Tool Quality Question
-
This is just my initial thoughts, I may add to this later.
First off:
- Finish. By this, I don't mean shiny-ness. Leatherman Charges/Waves, don't have a shiny smooth surface and I consider them high quality. In fact, I prefer their finish to the Vic Spirit because the smooth shiny Spirit is slippery as all get out when it gets oil or grease on it.
However, the finish should be even, and without rough areas.
-
Fit. Parts should match up reliably from tool to tool (ie consistency). Blades should be flat (not bowed) and locking tools should lock up cleanly with no wobble. IMO, the Charge TTi file rub is an issue of quality. My ALX doesn't rub, but I've seen it on Titanium scaled tools. That shouldn't happen.
-
Tool quality: Scissors should function like fine quality scissors or be left out--like the scissors on Vic 91mm SAKs, the LM Micra and Surge. Awls should work out of the box--again like Vic 91 mm and Alox awls, not like the LM Juice awl. Tools need to be made from quality material and be designed to work. That's my major complaint about SOG powerpliers. The tools are fairly bendy. I don't need that when I'm working on something. Nail nicks should work well. OHO tools should be actually OHO.
-
Tool layout. The tools should be arranged so that they work optimally. I've seen tools where the can opener was placed in such a way that it was a total PITA to use it for opening cans. Same goes for knife blades that are placed to interfere with use. I don't want to pick on SOG, but the piano covers are a pain to work around. Removing them makes the tool much less comfortable.
-
Warranty. These tend to be fairly expensive. when something breaks, I don't want a big hassle about getting it fixed.
That's it for now. I'll probably have more later. :D
-
Do the implements actually work , do they continue to do so . Is fit and finish good , is it well thought out .
The list is endless and will vary from addict to addict . Kinda like how many Oxycontin tabs you like to take each day , an who runs the best Meth lab !
Chris
-
I agree with what has been said. Is the phillips ground well, is the knife ground well also, is there play in the pliers or tools (wiggle)
-
I like a nice tight tool with implements that work well. Nothing worse than having a can opener that doesn't open cans, or an awl that isn't sharp.
-
My impressions of quality begin the moment I lay eyes on a tool. Even in a store, hanging on a rack, still in the blister pack, I'm evaluating it's quality. Is there plastic used in the construction? I'd rather there wasn't. Are the handles cast metal, or stamped? They'd better be stamped. Do the individual tools appear useful and well-formed, or are they just "filler" meant to give the appearance of adding more functions. Polished or sanded metal finishes imply attention to detail to me. Bead blast metal finishes imply just the opposite. The plier head itself should have crisp edges all around, inside the jaws and out, not rough inconsistent bevels that look like they were done by hand on a snag grinder.
All of these are quality cues I try to notice before even handling a tool.
-
@J-sews said:
My impressions of quality begin the moment I lay eyes on a tool. Even in a store, hanging on a rack, still in the blister pack, I'm evaluating it's quality. Is there plastic used in the construction? I'd rather there wasn't. Are the handles cast metal, or stamped? They'd better be stamped. Do the individual tools appear useful and well-formed, or are they just "filler" meant to give the appearance of adding more functions. Polished or sanded metal finishes imply attention to detail to me. Bead blast metal finishes imply just the opposite. The plier head itself should have crisp edges all around, inside the jaws and out, not rough inconsistent bevels that look like they were done by hand on a snag grinder.All of these are quality cues I try to notice before even handling a tool.
Seems like a waste of time in your case since your gonna buy at least one of everything anyway. Good or bad quality :D
-
My impressions of quality begin the moment I lay eyes on a tool. Even in a store, hanging on a rack, still in the blister pack, I'm evaluating it's quality. Is there plastic used in the construction? I'd rather there wasn't. Are the handles cast metal, or stamped? They'd better be stamped. Do the individual tools appear useful and well-formed, or are they just "filler" meant to give the appearance of adding more functions. Polished or sanded metal finishes imply attention to detail to me. Bead blast metal finishes imply just the opposite. The plier head itself should have crisp edges all around, inside the jaws and out, not rough inconsistent bevels that look like they were done by hand on a snag grinder.
All of these are quality cues I try to notice before even handling a tool.
Seems like a waste of time in your case since your gonna buy at least one of everything anyway. Good or bad quality :D
Oi!

:D
How will I know the good ones if I don't have the bad ones to compare them too? :D :D
-
I naturally agree with all of the above.

May I also add, to a lesser extent of course, the relation of the purchase cost to the perception of quality.I am annoyed by a minute rubbing on the cutting bit of my swisstool pliers (which could be necessary for good cutting performance, for all I know) and I don’t really care about the 2mm+ misalignment in the handles of the Bahco multitools I have (at least it is the same in both of them, so they have good consistency here), or the 1mm misalignment on the pliers head of one of them.
Talking of consistency, most multitools are able to get the blades they have reasonably right, that is, they are reasonably sharp, cut when needed, appear strong enough for the occasional use. However, better quality multitools get other things right too, a typical example that was mentioned many times by others is the Philips driver design (that is, they actually should fit Philips screws). Also files that actually can file something, scissors that work etc.
Also a good “solid” feel (read heavy), good “snap”, good feel of materials (G10 feels, to me, better than FRN, though, funnily enough, I am quite happy with the Victorinox plastic scales…), strength proportional to the size of the multitool, good finish, no ratling etc.
-
@dks said:
I naturally agree with all of the above.
May I also add, to a lesser extent of course, the relation of the purchase cost to the perception of quality.I am annoyed by a minute rubbing on the cutting bit of my swisstool pliers (which could be necessary for good cutting performance, for all I know) and I don’t really care about the 2mm+ misalignment in the handles of the Bahco multitools I have (at least it is the same in both of them, so they have good consistency here), or the 1mm misalignment on the pliers head of one of them.
Talking of consistency, most multitools are able to get the blades they have reasonably right, that is, they are reasonably sharp, cut when needed, appear strong enough for the occasional use. However, better quality multitools get other things right too, a typical example that was mentioned many times by others is the Philips driver design (that is, they actually should fit Philips screws). Also files that actually can file something, scissors that work etc.
Also a good “solid” feel (read heavy), good “snap”, good feel of materials (G10 feels, to me, better than FRN, though, funnily enough, I am quite happy with the Victorinox plastic scales…), strength proportional to the size of the multitool, good finish, no ratling etc.
I love the snap of Vic knives. That's one thing that bugs me about my LM's, the only models that really snap are the Juices, and they don't snap much. BUT, my steadfast companion for awhile now is the LM Pulse, with no end in sight. (kinda taking a liking to my new gerber mp450, but it is my around the house tool)
-
@Mercury said:
I love the snap of Vic knives. That's one thing that bugs me about my LM's, the only models that really snap are the Juices, and they don't snap much. BUT, my steadfast companion for awhile now is the LM Pulse, with no end in sight. (kinda taking a liking to my new gerber mp450, but it is my around the house tool)+1!
I think Victorinox multitools are on top-drawer when it comes to quality (fit & finish, consistency, snap or "walk and talk", as mentioned above). However, if you were to ask me to empty my pockets, 90% of the time you would have an LM Pulse laid out in front of you. The original LM frame design (PST, Pulse, ST200, etc.) was a quality product without being overcomplicated and overburdened with weight, unlike many of the more modern designs. I guess what I'm getting at is that I think quality can manifest itself in the efficiency of the overall design--it isn't always a tangible characteristic.
-
I love the snap of Vic knives. That's one thing that bugs me about my LM's, the only models that really snap are the Juices, and they don't snap much. BUT, my steadfast companion for awhile now is the LM Pulse, with no end in sight. (kinda taking a liking to my new gerber mp450, but it is my around the house tool)
+1!
I think Victorinox multitools are on top-drawer when it comes to quality (fit & finish, consistency, snap or "walk and talk", as mentioned above). However, if you were to ask me to empty my pockets, 90% of the time you would have an LM Pulse laid out in front of you. **The original LM frame design (PST, Pulse, ST200, etc.) was a quality product without being overcomplicated and overburdened with weight, **unlike many of the more modern designs. I guess what I'm getting at is that I think quality can manifest itself in the efficiency of the overall design--it isn't always a tangible characteristic.
Totally agree with this. (Well except that I didn't like the ST200 locks). In fact, I sorta shelved my original Wave, preferring the PST. The PST was compact, light and extremely functional. It didn't move out of EDC until I picked up a Skeletool.
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
I love the snap of Vic knives. That's one thing that bugs me about my LM's, the only models that really snap are the Juices, and they don't snap much. BUT, my steadfast companion for awhile now is the LM Pulse, with no end in sight. (kinda taking a liking to my new gerber mp450, but it is my around the house tool)
+1!
I think Victorinox multitools are on top-drawer when it comes to quality (fit & finish, consistency, snap or "walk and talk", as mentioned above). However, if you were to ask me to empty my pockets, 90% of the time you would have an LM Pulse laid out in front of you. **The original LM frame design (PST, Pulse, ST200, etc.) was a quality product without being overcomplicated and overburdened with weight, **unlike many of the more modern designs. I guess what I'm getting at is that I think quality can manifest itself in the efficiency of the overall design--it isn't always a tangible characteristic.
Totally agree with this. (Well except that I didn't like the ST200 locks). In fact, I sorta shelved my original Wave, preferring the PST. The PST was compact, light and extremely functional. It didn't move out of EDC until I picked up a Skeletool.
The PST is a wonderful tool, and I (rarely) edc it sometimes. The pulse is what I consider to be a perfected PST, and since buying the pulse, I have not had the desire to swap it out for something else as far as EDC goes.
-
On the question as to what quality is my thoughts are pretty simple; can it do the job it was designed to do? Is it well enough built to last a long time doing that job?
Within those two questions are many little decisions to be made; how comfortable is it, will it rust away, can I get the components out, will it actually turn a Phillips screw etc etc. But really it's covered by the two basic questions.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login