Small knife rust resistance experiment
-
Loving the experiment Hawkeye.

-
Cheers.
Didnt get home with the sunlight today so will hold off until the weekend to show latest developments... -
So, a week has gone by with both blades in the salt water. The results are not quite as I expected...
The long term salt blade increased in rust a bit:

However, the one that used to be in the fresh water:

Its still perfect! - not a sign of rust at all.
Interesting.
Now I cant be sure which is from what, but if you look at the nail nick's, they are different sizes, suggesting different ages of the swiss knives they came from. I can confirm 100% one is from a Tinker and the other 99% from an non hook Climber (with older corkscrew).Perhaps age, or stainless used at the time has caused one to rust and the other not to...thoughts?
So, no content bringing the mountain to moses, I decided to take moses (the blades) to the mountain (the sea). This is either the next stage of the rust test, or, a fairwell to the brave blades of science:

I chose a place you can only access at low tide, but who knows, a scavenger may find them and take them.

So...its either an update next week, or... -
Love those photos by the water.

Looking forward to the update. -
Very interesting that the second blade didn't rust at all. Other than being a different steel can anyone else think of a good reason for this?
-
@Gareth said:
Very interesting that the second blade didn't rust at all. Other than being a different steel can anyone else think of a good reason for this?Age and wear. My guess is that the unrusted blade is newer with less wear - less pitting and scratching on the surface, considerably less surface area for rust to form in.
Similar reason to why mirror polished blades are more corrosion resistant than bead-blasted or matte-finished blades of the same steel.
-
@Gareth said:
Very interesting that the second blade didn't rust at all. Other than being a different steel can anyone else think of a good reason for this?Salt water is WAY more detrimental to the steel. Going back to the boat subject and anodes - if you use freshwater anodes at sea - bye bye anodes VERY quickly, whereas salt water anodes don't corrode in fresh water and thus don't protect the boat. Don't worry - you'll see some rust now it's been put to sea assuming the water (or anything else) doesn't take it first
... but yes, the scratches/wear arguement is relevant too, just less so than the electrolyte in this instance
-
Very interesting that the second blade didn't rust at all. Other than being a different steel can anyone else think of a good reason for this?
Age and wear. My guess is that the unrusted blade is newer with less wear - less pitting and scratching on the surface, considerably less surface area for rust to form in.
Similar reason to why mirror polished blades are more corrosion resistant than bead-blasted or matte-finished blades of the same steel.
except of course that it's the non-rusty blade that's got all the scratches. In fairness I'd normally completely agree with you.

-
Yes, the non rusty blade had many more visual scratches than the non rusted. Also, the non rusted was in the same salt conditions for a week as the rusted and didnt show any rust at all, even though the first blade in salt got obvious rust in the first week.
In the controlled jar, the rust from the blade being exposed to air/water showed no more rust at the surface level than that which was submerged all the time (the tip)
I would assume the non rusted is newer, and obviously pitting etc on the older blade can be smaller than seen by the naked eye, but you would have thought visual scratches were just as detrimental as unseen pitting?
Also related to that, would the cutting edge not be one of the first expected areas to rust? - its not polished to the degree that the blade is.
Can anyone approximate the ages of the blades based on the nail nicks? -
@HawkeyX said:
Yes, the non rusty blade had many more visual scratches than the non rusted. Also, the non rusted was in the same salt conditions for a week as the rusted and didnt show any rust at all, even though the first blade in salt got obvious rust in the first week.I thought the non-rusted had always been in plain water - first fully submerged then partially

@HawkeyX said:
In the controlled jar, the rust from the blade being exposed to air/water showed no more rust at the surface level than that which was submerged all the time (the tip)That did surprise me - certainly very different from what I've seen before. But that was over FAR greater periods of time and not on stainless knives :D
@HawkeyX said:
I would assume the non rusted is newer, and obviously pitting etc on the older blade can be smaller than seen by the naked eye, but you would have thought visual scratches were just as detrimental as unseen pitting?
Also related to that, would the cutting edge not be one of the first expected areas to rust? - its not polished to the degree that the blade is.
Can anyone approximate the ages of the blades based on the nail nicks?I'd have expected that too - lots of surprises so far

Lets hope they're both still there next week :) -
@50ft-trad said:
Yes, the non rusty blade had many more visual scratches than the non rusted. Also, the non rusted was in the same salt conditions for a week as the rusted and didnt show any rust at all, even though the first blade in salt got obvious rust in the first week.
I thought the non-rusted had always been in plain water - first fully submerged then partially

Sorry for the confusion. I placed the fresh water one in salt water with the other blade last week.
Fingers crossed the blades survive the wilderness. Would be great to see how the non rusted goes over a week!
Stormy conditions at the moment however, so will have to wait and 'sea' -
Ha Vegemite again :). I actually just had a Vegemite sandwich 20 minutes ago, something i haven't had in a long time!
This is going to be real interesting to see how they go being left out in the sea. such a good idea

I would have thought the metal is the same make up throughout so it would not matter if there was scratched or not. Theres no coating so i dont think scratches would rust any more.
-
@50ft-trad said:
Yes, the non rusty blade had many more visual scratches than the non rusted. Also, the non rusted was in the same salt conditions for a week as the rusted and didnt show any rust at all, even though the first blade in salt got obvious rust in the first week.
I thought the non-rusted had always been in plain water - first fully submerged then partially

Sorry for the confusion. I placed the fresh water one in salt water with the other blade last week.
Sorry - must have missed an episode. I'm back on track now :D -
Update time! :_c:
So I managed to catch low tide today and wandered down to the secret cove of the blades...
I forgot to take my camera, but was also 50/50 they would be there. About 30m away from the spot I saw a shimmering light that could only be a swiss blade (well, ok, any shining metal).
On close inspection, both blades are doing pretty darn good. The rustless one finally has a small rust stain, but this is at the pivot point, under the fishing line holding it there.So they are holding up very well to the ocean so far (and are still there!). I'll try to get a pic before easter is over.
@Cyclone82 said:
I would have thought the metal is the same make up throughout so it would not matter if there was scratched or not. Theres no coating so i dont think scratches would rust any more.Im no metallurgist, but thats a good point. I guess the only difference would be areas that are not as finely polished (e.g. bade edge), but so far neither scratch or cutting edge is showing to be any less resistant than other areas.
-
Just managed to catch the tide before sun down today.
Both blades still hanging around, both doing pretty good after a week in the ocean (sorry for the amount of noise in images, had to use a fairly high iso!):

As in last post, only the small bit of rust stain on the pivot point of 'non rust' blade. Rust blade is looking no worse than several weeks ago.

-
This is such a great thread

If now the pivot point is rusting it would kind of back up the theory that high friction/use area rust faster. Or it would prove that rust is completely random ::) :D
-
Wow, this is an amazing test. :) After seeing how quickly rust developed during the submerged-in-salt-water-jar test, I expected we'd see a lot more rust by now on the blades tied to the oceanside rock. These results so far are most surprising.

-
So another week update.
I only just caught the tide again today and initially could only see the fishing line and not the blades. Luckly they had just tucked behind the rock and have survived another week.
So hows the rust going? - lets see:


Not bad at all!!!
Im going to give them one more week in the ocean and then bring them home for some closeups and to see how well I can clean them up again.
Might be time for a fuller experiment to be formed me thinks :sak:
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login