AL or ALX?
-
Not so sure. The scissors are what I need more then another bit driver. But to each their own. :D
-
Between the AL and the ALX I would have to choose the AL, I don't care for the redundant bit drivers at all. I don't use the Charge scissors often but I like having them.
That having been said I would forgo them both and go with the TTi.
The TTi offers the following compelling reasons to won over both of them:
- The titanium scales offer a measure of comfort over the aluminum. They just feel better in the hand. The AL felt almost abrasive to the touch.
- The TTi also seems to be less prone to wear than the AL aluminum scales. The TTi I daily carry and use often looks nearly new.
- The TTi (as has been mentioned in this thread) has the line cutter (guthook) which is a very handy feature, I think most people who haven't used it would find it indispensable if they did.
-
The difference between the titanium and aluminum is basically the finishes, and has nothing to do with the metal used. The AL/ALX seem abrasive because of the hard anodize coat on them, while the Ti/XTi/TTi are natural. This is also why it looks like it holds up better- no finish= no finish to wear off.
Frankly, I think the titanium on the Charge is one of the biggest snow jobs Leatherman has ever pulled on people, but I've gone into that in detail in the past and there's no point in repeating it here.
Def
-
That's it get him started ::) :D
-
In a nutshell:
Titanium's benefits include increased corrosion resistance, magnetic neutrality, weight reduction and superior strength. It's a thin slab stuck to the side of a steel tool, covering a small area, and it's not in a structural position. Therefore, it's really not providing any of the real benefits listed above, so why use it? Simple- people will buy it because it's titanium which is sleek and sexy.
Then, take the original Charge models- the Ti and XTi- and realize that they were initially released with an MSRP of $100. Then, a couple of years later, they are discontinued and replaced by aluminum versions at the same price point of $100, and the "new" titanium model now has an MSRP of $150. So, in short, the titanium doesn't give any tangible benefits, and yet they can charge more for it and people keep buying them because it's titanium.
Titanium isn't that much more expensive than aluminum- I know, I have been watching titanium prices for our future Multitool.org Charge project. While there is a higher cost on titanium over aluminum, it's not enough to justify another $50/unit, and the difference between the modern price of titanium and titanium from five years ago also doesn't justify a 50% increase in price.
Of course this isn't a shot against Leatherman per se. They are following in the footsteps of the knife industry and offering "super steels" along with fancy materials like titanium and carbon fiber just like everyone else, and it's working.
Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
The difference between the titanium and aluminum is basically the finishes, and has nothing to do with the metal used. The AL/ALX seem abrasive because of the hard anodize coat on them, while the Ti/XTi/TTi are natural. This is also why it looks like it holds up better- no finish= no finish to wear off.Frankly, I think the titanium on the Charge is one of the biggest snow jobs Leatherman has ever pulled on people, but I've gone into that in detail in the past and there's no point in repeating it here.
Def
I've never bought into any real world benefit of the titanium over the stainless of the New Wave. I do feel the titanium is superior to the aluminum though, for the reasons I mentioned. The anodizing does give the aluminum scales a rough texture which admittedly most people would not notice unless they handled both at the same time to compare.
For me the allure of the TTi has always been the line cutter/guthook blade, and the upgraded S30V steel. The choice of using titanium for the scales has always been a marketing gimmick to me, but the titanium scale material is superior from a comfort standpoint as opposed to even the stainless scales of the wave. Unless of course you sand down the rough edges on the wave.
-
I'm not embarassed to admit that being a tart, I dig the Ti for being Ti.

-
Grant, your points about Titanium seem valid but I don't think LM is trying to "snow" anyone with Ti. Although I'm completely happy with aluminum, I also like the Ti for aesthetic purposes and would be willing to pay the extra price for it if I wanted another one. I wonder if G10 would have been an even cheaper material for the slabs - and how well it would hold up on a Charge

-
Crouton- I wasn't trying to imply that you were Benner-like.... just spelling it out for people. If you like attributes of the TTi like the guthook and the finish (or lack thereof) then power to you, and enjoy it- it's still a fine tool.
Leatherman markets the titanium tools like they were somehow better than the aluminum tools, and that somehow the titanium is beneficial, when in reality it's not. You like the tools and the feel, which are both very valid. If the AL/ALX were anodized naturally instead of the hard anodize, I imagine many folks would still buy the Ti, and claim they could tell the difference....
And according to the Comparative Weight Chart the difference in weight between the aluminum and titanium models is negligible.
ALX: 236g or 8.33oz
XTi: 233g or 8.22oz1/10 of an ounce or 6 grams... I'll bet that the weight difference of not shaving for two days is more than 3g!
Def
-
I agree with Grant that the use of Ti as a scale material was a marketing "snow job" and I also believe that the choice of that material or the implementation of that scale material has caused a quality control issue. See my post from Feb 09 regarding the quality of the scale casting /post/167561 Most of my Ti Charges have some irregularity in the titanium scale material.
I do however believe that when coupled with the titanium scale material, the addition of the guthook/line cutter, the S30V blade and to a much lesser extent, the cap crimper, Leatherman attempted to create a "premium" tool and increased the price for it. The extras make the tool a better daily carry option for me, and thus I can justify the increased price because there simply is no better option for me.
One other potential benefit to the Ti is that due to it's wow factor the titanium Charges tend to hold their value better and have significantly higher resell values. Especially here on mt.org :)
-
I was one of the absolute worst critics of the AL slabs until I got my very own Charge ALX, but now I like the T6 just as well. Didn't people used to pretty much have the same thoughts towards Zytel vs G10 in the past with knives etc?
-
I'm not suggesting that anyone not buy a TTi, just like I'm not insinuating that anyone is an innocent dupe for owning one. I just think that if you want one, you should know about it and make up your mind on what it can do rather than some smoke and mirrors.
For example, a Ferrari is a nice car, and well worth the money, but probably not the best for a morning commute across town, picking up groceries or hauling the kids to hockey practice. It is still a nice car, and does what it does, and no one buys it thinking any different. That's how I think people should buy a titanium tool- they know what it is, what it does, and don't mind spending the extra money, then power to them.
My problem is with folks being lead to believe that the titanium somehow makes it perform better somehow.
Def
-
I've always liked the look of the TTi. That coupled with the s30v main blade makes it attractive to me.
I have to say though in my opinion it's the nicest looking multi out there. I love the finish they've given
it. I've really got to grab one for my collection of users.
-
I've only owned LMs for about 4 years and seriously began looking at this site for about 2. I just acquired two charges with in the past month after being completely happy with just my wave and skeletool. I don't know if its just my anal research I do when buying something(electronic/tools/etc), but one of the first things I read here and on other sites is that the TI was used purely on the scales. The implements in side were of the same steel as the wave.
When you say:
@Grant Lamontagne said:
My problem is with folks being lead to believe that the titanium somehow makes it perform better somehow.Was it something that happened when the the Ti and Xti first came out? or was it something that you noticed with the new Al/ALX vs the TTi? Do you believe it was LMs marketing or just people being misinformed about where the titanium was being used?
-
Alx for me I like 2 bit drivers, however I'm not keen on the scales mine are dented etc thanks to aluminum being aluminium lol
-
You can't really fault the Leatherman marketing machine for doing their job and extolling whatever potential virtues they might see. However, when you look at the current product page for the TTi you find the following blurb
"When we made the Leatherman Charge TTi, we knew the Charge AL and ALX were just too hard to beat, so we didn't even try. Instead we simply combined them. But we had to give the TTi its own claim to fame, so in addition to all the other Charge features, we gave the TTi premium comfort-sculpted titanium handle scales and the S30V® stainless steel clip-point knife. Who says a multi-tool can't be sexy?"
That's not over the top nor is it unrealistic.
The majority of the puffery regarding titanium and it's properties has been done here on the forum. Me I could care less about the titanium on the Charge except for it's comfort, and I would love to see a Xytel insert version of the Charge like the Blast.
Oh and I just thought of another compelling reason to own a TTi over an AL or ALX.......wait for it.......those darned knurled screws on the AL/ALX that I don't have a wrench for.
-
I agree

-
Question for you guys, i just got the ALX 2 days ago and i used the precision screwdriver today for the first time. on the second screw i was backing out it broke!
Does anyone know where i can get a replacement?
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



