Vic 111mm Backside Phillips is PANTS!! (that's bad...)
-
Time to send it to Vic for Warranty.
Never seen such a total faulire. How does the hole in the driver look, I'm thinking it would need to be pretty sharp to cut the rivet. It's true the rivets are not that strong against a sheer force, but maybe the bending of the liner allowed for a greater force to be applied. hmmm.
Send it to vic and let us know what they say.
-
Well,
I have a hardened steel pin that's just over 3mm. I'm going to sand it down to 2.5 mm and see if it functions better. The liner could still strip out, but we'll see.
If I send it in, I'll just get the same weak pins back, so I figure I'll try this first.
To be honest, if this doesn't work, I'll be abandoning the 111mm Vic as a serious EDC.
-
Another score in favor of backspring corkscrews :D
-
@thebullfrog said:
Another score in favor of backspring corkscrews :DLol!
@ Mr W - good point. Good luck with the beefing up. (I'm still surprised though)!
-
Just because you can use it as a t-handle doesn't mean you should. :P I've broke hardened steel parts with the amount of torque a handle can provide, the brass/aluminum construction just isn't made to be that strong.
-
Ouch!

-
Wow that was a new one. I'm surprised you could apply that much torque, had to fit the screw perfectly - the corkscrew replacement phillips driver is notorious for being too large to be useful for most things
-
Now that is surprising :o
Mind you, you did generate a hell of a lot of torque :-\
-
That is truly a first!! :-\
-
Yup, that's a first for me too. I think you've got strong hands Nate. :-\
-
Ouch! I'm another who's never seen that before and I've seen a lot of damaged SAKs. I'd send it back to Vic. anyway and have a nice new one to modify if that's your plan.
-
This is my OH Locksmith. Don't think I'll get a warranty repair on this one... :-\
-
I rarely use SAK phillips, so I've nothing to say on that part of it.
If it weren't for the custom jobby, I'd give Vic at least one chance at warranty before avoiding the whole 111mm line.
What I did notice as I was checking my 111mms for comparison.
The outer liner on my Three layer 111mms (OHT & Helmsman) is slightly thicker than the one on my two Layer 111mm.
I also noticed that the Inner liner on my OHT and (Dutch?) Army knife is steel, while the centre liner on my Helmsman is alloy. (I imagine that has something to do with the OHT and Army knife being Liner locking, while the Helmsman is Packlock)
Just some possible variables that might contribute to that sort of failure.
-
All backspring Phillips are only good for one thing , fistloads . as drivers they fail !
Chris
-
Well,
Looking at this rigorously,
If the Phillips head is normal to the plane of the screw/bolt, and force is applied normal to the handle surface we can figure out the torque. I figure maybe 60 lbs (260 newtons) of force applied, 1/2 to each end of the handle gives a torque of:
2(0.045m X 130N)= 11.7 Nm torque
From a website giving assembly specs for steel bolts,
a #4 grade 5 steel bolt (diameter of 2.8 mm, that's 10% bigger than the diameter of the 2.5 mm brass pin), dry assembly torque is 2 Nm
This was 6 times the assembly torque!
Oh, and this little bit from a site regarding bolts and materials
Brass
Brass is an alloy of primarily copper and zinc. Brass is highly corrosion resistant and electrically conductive. However, its use as a fastener is somewhat limited due to its relative softness. It is used primarily for its appearance.I think it is safe to say that the backside Phillips is under-engineered. Even if the outer liner was as stiff as a regular backspring, I suspect the brass would begin to stretch, fatigue and eventually fail, given the arrangement in the tool.
I'll replace the pin, but I don't hold much hope for this as a goto farm tool... :-\
-
wow Mr. Whippy! very interesting and thanks for that. (and sorry it broke on you)
I do not like the back philips but so many of my country-people (usa) like it.
Mainly because we are not a big wine drinking country and idea of a philips
instead of a corkscrew appeals to so many here (just my opinion) ::)In my case, for me when I first started getting into SAKs I wanted philips and
not the corkscrew, even the backspring one.(scene from 2010) "I didn't know...I didn't know!"
How inconvenient it was and impractical, and you have just increased that notion!but I have learned, from the smart people here and at SOSAK! ty sir

-
Update: Repaired.
A few pictures:
The sheared brass pin:

Both pieces of sheared off brass pin. New hardened steel pin in place:

The repaired liner. The steel pin donor next to it. Scales back on:

Beauty shot of the tool with Donors and Deceased. :)

-
I'll stick to a corkscrew. If the screw is that hard to get out, I'd rather just skip the whole thing and drink wine until someone arrives with a proper driver.
-
Which reminds me...
Hey Victorinox! Can we get a nice inline Phillips of a decent size? Not the Outrider type, I mean something more substantial. And go ahead and couple it with a magnifier while you are at it. I imagine a 111 Scientist or Yeoman would sell like ice water at a curry shop.
Can I get an amen?
-
Good to see it back up and running Nate! :)
(amen)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login