thoughts about bladeforums
-
I think it's kind of interesting that knife forums probably attract a slightly different crowd than a multitool forum. ::)
I've always appreciated design more than stabby pointy things. :D -
I used to really enjoy going to Bladeforums, back before they got rid of the Kershaw sub-forum. Once that disappeared, I kinda quit going there very often. I've noticed there and certain other forums crucify new guys for asking some commonly asked questions. The search function is great, but I thought the point of a forum was for people with common interests to discuss those interests. Can't say it has happened to me, its just something I've found to be somewhat rude. Bladeforums Multi-tool sub-forum is how I ended up here. It's the "pub after work" atmosphere that keeps me here.
-
All these horror stories remind me of a few old forums I used to frequent. As someone had said before, the bigger a forum is the worse it gets. I was part of a great little guitar forum back, oh probably 2-3 years ago. When I started out it was the same type of atmosphere as here, chilled out and friendly. I made friends there that I would accept into my home any time. I'm STILL friends with some of them. However, as time went on, the forum got bigger and bigger, to the point where most of the old guys, the founders of TGF, had left, and the ones who remained were just so pissy and hard on administration it was getting ridiculous. There was a "karma" system there, where you could vote someone +1 or -1 every 4 hours. When I started out, for a few months I think I had something like 40 or 50. That was pretty normal, no one really took it seriously because everyone was friends and no one would ever down-vote someone. We were like a brotherhood or something. By the time I left I think i had -200 something, and had been temporarily banned multiple times. Nothing changed with me, my posting, or my personality, yet by the time I had left pretty much every post I made was met with rudeness or a reprimand. Everything I said was always met with negativity. It was really heartbreaking to see a forum I loved so much go down the crapper, but I abandoned ship before it sunk completely. At this point I don't think there is a single TGF veteran still frequenting the forum there.
After TGF I was pretty lost and alienated in terms of forums. I tried out shortscale.org but they were even bigger than TGF on it's biggest day. From the moment I first posted I was met with rudeness and hostility.
Seriously, MTO is like an oasis on the internet. Over these past few months I've seen kindness and friendliness I didn't even see in TGF's golden days. Thank you guys.
and 
TL;DR I love MTO, you guys are awesome, other forums suck!
-
An oasis indeed. For some reason MTO keeps attracting some of the very best people from all around the world

-
I tried many years ago to join but like Grant I only had a Hotmail account which they did not accept - their loss :D
-
We tried the Karma system for a short while here as well, but it didn't last long. It just served to upset people over what I really felt was nothing. Guys had hundreds of +'s in just a few days, then would obsess over one -. Other guys would just go around and "smite" other people for the fun of it, and in the end it really just seemed kind of stupid.
Anyone who knows me knows I think feedback in general is kind of lame, and this "instant feedback" in Karma just caused rifts as people tried to find out who took a whack at them and tried to "smite" them back.
Good to be rid of it in my book! Guys can find all kinds of things to fight about, we don't need to give them more!
Def
-
I'd never heard of this kind of feedback before I guess it's on some of the forums I belong to but I've never
bothered to really check it out which is just as well. -
My somewhat simple evaluation of Bladeforms, I may have posted there once or twice.
Very knowlegeable people very into using knives. I see the atmosphere as a counter/alternative to certain parts of Knifeforums which has a lot of 'vendors' who don't really appreciate you speaking your mind unless you're praising them.
So I think they serve a good purpose and are a nice alternative for some.
I'm more into multitools and we have MT.O, so no time to visit there.
-
After getting my account banned* at BF, I'm quite glad for this little corner of sanity...
*I did it on purpose
-
I have dealt with the Karma system, on a skiing forum (newschoolers.com). It just ends up exactly as Def described. Everyone is begging for + and use - to mark anyone they don't agree with. I don't have a ton of experience on BladeForums, but I am registered there in case I wanted to read any of the threads there. They seem... so strict. :-\
-
Well this is funny. Either marcinek loves google himself or somebody here ratted me out, but my account at knifeforum just got banned in the past few days, for the same BS charge he gave me 7 months ago, and I didn't even post anything since.
-
I primarily hang out in the "Traditional Folders and Fixed Blades" forum with the folksy folks which are a pretty good bunch. I try and stay out of the dark places.
-
@jzmtl said:
Well this is funny. Either marcinek loves google himself or somebody here ratted me out, but my account at knifeforum just got banned in the past few days, for the same BS charge he gave me 7 months ago, and I didn't even post anything since.I haven't talked to him in months, I only go to SOSAK there now (not much need for more blades now)
maybe he just luvs you!
:D -
I have found the Maintenance, Tinkering & Embellishment to be a wealth of information on sharpening especially a member named knifenut1013. He has been really friendly and answered many questions I had. He even told a member to call him so he could talk him through a problem he had with a sharpener over the phone. He does amazing work if you haven't seen it.
-
There are thousands of forums across the internet, all conforming to the net norms by being bitchy, egocentric and not talking about pliers with pickle forks on.
MTO rebels against this norm by being .... nice :)
Group hug anyone?

-
@jzmtl said:
Well this is funny. Either marcinek loves google himself or somebody here ratted me out, but my account at knifeforum just got banned in the past few days, for the same BS charge he gave me 7 months ago, and I didn't even post anything since.Software upgrade the day before automatically banned everyone who had a warning/strike at any point in the past. They are still trying to figure out how to fix this and some other issues.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

