Vic Deluxe Tinker vs LM Juice CS4
-
Nice review. I caught something interesting, about you favoring the Wenger can opener design over the Vic design. This is interesting, since I have read about a lot of people who find the Vic setup to be the best. I have used my Vic can openers and though they work very well, I usually just break out a Swing-A-Way! I need to put my Wenger can opener to the test today, to see how it compares. I actually like the Wenger can opener design as it sort of works as a rough blade for random tearing/cutting duty. If I am going to cut open a tapped box, I always use the Wenger can opener, so as not to gunk up and dull my main blade. I actually started using the awl's on my Vics for this same purpose. Considering how useless the medium screwdriver is on that same tool, you may have a point of Vic just ditching that tool. Hell why not skip them both and use the combo-tool. I find that tools bottle opener is superior to the standard bottle opener, and the screwdriver works comparable to the large screwdriver. The only loss would be the can opener function. Since I rarely need it, I would be fine.
-
@Aloxfan said:
Nice review. I caught something interesting, about you favoring the Wenger can opener design over the Vic design. This is interesting, since I have read about a lot of people who find the Vic setup to be the best. I have used my Vic can openers and though they work very well, I usually just break out a Swing-A-Way! I need to put my Wenger can opener to the test today, to see how it compares. I actually like the Wenger can opener design as it sort of works as a rough blade for random tearing/cutting duty. If I am going to cut open a tapped box, I always use the Wenger can opener, so as not to gunk up and dull my main blade. I actually started using the awl's on my Vics for this same purpose. Considering how useless the medium screwdriver is on that same tool, you may have a point of Vic just ditching that tool. Hell why not skip them both and use the combo-tool. I find that tools bottle opener is superior to the standard bottle opener, and the screwdriver works comparable to the large screwdriver. The only loss would be the can opener function. Since I rarely need it, I would be fine.Cheers mate

I'm with you on the "scoring" potential of the wenger style, and as for pitching one opener against another, it was interesting to see the LM making a neater job (once the Vic had got it started). Another member did a head to head between three openers recently, and the Vic came first, and the Wenger last ... maybe style / technique come into it
To me the Wenger just looks and feels like a can opener should, plus has the ability to score through tape and be a general purpose pokey thing. While I've not timed myself with the two different brands - I'm pretty sure I'd do just as well with the Wenger ... based on my pics in this thread I couldn't do much worse with the Vic :DI've not tried the combo tool to be honest (only discovered there is one earlier today :-[), but I certainly want to try one out. Bottle opening is far more frequent than can opening (for me anyway), and I'm surprised we don't see more of the combi
-
@50ft-trad said:
OK, a good sleep and a couple of fried egg butties later, and I've decided to email LM for their comments.I'm not prepared to start spending further cash on P&P etc to risk being further disappointed until I've heard what they have to say for themselves and their products. I am going to point out that I actually want to like, trust, and be inspired by their products. I'm going to tell them how the Juice line in my opinion could have been the epitome of pocket tools. I'm also going to be clear and level headed about my feelings with what I have actually experienced so far.
I'll keep you guys informed

Hi, I'm in the market for a Juice CS4 and the follow up posts you made really bug me. I read your review a wile ago on that "other forum" but the problem with the scissors is a big one for me. Did you get any reply from Leatherman. They always did right by me.
As for Vic or Wenger buying of Leatherman. I always suspected Leatherman to have some sort of partnership with Wenger. Leatherman uses some of Wengers designs like the spring for the scissors or the can opener (wave, surge,...). Maybe a merger :) I'd prefer the steel of the SAKs on my Leathermans.
-
@50ft-trad said:
OK, a good sleep and a couple of fried egg butties later, and I've decided to email LM for their comments.I'm not prepared to start spending further cash on P&P etc to risk being further disappointed until I've heard what they have to say for themselves and their products. I am going to point out that I actually want to like, trust, and be inspired by their products. I'm going to tell them how the Juice line in my opinion could have been the epitome of pocket tools. I'm also going to be clear and level headed about my feelings with what I have actually experienced so far.
I'll keep you guys informed

Hi, I'm in the market for a Juice CS4 and the follow up posts you made really bug me. I read your review a wile ago on that "other forum" but the problem with the scissors is a big one for me. Did you get any reply from Leatherman. They always did right by me.
As for Vic or Wenger buying of Leatherman. I always suspected Leatherman to have some sort of partnership with Wenger. Leatherman uses some of Wengers designs like the spring for the scissors or the can opener (wave, surge,...). Maybe a merger :) I'd prefer the steel of the SAKs on my Leathermans.
What can I say
- I didnt follow it through :-\I came to the conclusion that manufacturing issues aside, I didn't like the design of some of the tools - so it's pending modification. When I get some free time I'll have a pop at making it how I want it - getting a well made one would only address some of the issues IMHO, so it needs some thought and cross-breeding with other tools. It's a crying shame there aren't more options at this size for pliers based tools.
C'mon Victorinox - there's an opportunity here for ya

-
I was really wanting to buy a Juice too but after reading this im not sure, your review has me worried. It sucks because its just another thing i would really like to get but im not going to be happy with junk quality you can find on chinese made tools. Its just really frustrating when a product is ment to be good quality, made in USA etc and you end up getting bad product. Cant manufacturures understand that 99% of people into multi tools or knives etc just want something good quality and are prepared to pay a little extra $ to get a good product. We dont want to see manufacturing moved off shore or the quality lowered to make the tool 'cheaper'. There was a time when i bought a lot of cheaper tools, torches and things and the damn things just do not last at all and are just rubbish quality. I got sick of it I said enough is enough and after much shopping around i bought a Fluke multi meter valued at $800 AUD (although i sourced it much cheaper in USA) as i wanted something that was good quality and going to last rather than a cheap $25 one. So far i have been nothing but very impressed with all the Victorinox SAKs i have. They are not 100% perfect, but they are very, very good, you can hardly complain. All other manufacturers should take a good hard look at what Victorinox does.
I think you should of complained to Leatherman because otherwise they will think they can just keep selling this sort of quality to people and think 'well no ones complained so far, we must be doing everything alright'
-
It's true that some Juices have these issues, my Xe6 has exactly the same issues with the saw as 50ft had here for example, but it should also be noted that neither of mine have any issues with the scissors. In fact they're both rather good. Certainly it'd be unfair to compare either of them to some junk Chinese MT, they're much better than that.
-
@Cyclone82 said:
I think you should of complained to Leatherman because otherwise they will think they can just keep selling this sort of quality to people and think 'well no ones complained so far, we must be doing everything alright'I suspect for many users, the tool would actually be acceptable. I was expecting quality of Victorinox standard, and far superior design. In my opinion, these fall well short on both counts, but many folks seem happy with their Juices despite a great many having the same weaknesses. My findings are that many of the issues I've highlighted are typical for the Juice line, but people (such as Gareth) still find them go be worthwhile purchases. I like the pliers, i like the size, and i like the external access - however I PERSONALLY find the design and quality of the accompanying tools to be poor. LM's QA dept, and design dept have decided these are fit for market, and many users agree. I'll not complain, I'll just spend my money elsewhere on makers whose products I'm happier with. I'd love have a Juice I am happy with, but do not believe LM can deliver that, so I'll have to try and achieve that myself. However based on how people like these tools despite their issues, I now feel I cannot justify buying any of LM's higher end tools. Yes, other folks rave about them too - but if folks actually like these Juices, then maybe people have different expectations to me - and I'm not going to pay double (or more) market price for a tool which is not two or three times as good as the alternatives. If this is a measure of what LM offer, and most users like them, then good luck to them - but I'll be shopping elsewhere.
-
I understand what you are saying. At least i know what to expect when my PS4 arrives.
So what alternatives do we have other than a LM Juice? as far as i can see there isnt an alternative in that size. You either got smaller to the PS4 or Gerber Clutch/Vise or you go up to the full size 4 inch models.
For me the important bit is the quality of the mechanical side of the tool. Eg no loose, floppy or misaligned tools. Dull paint or lesser quality cosmetic finish is not the number one thing for me and i think it should be manufacturers priority too rather than hide a tools mechanical poor quality with a bright blingy, shiny annodized covering for example. You cant hide whats underneath ;)
-
@Cyclone82 said:
I understand what you are saying. At least i know what to expect when my PS4 arrives.So what alternatives do we have other than a LM Juice? as far as i can see there isnt an alternative in that size. You either got smaller to the PS4 or Gerber Clutch/Vise or you go up to the full size 4 inch models.
For me the important bit is the quality of the mechanical side of the tool. Eg no loose, floppy or misaligned tools. Dull paint or lesser quality cosmetic finish is not the number one thing for me and i think it should be manufacturers priority too rather than hide a tools mechanical poor quality with a bright blingy, shiny annodized covering for example. You cant hide whats underneath ;)
The ps4 is actually well made ( I have the torx version :) ), on par with my skele cx. But I'm not too happy with the wave. Has some rough edges and the spine of the knife isn't finnished properly. I wish LM would use some better stainless steel on their tools like vic does. Maybe vic will make a mini swisstool. :D
-
@Cyclone82 said:
I understand what you are saying. At least i know what to expect when my PS4 arrives.So what alternatives do we have other than a LM Juice? as far as i can see there isnt an alternative in that size. You either got smaller to the PS4 or Gerber Clutch/Vise or you go up to the full size 4 inch models.
For me the important bit is the quality of the mechanical side of the tool. Eg no loose, floppy or misaligned tools. Dull paint or lesser quality cosmetic finish is not the number one thing for me and i think it should be manufacturers priority too rather than hide a tools mechanical poor quality with a bright blingy, shiny annodized covering for example. You cant hide whats underneath ;)
Agreed! Though shiny is very nice too if the tool works as it should :D. My other options for small pliers are just SAK's or Buck Extract (Big tool with small pliers) or it's a leap up to Swisstool & Wengergrip (I consider my Gerber Suspension to be a joke, not a tool). I have got a Squirt P4 in the back of a drawer somewhere but that wasn't made well either >:( The file has bald patches and the knife blades catches the scales when closing (right on the edge) unless you take care to close it.
I don't have great experience with LM products

Aside from (hopefully) fixing up the Juice, I've considered a Vic Spirit ... though heard a few gripes about the scissors not opening very wide. I'd like to hear if this is a big problem for scissor using spirit owners, or if it's just "fussy"

The only other thing I can think of in this size realm is a Minigrip/Pocketgrip ... but they are a little on the odd side. I have got one but not cariied it yet to be fair.
-
This was a good review. Thanks.
-
Great review. I would note though that the 'can opener' probably performs so poorly because it isn't a can opener. Leatherman show it as a bottle opener and 'corkscrew assist', no metal-cutting abilities implied so would probably count as tool-abuse for warrenty purposes:

-
Interesting spot Dave, welcome to the forum.
Leatherman does list the can opener as being part of the tool list on their website so I think we are still in the clear for using it as one. :) -
I tested my Juice S2 as a can opener (unmodified), and it worked, although the initial puncture into the can was tough.
However, a few minutes of work with a file to bevel that cutting edge makes a world of difference, and turns a potentially problematic opener into a decent one.
And yes, the juice is listed as having a can opener. For instance, the Leatherman page on the S2...
http://www.leatherman.com/product/Juice_C2After all the testing I've done on can openers, I still don't have a strong preference. As others have pointed out, the hook-bill style has a lot of general scraping functionality outside of can opening. The Vic style has the smaller driver added, and works as a reasonable phillips driver. As can openers, they're all within a few seconds of each other in performance., and opening cans is becoming less and less important as a function of MTs.
My view of the Juice vs. the Deluxe Tinker... I prefer the Vic blades, and there are two. I vastly prefer the Leatherman Phillips. I never have the nail stabbing problem with flatheads on the Juice that some folks do. The Vic 91mm Scissors beat the Juice scissors by a large margin, and moreso for lefties. The Vic Awl/reamer is loads better than the leatherman. What it really comes down to is pliers. This is an utter no-contest, with the Juice blowing the Vic away. If you need good pliers, the Leatherman clearly wins. If you just want a grabby tool (like strong forceps), then I think the Deluxe Tinker wins. Just my opinion, of course.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login