Every Day Carrier?
-
With engines in it, it'd make one hell of a house boat - even with enough deck surface to have a sizable garden and parking space for a couple vehicles.
Hmm, getting a hot tub into the thing, though, would be difficult with the narrow corridors.

And yes, I'm kidding, though only partially. :D
-
-
I'd love to know the price and who would want it?

-
scrap metal...
-
I would have thought you would approve of it being scrapped? That means it'll likely be recycled, which is something a tree hugger should appreciate!
Def
-
I got a great idea. Let's all pitch in and buy it. Then we all can become pirates or specifically an army of pirates, because that is about how many people it will take to manage that ship. Yo ho ho and a bottle of rum

-
Our own little MT.O community. We could be like Paul Watson except that we ram and sink boats with crappy China made MT and Knifes instead of Japanese whalers
-
-
Have the new carriers they were planning come into service then? I thought they were a few years out yet...
-
they are...
-
-
@CQC-7 said:
I got a great idea. Let's all pitch in and buy it. Then we all can become pirates or specifically an army of pirates, because that is about how many people it will take to manage that ship. Yo ho ho and a bottle of rum
Lets do it :ahhh
@Grant Lamontagne said:
I got a great idea. Let's all pitch in and buy it. Then we all can become pirates or specifically an army of pirates, because that is about how many people it will take to manage that ship. Yo ho ho and a bottle of rum

Who's gonna row? As the Captain, I say not me... :D
Def
Captain Dunc at your service Sir

-
@rp252 said:
Have the new carriers they were planning come into service then? I thought they were a few years out yet...And don't forget that the two currently/about to be in service don't have aircraft to carry, since the decommissioning of the F-15 (I think it is), and the carriers' lack of bloody catapults. One of the two will be sold off next year, too, and the other is so far underway that it'd cost more to scrap it now, than it would to see it through to completion.
Who designs a modern aircraft carrier without catapults? Yes, STOL and VTOL aircraft exist, but why hamper yourself that much?

-
Increased range of aircraft coupled with mid air refueling and the number of bases, either your own or allied makes a mobile air base almost obsolete nowadays.
Def
-
While true, Grant, it's also a morale effect, too, though. Nothing says, "prepare for hurt" as a carrier group arriving on scene. Granted, should a carrier group go down, well, it'd be the same reaction as in The Sum of All Fears. :-\
On that note, has the US ever lost a carrier since WWII?
-
Probably not, but I don't think there have been any US carriers involved in any significant naval battles since WWII either, so it's hard to say whether that has any significance or not.
A carrier may be intimidating, but it's an awful lot of eggs in one basket, and with very little of it's own actual defensive capabilities, it is either very costly (running a defensive perimeter with submarines, frigates and air cover) to run, or it's a sitting duck. Lots of surface area to bomb or torpedo, not terribly maneuverable or fast, so little chance of it evading an attack, and not much (if anything) in the way of armaments.
To think you could reduce the expenditures significantly by establishing a beach head with longer range aircraft, paratroopers and some transports (air and naval), along with some prefab buildings, and you wonder why carriers are even still in use at all.
Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Probably not, but I don't think there have been any US carriers involved in any significant naval battles since WWII either, so it's hard to say whether that has any significance or not.A carrier may be intimidating, but it's an awful lot of eggs in one basket, and with very little of it's own actual defensive capabilities, it is either very costly (running a defensive perimeter with submarines, frigates and air cover) to run, or it's a sitting duck. Lots of surface area to bomb or torpedo, not terribly maneuverable or fast, so little chance of it evading an attack, and not much (if anything) in the way of armaments.
To think you could reduce the expenditures significantly by establishing a beach head with longer range aircraft, paratroopers and some transports (air and naval), along with some prefab buildings, and you wonder why carriers are even still in use at all.
Def
I don't disagree with you whatsoever that even with proper carrier group defense nets, carriers are still sitting ducks with the ship having over 6,000 crewmembers, plus costing in the high millions to billions in funds. With that said, with the US decreasing the number of bases worldwide, even with longer-range aircraft, the aircraft carrier - at least for the US - is still a necessity; for how long that remains is yet to be seen, though. Personally, I hate that the battleships were decommissioned, even though modern weaponry made it obsolete.* Still, the A-10 Warthog is effectively a flying gun with no modern replacement in sight for it's combat role, so YMMV.
- I would say that this point is a bit iffy, in regards to electromagnetic countermeasures; can't really do much to screw up trajectories of shells, compared to smart missiles, for instance.
-
Yes, the US, and many other countries are downsizing military concerns and closing bases, but that is because of the longer ranges of equipment, and increasing numbers of allies thanks to things like the UN.
While carriers may not be obsolete, they are expensive and their role is shrinking.
Def
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login







