Why don't...
-
Yup- I'm fat and middle aged.... I could probably do my job in a Smart Car! :ahhh
Def
-
I'd love a smart car
with a hayabusa engine in it. >:D
But on topic, I used to go offroad, but due to new housing popping up like dandelions there is no longer any place to go. Although my jeep comes in handy in winter, if the situation allows I'd gladly trade it for a mini cooper S/mazdaspeed miata/mustang GT.
-
wow fun read

Bullfrog- here is a reason for a big truck they are fun :D
We just got a truck (chevy avalanche) because it was decided they we want to camp so we needed a something to tow. It has replaced our ford van because it is fun to drive, also the MPG dose not matter my mom works an Oil company (NOT BP) and the van is old enough that it is not a big diffrence.
-
I have to say, I fully agree with Bullfrog. Kinda strange that you think they like to be higher, and I guess this is the same thing, but safer usually comes up more. Whippy and Gareth said it though, they get such terrible ratings and rollovers are way to common.
Also, I wiped the sweat off my brow when he said that Rangers were okay in his books, cause I drive one. But in my mind, 100% justifiable. I camp, haul wood to my cabin, work construction summer jobs, ski, climb (which usually means we are going on some random road that needs 4x4). In my part of the woods, we are in the woods, in BC. So trucks are extremely common, lots of forestry workers, some oil guys. Few odd a-holes that got the $5000 lifts in their trucks that will never see rain, never mind mud...
-
I have heard the safer argument, but really, people always tell me it's because they like to be "high up", and can't justify it beyond that. In some places it makes sense to me to have a truck as the family vehicle. If you have a big family and live in, say, Canada or Alaska where you get like 200 feet of snow, a large truck or SUV is a smart thing to buy. Around here however that doesn't happen. Even in our worst snows, I've never had a problem driving in any car. FWD, RWD, whatever, even if we get a couple feet, it's not that hard to handle if you know how to drive, especially since everything gets plowed around here. If you need room a wagon will do just fine, get one with AWD and you can handle anything that will ever happen around here, while technically being safer and saving a ton of money. Not to mention a good AWD wagon I guarantee will do better in snow than all the half-assed FWD truck wannabe SUV's that people insist on driving, that are really just minivans with the sliding doors removed.
-
I have a huge truck and jeep to pull out all of the small cars out of ditches or the small cars that stuck on the road in the snow.(I am not joking) And yes I use my 79 ford F350 with a 400ci big block engine to drive back and forth to work, haul 1500 lb bales of hay to different farms(3 at a time), move farm machinery to different fields and to go to the store for a few groceries. And yes I do b#@%$ about the price of fuel when there is tons of oil in our own country that we are not allowed to drill. Do not get me wrong, i am for alternative fuels and new more fuel efficient trucks, cars and etc.,but till they come up with a new fuel that works good or improve the new fuels that are out there now, drill some d@*n oil in this country. As far as my jeep goes, it is more efficient than my truck and I have one because I just plain wanted one. It is great for snow, mud, trail running, pull smart cars out of the ditches and etc which is what I use it for. But if I want a jeep, i am getting a jeep.
OK rant over, sorry about that.
-
@thebullfrog said:
I have heard the safer argument, but really, people always tell me it's because they like to be "high up", and can't justify it beyond that.Higher up is safer, simply because you have better visibility (obvisouly the driver need to pay attention to surrounding to begin with). Once I was driving on the highway, and I could see the traffic in front quickly slowing down, so I slowed down accordingly. The guy in front of me has his view blocked by a minivan (which I could barely see pass), so when the minivan smashed brake he didn't have enough time to respond and plowed into it.
Another one is nothing something I can prove but just a gut feeling. You know those dump trucks on road, with bumper way off the ground and nothing below like a 18 wheeler. The bumper is right where my head is when in a passenger car, with just the three pillar to protect me if that thing smack into me. With my jeep that bumper is where my feet is and have the much more solid ladder frame to take the hit, maybe it's safer, maybe not, but I feel better about it.
-
I have heard the safer argument, but really, people always tell me it's because they like to be "high up", and can't justify it beyond that.
Higher up is safer, simply because you have better visibility (obvisouly the driver need to pay attention to surrounding to begin with). Once I was driving on the highway, and I could see the traffic in front quickly slowing down, so I slowed down accordingly. The guy in front of me has his view blocked by a minivan (which I could barely see pass), so when the minivan smashed brake he didn't have enough time to respond and plowed into it.
Another one is nothing something I can prove but just a gut feeling. You know those dump trucks on road, with bumper way off the ground and nothing below like a 18 wheeler. The bumper is right where my head is when in a passenger car, with just the three pillar to protect me if that thing smack into me. With my jeep that bumper is where my feet is and have the much more solid ladder frame to take the hit, maybe it's safer, maybe not, but I feel better about it.
I'm sorry but that's why you should leave plenty of breaking distance between you and the car in front, something BTW that most drivers in the UK seem to suck at. If everyone drove trucks just so as they could see better, then everyone is back to driving at the same height as all the other vehicles on the road.
@ducttapetech said:
I have a huge truck and jeep to pull out all of the small cars out of ditches or the small cars that stuck on the road in the snow.(I am not joking) And yes I use my 79 ford F350 with a 400ci big block engine to drive back and forth to work, haul 1500 lb bales of hay to different farms(3 at a time), move farm machinery to different fields and to go to the store for a few groceries. And yes I do b#@%$ about the price of fuel when there is tons of oil in our own country that we are not allowed to drill. Do not get me wrong, i am for alternative fuels and new more fuel efficient trucks, cars and etc.,but till they come up with a new fuel that works good or improve the new fuels that are out there now, drill some d@*n oil in this country. As far as my jeep goes, it is more efficient than my truck and I have one because I just plain wanted one. It is great for snow, mud, trail running, pull smart cars out of the ditches and etc which is what I use it for. But if I want a jeep, i am getting a jeep.OK rant over, sorry about that.
I'd say you have every reason to own a truck then, both for work and for the heavy weather you have. I'm not saying that trucks and big 4x4's are in any way bad, it's just that not everybody who has one needs one. I know I don't as I spend much of my time in the city, but looking out my window I can see three big 4x4's that have never (to the best of my knowledge) ever been muddy in their lives.
Lets put it this way, there are some people who need a Supertool 300, there are some that need a Wave, and there are some that can get buy with a Squirt. It's just about picking the right tool for the circumstances. :)
-
@Gareth said:
Lets put it this way, there are some people who need a Supertool 300, there are some that need a Wave, and there are some that can get buy with a Squirt. It's just about picking the right tool for the circumstances. :)Possibly not the best analogy to use on this forum, as the motto is "get all three". But I agree with everything you say above :)
-
everyone heres broke from just tools, i doubt they d manage cars aswell dave :D
-
I'm going to have to agree with the Bullfrog on this one (although possibly not as fanatically)
I own three trucks that are used for their specific purposes; one is a fullsize. However, at least 80% of my driving is in a Ford Focus. I consider it the safest vehicle I own--not just because of safety test results--but because it is MUCH more nimble than the trucks. It's much more fun to drive too, for the same reason.
I don't usually drive a truck unless I need a truck. I wish more folks around here would follow this line of thought. If there weren't so many damn unnecessary trucks on the road, nobody would need to drive a truck to see over them.
-
-
@BlueDot said:
Second, While it's true that the big vehicle will run over the smaller in a crash, you are more likely to have an accident in a truck with 30% longer stopping distance. And slower to respond to evasive tactics due to more mass.To an extent, maybe. But excess mass alone can't be blamed for a vehicle's sluggish kinematics. You can rest assured that a Bimmer M5 will handle and brake a whole lot better than a Honda Fit, despite weighing ~700 kg more.
An SUV's mass does play a role in its sluggish handling characteristics largely because its center of gravity lies quite a bit higher than a car's.
@Gareth said:
Big doesn't always mean safer anyway. I'm sure you guys have similar crash tests over there but here the standard is the Euro NCAP testing. So a Ford Ranger is only a two star car (out of five) http://www.euroncap.com/tests/ford_ranger_2008/342.aspxWhile a Smart Fortwo (one of the smallest cars on the road) has a four star rating. http://www.euroncap.com/tests/ford_ranger_2008/342.aspx
One has to remain mindful of the basic laws of collision physics when perusing these "star" ratings. These tests are done with cars hitting a wall at a set speed (V)--essentially demonstrating how the car would behave if it 1) hit a wall at V kph, or 2) hit another car EXACTLY like it head-on, both moving at V/2 kph.
Every moving object/vehicle has KINETIC ENERGY (which is (mass in kg)*(speed in m/s ^2))/2)... That means for any given speed, the relationship between a car's kinetic energy and its mass is 1:1... Basically, more mass = more energy. So, if a 2,000 kg SUV going 50 kph hits a small 1,000 kg "mini" car head-on (which is also going 50 kph), the SUV will be bringing twice the kinetic energy as the small car into the collision, and that does not bode well for the car, no matter what its "star" rating.
We can look at such a crash in equivalent "into a wall" speeds to really drive home this point. A collision's total energy is the sum of both cars' KE. Using the above KE formula, and assuming a perfectly head-on (no angles) inelastic collision between the two cars (to keep things simple), the SUV will be hitting the car with an equivalent "into a wall" speed of ~61 kph. The car, OTOH, will be hitting the SUV with an equivalent "into a wall" speed of ~86 kph--a 41% difference, which is significant.
Now, don't get me wrong. I do think a lot of truck owners really have no need for their big hulking trucks (for reasons already stated). And I'm not at all eschewing these star ratings, as they really are a good yardstick to help determine a car's crash worthiness, just so long as you're mindful that these ratings become less relevant when making comparisons with cars that have significantly different mass.
My 2¾¢. :)
-
@Gareth said:
I'm sorry but that's why you should leave plenty of breaking distance between you and the car in front, something BTW that most drivers in the UK seem to suck at. If everyone drove trucks just so as they could see better, then everyone is back to driving at the same height as all the other vehicles on the road.You should, but try drive like that in rush hour on a major metropolitan freeway. :P
Higher up is safer, simply because you have better visibility
Is it really that simple? What about the higher center of gravity and poor handling associated with "higher up"? IMO, those characteristics would make "higher up" less safe.
It's a trade off, but I'm willing to accept that, plus I don't get door dings in parking lot. :D
Of course the ideal solution is like what you did having several vehicles for different purposes, I'd love a small and quick car to drive around town. But outside u.s. it's just not possible unless one's stinking rich, everything from registration, insurance, parking is at a premium.
-
Second, While it's true that the big vehicle will run over the smaller in a crash, you are more likely to have an accident in a truck with 30% longer stopping distance. And slower to respond to evasive tactics due to more mass.
To an extent, maybe. But excess mass alone can't be blamed for a vehicle's sluggish kinematics. You can rest assured that a Bimmer M5 will handle and brake a whole lot better than a Honda Fit, despite weighing ~700 kg more.
An SUV's mass does play a role in its sluggish handling characteristics largely because its center of gravity lies quite a bit higher than a car's.
@Gareth said:
Big doesn't always mean safer anyway. I'm sure you guys have similar crash tests over there but here the standard is the Euro NCAP testing. So a Ford Ranger is only a two star car (out of five) http://www.euroncap.com/tests/ford_ranger_2008/342.aspxWhile a Smart Fortwo (one of the smallest cars on the road) has a four star rating. http://www.euroncap.com/tests/ford_ranger_2008/342.aspx
One has to remain mindful of the basic laws of collision physics when perusing these "star" ratings. These tests are done with cars hitting a wall at a set speed (V)--essentially demonstrating how the car would behave if it 1) hit a wall at V kph, or 2) hit another car EXACTLY like it head-on, both moving at V/2 kph.
Every moving object/vehicle has KINETIC ENERGY (which is (mass in kg)*(speed in m/s ^2))/2)... That means for any given speed, the relationship between a car's kinetic energy and its mass is 1:1... Basically, more mass = more energy. So, if a 2,000 kg SUV going 50 kph hits a small 1,000 kg "mini" car head-on (which is also going 50 kph), the SUV will be bringing twice the kinetic energy as the small car into the collision, and that does not bode well for the car, no matter what its "star" rating.
We can look at such a crash in equivalent "into a wall" speeds to really drive home this point. A collision's total energy is the sum of both cars' KE. Using the above KE formula, and assuming a perfectly head-on (no angles) inelastic collision between the two cars (to keep things simple), the SUV will be hitting the car with an equivalent "into a wall" speed of ~61 kph. The car, OTOH, will be hitting the SUV with an equivalent "into a wall" speed of ~86 kph--a 41% difference, which is significant.
Now, don't get me wrong. I do think a lot of truck owners really have no need for their big hulking trucks (for reasons already stated). And I'm not at all eschewing these star ratings, as they really are a good yardstick to help determine a car's crash worthiness, just so long as you're mindful that these ratings become less relevant when making comparisons with cars that have significantly different mass.
My 2¾¢. :)
I can't argue with that, but it does assume a direct head on collision. In the accident witnessed by jzmtl (running into the back of a hard breaking minivan) I'd still rather be in the more structurally stable Smart car.
You could also argue that if everyone drove a 1,000g car rather than a 2,000kg truck then there would be an awful lot less energy being brought into your equation. Surely an argument for more people to be driving smaller cars rather than bigger ones?
-
Not to mention that rollover safety standards are way lax for trucks compared to cars, so in a rollover a car will do better, which is even scarier when you consider trucks are for more likely to roll in the first place.
-
@jzmtl said:
It's a trade off, but I'm willing to accept that, plus I don't get door dings in parking lot. :DOf course the ideal solution is like what you did having several vehicles for different purposes, I'd love a small and quick car to drive around town. But outside u.s. it's just not possible unless one's stinking rich, everything from registration, insurance, parking is at a premium.
You make a good point there--one that I don't think about much.
If I were to keep only one of my vehicles it would be the mildly-lifted XJ, so I guess I can sort of see things from your point of view.
-
I think Ducttapetech hit the nail on the head:
@ducttapetech said:
But if I want a jeep, i am getting a jeep.We can sit here and point out what people need and argue about what's safer and what's better and it's really all highly subjective. What we need to remember is that we all live in relatively free societies that allow us to buy what we want and what we can afford, and for most of us, we try to get that little bit more in everything. For some, that little bit extra is the ability to see over things that others can't. For others, it's getting a little bit more mileage, and yet for others it's trying to convert everyone to riding bicycles everywhere! :P
I don't need a Jeep. Yes I go off roading, but I only do it because I have a Jeep, not the other way around. I can justify it by saying that I need it to pick up things for the house, but the reality is, Home Depot delivers, so that's a load of poo. Also, I can fit both my dogs into my wife's Sunfire- which we did for years. So really, I don't need a Jeep. But, I'm a fat, middle aged guy and I wanted a convertible, and I like trucks, so I bought one. Fortunately I am averagely endowed so I didn't need a Ram 3500 with the Hemi and a 6 inch lift to compensate. Some people do though, and that's their choice.
We can complain and discuss this till the cows come home, but we should be careful on how far we push others to shtart sinkink der same vay ve do, because ve all know vhat road zat kind of mentality leads us down. ;)
Def
-
I do gotta say though that I really am a bit hypocritical. Because the fact is you don't by any means need a fast car to get anywhere, but I insist on modifying every car I have ever owned and will always continue to do so. It's never fast enough. Of course I never complain about how much the gas costs when my mileage drops into the toilet and I have to run premium to keep from blowing pistons apart. I'm sure my loud ass car pisses people off just as much I get pissed not being able to see around the dillhole in the Tundra blocking my view of the turn lane.
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
I think Ducttapetech hit the nail on the head:But if I want a jeep, i am getting a jeep.
We can sit here and point out what people need and argue about what's safer and what's better and it's really all highly subjective. What we need to remember is that we all live in relatively free societies that allow us to buy what we want and what we can afford, and for most of us, we try to get that little bit more in everything. For some, that little bit extra is the ability to see over things that others can't. For others, it's getting a little bit more mileage, and yet for others it's trying to convert everyone to riding bicycles everywhere! :P
I don't need a Jeep. Yes I go off roading, but I only do it because I have a Jeep, not the other way around. I can justify it by saying that I need it to pick up things for the house, but the reality is, Home Depot delivers, so that's a load of poo. Also, I can fit both my dogs into my wife's Sunfire- which we did for years. So really, I don't need a Jeep. But, I'm a fat, middle aged guy and I wanted a convertible, and I like trucks, so I bought one. Fortunately I am averagely endowed so I didn't need a Ram 3500 with the Hemi and a 6 inch lift to compensate. Some people do though, and that's their choice.
We can complain and discuss this till the cows come home, but we should be careful on how far we push others to shtart sinkink der same vay ve do, because ve all know vhat road zat kind of mentality leads us down. ;)
Def
Was that a dig at me
:D
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login