 sellers have been shill bidding each others items up. I notified eBay but as we all know nothing ever seems to get done.
-
Here is proof of what I said above;
Check out the following 2 links from eBay and it should be clear of shill bidding between these 2 sellers.
These are current history searches so as the date range changes it may or may not be as clear. I took a screenshot of these from today just to verify for this date.

-
Here is the other link page---sorry for the low quality but had to lower it due to size constraints.
Clearly you can see where they have collaborated together. Keep in mind these are only the "winning" bids placed on each others items, which means there will be more where they were outbid thereby causing some unlucky eBay buyer to bid higher and pay more.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login