Gerber MP 600 D.E.T Fake.
-
Now...do you think I can sell these on ebay if I list them as Gerber fakes???

-
@Fisting_Chili said:
Now...do you think I can sell these on ebay if I list them as Gerber fakes???
eBay really helps perpetuate this sort of unauthorized/counterfeit business by allowing these overseas sellers to maintain auctions - the companies affected have little recourse against the seller(s), other than maybe shutting down their eBay accounts.
If someone were stupid enough to import those things to the US and then sell them, then they could get hit with trademark/patent infringement suits like whoa

-
Its all about presentation :P
**Title: <u>Genuine INFAMOUS Gerber FAKES!!!</u>
Description: Yes these are the real deal! These are not just any old knock -off, NO! These are the truly infamous ones that you've heard all the woeful tales about. The clandestine oriental deals, the black mail, the retaliation, the horror of negative feedback :o
Become the end of this internet legend and own one of THESE <insert picture>
You know you'll regret it if you don't win this, there are no second chances. You've followed the drama, now's your chance to be part of it.**
-
@Neil said:
Its all about presentation :P**Title: <u>Genuine INFAMOUS Gerber FAKES!!!</u>
Description: Yes these are the real deal! These are not just any old knock -off, NO! These are the truly infamous ones that you've heard all the woeful tales about. The clandestine oriental deals, the black mail, the retaliation, the horror of negative feedback :o
Become the end of this internet legend and own one of THESE <insert picture>
You know you'll regret it if you don't win this, there are no second chances. You've followed the drama, now's your chance to be part of it.**

-
@Neil said:
Its all about presentation :P**Title: <u>Genuine INFAMOUS Gerber FAKES!!!</u>
Description: Yes these are the real deal! These are not just any old knock -off, NO! These are the truly infamous ones that you've heard all the woeful tales about. The clandestine oriental deals, the black mail, the retaliation, the horror of negative feedback :o
Become the end of this internet legend and own one of THESE <insert picture>
You know you'll regret it if you don't win this, there are no second chances. You've followed the drama, now's your chance to be part of it.**
Neil's on the sauce again ::) :D
-
Just a slight headache actually

-
Mine is a real Lansky. I checked Lansky’s official site when I bought it and it matched.
That tool is generic. All those examples are basically the same tool made by the same factory, with different cosmetics specific to the buyer.
-
@Chako said:
Mine is a real Lansky. I checked Lansky’s official site when I bought it and it matched.That tool is generic. All those examples are basically the same tool made by the same factory, with different cosmetics specific to the buyer.
also the fasteners used on the tools next to the Lansky look very much like the one used on the "fake" Gerber
-
That is because that middle one is what the seller is selling as a Gerber...which it isn't. I bought that one somewhere in town for a song and a dance. It wasn't pretending to be anything other then what it is. The Lansky is real, and was in the right packaging and all. I got that one from the local gun shop. The other is another version of the same tool. It is a very common type of tool that can be found with plenty of cosmetic variations. The tools inside of these are all the same though.
That seller is using the middle cheap tool and trying to tell people it is a Gerber. If you don't know what your looking for, some unsuspecting person might think it is a Suspension or some other like shaped Gerber.
Seeing that eBay hasn't done anything to this guy, it looks like they are quite happy in getting their fees from him above making the um....er...."eBay experience" a safe one for buyers.
-
@Chako said:
That is because that middle one is what the seller is selling as a Gerber...which it isn't. I bought that one somewhere in town for a song and a dance. It wasn't pretending to be anything other then what it is. The Lansky is real, and was in the right packaging and all. I got that one from the local gun shop. The other is another version of the same tool. It is a very common type of tool that can be found with plenty of cosmetic variations. The tools inside of these are all the same though.That seller is using the middle cheap tool and trying to tell people it is a Gerber. If you don't know what your looking for, some unsuspecting person might think it is a Suspension or some other like shaped Gerber.
Seeing that eBay hasn't done anything to this guy, it looks like they are quite happy in getting their fees from him above making the um....er...."eBay experience" a safe one for buyers.
That just goes against my principles. Bugs the hell out of me.
-

Someone should compare the "fake" 600 to that model
Like i said, if this was a "counterfeit," someone went thru a lot of trouble and expense to make the tooling necessary to make a pretty close facsimile. Which doesnt make a whole lot of business sense, because Ebay is one of the few venues where a seller could get away with passing this off as the real thing.
@mhhanson said:
This is highly likely an example of why you have to really watch what is happening with overseas production. It can happen with any outsourced production, but overseas where you are not there watching, it can really show up. There have been companies ruined by the clones that rolled off of unsupervised lines. They transferred the technology and were transferred out of business.It is just too easy when there is no one around to walk the product out of the back door. If nothing happens then it just gets worse until you see your product sitting at half price next to your official one. Then they say sorry and go on to the next sucker.
This is not a Xenophopic chant, I have seen good stuff done off shore or by contract, honestly, but usually to get it, you pay a premium to get it, have your people there and on a first name basis with the company, and/or own the plant. When outsourcing, it is very much buyer beware and requires more effort than most companies realize. It is not just the MBA attitude, lets get of that troublesome, dirty plant and rake in the dough, it is harder work wth the travel as running that dirty, troublesome plant or you end up in a process that starts with Chapter and ends with 11 or 7.
My vote goes for this one walked out the back door.
Great observations.
IF i were a betting man, i would put my money on either a current (or former) Gerber component supplier.
-
That is an MP400, which is smaller than the MP600 line. Comparing the fake 600 D.E.T. to a smaller tool makes no sense when the fake is the same size as the real 600.
I do agree with you tough, someone went to a lot of trouble in copying the real Gerber. My only guess is that the real one is close to 100 US on eBay, and someone along the way felt bad about selling them for that price and making a huge profit, and started to sell them for under 30 bucks.
-
@WH867 said:
Mine showed up today. Couple pics beside the real one..




See I am not a complete fool , bloody close copy :( :( :(.
I would be keen to hear from Gerber about this , surely they used some Gerber parts to make this copy.

Like Multitaskertools says, those fasteners on the Fake scream Gerber.
Supplier gone rouge maybe we wont hear from Gerber
:D -
Different plier head mold though. And different handle stamping dies. And different blades. And different slide lock releases.
Does it seem likely that the supplier of genuine Gerber screws would go out and purchase ALL of the other tooling necessary to produce all the other components?
I wouldn't think so. :-\ -
@Chako said:
That is an MP400, which is smaller than the MP600 line. Comparing the fake 600 D.E.T. to a smaller tool makes no sense when the fake is the same size as the real 600.you miss my point; I'm saying the components on the "fake" 600 look like they're made by the same place that makes the mp400
-
No they aren't. The tools have subtle differences, even to the genuine MP 600. There is a slight difference in shapes, etc. Definitely in thickness. They are thinner than any Geber tool found on the 400/600 line.
MultiMat, if you look closely on yours, you will also note that the fasteners are not exact either. Bloody close, but they do not match my other MP 600s.
Yeah, it is a good fake. Surprisingly well made at that considering its lack of a pedigree.
-
@Chako said:
No they aren't. The tools have subtle differences, even to the genuine MP 600. There is a slight difference in shapes, etc. Definitely in thickness. They are thinner than any Geber tool found on the 400/600 line.MultiMat, if you look closely on yours, you will also note that the fasteners are not exact either. Bloody close, but they do not match my other MP 600s.
Yeah, it is a good fake. Surprisingly well made at that considering its lack of a pedigree.
Agreed. Everything is close. But nothing is exactly the same.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login