AL or ALX?
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
AL, Hands down. Although, I don't actually have an AL, but I do have a Ti and an SLV, which are the same tool complement, only dressed differently. I don't much care for the ALX/XTi for the most part because of the screwdriver duplication and lack of scissors. Some folks however like the extra screwdriver bits being available, but it is not for me.Def
How have the handles held up on your SLV?
-
I bought it second hand and fed it to some alligators in addition to the regular usage I have put it through, and to be honest, it's my favorite Charge model. It has a few scratches and dings, but nothing serious- it's not obvious when a gray coating on a gray tool gets chipped, as opposed to a black coating on a gray tool.
Here's my personal breakdown on the Charge models- I'm certain some folks will probably disagree with me, but then, that's what a forum is all about! :P
Ti- original, now discontinued model. It is my favorite, but since it's now discontinued I won't carry it since it can't be replaced if something goes wrong
XTi- original, now discontinued model. I don't like unnecessary duplication on tools, plus it's discontinued so I won't carry it for the above reasons
ALX- current version of the XTi, although with aluminum scales instead of titanium. I don't care for it for the same reason I don't care for the XTi and don't carry it
AL- current version of the Ti, although with aluminum instead of titanium. I would carry this model if I had one
TTi- current, fancy version of the Ti that is too p[painfully overpriced to carry or use in my opinion. I'm sure it's a nice tool, but that's too much money to hang over the side of a boat or clean out gunky plumbing with.
SLV- like the AL, only with gray handles instead of black, and was initially only available through Costco. You can buy them in a number of places now, so I think the Costco exclusive is over. Between this and an AL, I would probably opt for the AL simply because it is even more readily available.So, in short, I carry my SLV because it's already chipped up (although not easily noticed) and because I have one. If my SLV was prettier and/or I had an AL, I'd probably carry it instead.
Def
-
Depends on application. For general use, I would prefer the AL as it has scissors.
I would take the ALX if I was for example using a torx driver a lot. I could keep the normal screwdriver bit in one holder and the torx in the other.
-
That about sums is up Grant, much like I see it.
One thing left out, and not sure how important this could be, the ALX and TTI have the V Cutter on the back of the serrated blade.
-
I looked both the AL, and ALX over and chose the a ALX because I also like the "two" bit system. I don't want a downrigger ball on my hip so I shelved the bit kit, and go with a flathead, and phillips in the other side. My way of thinking is there isn't much I can do with small scissors on any tool, so I didn't consider it a loss. With the main blade of the tool, and the serrated blade, coupled with that very convenient guthook, which works better and faster than scissors, I think it to be quite the tool. ;)
-
Totally disagree.
ALX > AL
Guthook is hugely helpful for cutting baling twine and cutting electric cable ties.
Two bit drivers means I can have a combo Phillips/standard driver in one and a 4mm/5mm allen in the other. (The two most used bits in my set). No extra cards, no free floating bits in a pocket. Scissors? Who needs 'em? :D
-
I have two ALX's, one of which i've done a lot of work with, the other just for back up, but I bought both off the the forums for cheap. I would really miss that gut hook if I switched to an AL. My Charge TTI has the hook too and it's one of the few things I miss on my Swiss made tools. Great for strings, twine, zip ties and just all sorts of stuff. This last week I used the hook to slice my large worn-out solar pool cover up for easier disposal. The Wave is a cheaper tool so I can live without the guthook, but when it comes to the more expensive tools of the Charge series, I kinda expect a guthook or I feel like I'm getting shorted. I can live without scissors, most of my Swisstools and Spirits are the scissorless kind, so I'm used to it. I just carry my S4 if I think I'll really need them on a given day.
-
I find the ALX to be the most perfect multitool ever made. Since the bit-drivers are so thin and compact, I actually don't consider it "tool duplication", but instead, a useful feature. To the contrary: since I carry a Style CS or PS4, I consider the scissors on all the 'other' charge models to be "tool duplication". Before I ever actually had an ALX, I used to knock the aluminum scales but now that I have one I find the scales to be great. The main blade steel is my #1 preference - 154cm - and the gut hook is very useful. Believe it or not, I've even found some uses for the tiny bit driver, though I'm still on the fence whether that should be an awl or not. The only thing on it I don't use are the cap crimper and the can opener but I suppose those are useful for military folks. Come to think of it, to take a page from Victorinox, I'd like to see a chisel instead of a can opener. All that said, I fear at some point the ALX may get the AX from LM for Grant's "tool duplication" because I can see how the two bit drivers might negatively affect its sales...ironically.
-
I have the sneaking suspicion that the folks at Leatherman look at the things I say and do the exact opposite! :D
Def
-
Not so sure. The scissors are what I need more then another bit driver. But to each their own. :D
-
Between the AL and the ALX I would have to choose the AL, I don't care for the redundant bit drivers at all. I don't use the Charge scissors often but I like having them.
That having been said I would forgo them both and go with the TTi.
The TTi offers the following compelling reasons to won over both of them:
- The titanium scales offer a measure of comfort over the aluminum. They just feel better in the hand. The AL felt almost abrasive to the touch.
- The TTi also seems to be less prone to wear than the AL aluminum scales. The TTi I daily carry and use often looks nearly new.
- The TTi (as has been mentioned in this thread) has the line cutter (guthook) which is a very handy feature, I think most people who haven't used it would find it indispensable if they did.
-
The difference between the titanium and aluminum is basically the finishes, and has nothing to do with the metal used. The AL/ALX seem abrasive because of the hard anodize coat on them, while the Ti/XTi/TTi are natural. This is also why it looks like it holds up better- no finish= no finish to wear off.
Frankly, I think the titanium on the Charge is one of the biggest snow jobs Leatherman has ever pulled on people, but I've gone into that in detail in the past and there's no point in repeating it here.
Def
-
That's it get him started ::) :D
-
In a nutshell:
Titanium's benefits include increased corrosion resistance, magnetic neutrality, weight reduction and superior strength. It's a thin slab stuck to the side of a steel tool, covering a small area, and it's not in a structural position. Therefore, it's really not providing any of the real benefits listed above, so why use it? Simple- people will buy it because it's titanium which is sleek and sexy.
Then, take the original Charge models- the Ti and XTi- and realize that they were initially released with an MSRP of $100. Then, a couple of years later, they are discontinued and replaced by aluminum versions at the same price point of $100, and the "new" titanium model now has an MSRP of $150. So, in short, the titanium doesn't give any tangible benefits, and yet they can charge more for it and people keep buying them because it's titanium.
Titanium isn't that much more expensive than aluminum- I know, I have been watching titanium prices for our future Multitool.org Charge project. While there is a higher cost on titanium over aluminum, it's not enough to justify another $50/unit, and the difference between the modern price of titanium and titanium from five years ago also doesn't justify a 50% increase in price.
Of course this isn't a shot against Leatherman per se. They are following in the footsteps of the knife industry and offering "super steels" along with fancy materials like titanium and carbon fiber just like everyone else, and it's working.
Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
The difference between the titanium and aluminum is basically the finishes, and has nothing to do with the metal used. The AL/ALX seem abrasive because of the hard anodize coat on them, while the Ti/XTi/TTi are natural. This is also why it looks like it holds up better- no finish= no finish to wear off.Frankly, I think the titanium on the Charge is one of the biggest snow jobs Leatherman has ever pulled on people, but I've gone into that in detail in the past and there's no point in repeating it here.
Def
I've never bought into any real world benefit of the titanium over the stainless of the New Wave. I do feel the titanium is superior to the aluminum though, for the reasons I mentioned. The anodizing does give the aluminum scales a rough texture which admittedly most people would not notice unless they handled both at the same time to compare.
For me the allure of the TTi has always been the line cutter/guthook blade, and the upgraded S30V steel. The choice of using titanium for the scales has always been a marketing gimmick to me, but the titanium scale material is superior from a comfort standpoint as opposed to even the stainless scales of the wave. Unless of course you sand down the rough edges on the wave.
-
I'm not embarassed to admit that being a tart, I dig the Ti for being Ti.

-
Grant, your points about Titanium seem valid but I don't think LM is trying to "snow" anyone with Ti. Although I'm completely happy with aluminum, I also like the Ti for aesthetic purposes and would be willing to pay the extra price for it if I wanted another one. I wonder if G10 would have been an even cheaper material for the slabs - and how well it would hold up on a Charge

-
Crouton- I wasn't trying to imply that you were Benner-like.... just spelling it out for people. If you like attributes of the TTi like the guthook and the finish (or lack thereof) then power to you, and enjoy it- it's still a fine tool.
Leatherman markets the titanium tools like they were somehow better than the aluminum tools, and that somehow the titanium is beneficial, when in reality it's not. You like the tools and the feel, which are both very valid. If the AL/ALX were anodized naturally instead of the hard anodize, I imagine many folks would still buy the Ti, and claim they could tell the difference....
And according to the Comparative Weight Chart the difference in weight between the aluminum and titanium models is negligible.
ALX: 236g or 8.33oz
XTi: 233g or 8.22oz1/10 of an ounce or 6 grams... I'll bet that the weight difference of not shaving for two days is more than 3g!
Def
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login




