Some firearm advice?
-
I know there's a lot of people on here that are firearms users, so I figured I may as well ask here. Wisconsin finally passed a bill allowing for concealed carry. Since moving up here into a not so great neighborhood I've been tossing around the idea, but now that they are allowing for concealed carry come November I'm more thinking about it for both my GF and I. What I'm looking for is some good advice on what sort of gun I should be looking into. Something affordable, preferably compact, and reliable. Stopping power isn't a huge concern since the hope is that just having it would be deterrent enough in most cases, but I would like something more effective than some half-assed .22.
Interestingly, the law also states that it allows for concealed carry of knives, I'll have to look into that some more and see what exactly they mean by that, since I'm not aware of knives being prohibited in the first place.
-
For the price it's hard to beat a surplus CZ-82. Their superb guns that have great triggers, are very reliable and have 12+1 capacity.
http://www.jgsales.com/index.php/handguns/cz-surplus/cPath/16_155
-
Don't have any experience with concealed carry since that's against the law in Norway but I have fired enough guns to have a little experience on the matter :P
For concealed carry I would recommend that you get a gun that is made out of polymer or other plastic like stuff considering the weight difference with an all steel gun. The more heavier it is the more likely you will leave it at home for the just-going-to-the-store-and-buy-milk situation.
Seeing that you are looking for a compact light weight hand gun the guns that pop into my head is the Glock 26, Smith & Wesson M&P Compact 9mm, CZ 92 and H&K USP COMPACT. You also have the CZ 75 Compact but that is a tad heavier than the others. The CZ 82 isn't that bad either.
But if compact isn't that important then you have the trusty Glock 17 (this coming from someone that really don't like Glock's), Smith & Wesson M&P 9mm, H&K P30, SIG P226 and CZ 75. I myself have the CZ 75 SP-01 Shadow and I really love this gun, little over 4000 round through it and not a single problem with it, NOTHING! But that is a pretty heavy gun for concealed carry.
If stopping power isn't that important I would go for a 9mm since it's the cheapest round there is and therefore more cost efficient on the range.
But I guess someone more experienced than me can enlighten you on this subject will chime in shortly :P
-
Point the end with the hole in it away from your face. Best advice I have.... the rest is just details! :P
Def
-
hammerless Ruger sp101. Kimber makes some fine weapons too.
1911's have a ton of aftermarket bits and pieces. Of course you can never go wrong with a Glock either :D
-
For concealed carry I would recommend that you get a gun that is made out of polymer or other plastic like stuff considering the weight difference with an all steel gun. The more heavier it is the more likely you will leave it at home for the just-going-to-the-store-and-buy-milk situation.
Not necessarily, size and shape also comes into consideration. The lightweight polymer guns also tend to be thick, blocky and to me anyway, simply uncomfortable to hold and shoot. Not to mention expensive and, occasionally, finicky. Especially with cheap ammo. The CZ-82 may be heavy but it has thin barrel so it can conceal nicely. It's also designed to function under the worst conditions with the crappy ammo.
But I may be biased. I have the CZ-82's older cousin the Makarov(link below) and it's the one gun I will never sell. And if thebullfrog comes across a decent Makarov for a good price grab one of those too.
-
thebullfrog,
Before I get into any advice on what to look for let me say that your first go at this is likely not going to be the one. And what I mean is a good combination of comfortable concealed carry, ergonomics, shootability, etc.
Been a CCW holder for many years, have carried a vast number of different guns in all weather conditions and varying level of clothing.........I have owned dozens of handguns and have a gym bag and a large box full of holsters and have yet to find that one perfect combination for all year long CCW.
So don't expect to get it right first time out. Taking CCW seriously is going to cost money.
Next I will say, if you are going to get a CCW and plan to carry a firearm for personal protection.......keep the mindset that you will eventually have to use it for that purpose. And plan what you choose accordingly.
CCW is not some major weapon of mass destruction, so the idea of a deterrent throw out of your mind. CCW means Concealed Carry Weapon, having it concealed means it's deterrent factor is zero until you pull it on someone. And once you pull a pistol the game changes, keep that in mind. At that point you are half way to dropping the hammer on someone......and anything can happen.
Now, with all that said.......if you are looking to get a piece for CCW that will likely be a all year carry gun you need to take what you wear into consideration. The gun has to stay concealed no matter what you wear and how you carry. This generally means a small and lightweight sidearm. In a effective caliber the small size and light weight means added recoil and muzzle flash. And if a semi-auto becomes your choice it also means a higher probabilty of malfunction, especially during a time of crisis.
You need to be flexible enough to understand you might have to change your waredrobe for the year slightly. You might also have to purchase and use a couple different holster types, at least until you find the one rig that works for you.
As to firearms, my first piece of advice is get out and shoot a number of them that fall into the CCW category. The size and type of weapon you are looking to get, be it revolver or semi-auto. Go to the range with friends who may own some, or find a range that rents guns and try some out. Get to some gunshops and handle a bunch, find some that feel good in the hand, ones that have triggers that work for you and in the case of semi-autos, controls and functions you can access easily one handed.
And with that look at the calibers available in a given platform. I personally, for those with little to no CCW experience or dedicated handgun experience, would recommend nothing in a caliber smaller than .38 Special or 9mm. The smaller and more ineffective a caliber is the more critical shot placement becomes. And unless you spend and have spent alot of time with firearms and put thousands of rounds down range in all types of enviroments and at various levels of physical exertion........the chances of you being a crack shot with your sidearm at the moment of truth when your heart is racing and your body is flooded with adrenaline is slim.
So it's best to have a cartridge.....that when the times comes and you actually have to use it.....when the round or rounds hit them they immediately stop what they were doing that got them shot in the first place!
There are alot of good choices in this range. Go for a simple manual of arms, best to look at a good revolver from the likes of Ruger, Smith & Wesson, or Taurus. If you want a slimmer profile and higher capacity look at some of the compact semi-autos.......but here I recommend looking at a double-action semi-auto. Preferably one with a exposed or bobbed hammer. Something that'll give you second-strike capability, but this is not really all that needed as long as you are willing to put in the practice to fully understand the trigger system you are using. If a striker-fired pistol is a way you want to go.......avoid Glocks. As simple as their manual of arms is, and as popular as they are, they are very easy to AD (accidental discharge) due to their simplified trigger and safety set-up.
But in this semi-auto category look at Springfield Armory's XD line, or S&W's SD and M&P line, SigArms, CZ, H&K, Walther P-99 series, Bersa Thunder Series, EAA Witness line, and a number of others.
2xTap
-
a tanker AK with a 100 round drum...slightly harder to conceal than a pistol. Or a Thompson Contender in 30-06 >:D
whatever you get ..make sure you get real familiar with it..if it's in the least bit unreliable get rid of it. Take care of it and it will take care of you when you need it most.
-
agrees with 2xTap

-
I will also add.......I am a big proponent of the 1911. No other other handgun can match it in my view. The 1911 platform is the quintessential sidearm by which I judge all others. I carry and have carried one in a number of variations. But......it is not the sidearm for the novice CCW holder. It's single action only design requires a level of practice and knowledge to safely carry.
And to be effective a 1911 needs to be carried in "Condition 1".....which means "Cocked and Locked". Chambered loaded, hammer back, safety on.
With time and practice, and a expert level of familiarity the 1911 is the best CCW platform. And there is no better combat handgun on the planet. But not one I would recommend to those unfamiliar with it's manual of arms.
2xTap
-
Lotta good info, thanx. I'll certainly look into all the suggestions. Im not looking to do anything soon, but its something I do wanna start considering very seriously.
-
I agree with what 2xTap has written. Well thought out and good points.
For me, since I usually only carry when traveling by car through different states, and did not want to redo my wardrobe to fit around my firearm; I went the small, easily concealed route.
I currently have a Ruger LCP with a desantis nemesis pocket holster.
We also have a Ruger LCR that my wife uses. I liked the simpler manual of arms that a revolver has for her use, and the LCR has probably one of the smoothest double action triggers around (for a stock trigger anyway).
I like revolvers the best, personally, but I find them hard to conceal in my regular clothes. Maybe I'm just being a bit paranoid, but I always think that the cylinder is printing.
-
One thing I will add, if you do go the revolver route getting a "moonclip" conversion will greatly speed up reloading.
avoid Glocks. As simple as their manual of arms is, and as popular as they are, they are very easy to AD (accidental discharge) due to their simplified trigger and safety set-up.
I agree with this too but there is an aftermarket thumb safety for Glocks that reduces the chance for AD's.
-
hammerless Ruger sp101. Kimber makes some fine weapons too.
I also agree with a good wheelgun if you shoot it well enough.
I also agree. The revolver has a simpler manual of arms, is more reliable (but not to a large degree), and usually easier to shoot for new gun users. I strongly recommend a double action only revolver in a reasonable caliber. I would say the old .32 H&R mag as a minimum and a .357 mag loaded with .38+p as the top end for someone who is not going to shoot a lot.
More important than choice of equipment, is the ability and willingness to use it. All the potential gun handlers in your family should receive instruction from a trained firearms instructor. They also have to decide before hand whether or not they are capable of KILLING another human being. Not point a gun at, or shoot them, or shoot at them, but KILL THEM DEAD NOW. Hopefully it will never come to that, but if a person isn't capable of doing that, they are better off with a self defense plan that does not include a firearm or a knife. Shooting incidents will happen in a blink of an eye and will be 2nd guessed forever. The mindset needs to be in place ahead of time.
-
Given that my shooting is done in a UK Club,I cant add much other than a truism I learnt living in SA years ago:If you pull the gun and you ain't prepared to use it,IT WILL be used on you!
PS the former wife was in the SA Police,and had a Walther PPK as her service arm
-
See, I told you that someone with more knowledge would come around and give you some good advice.
-
This has been an interesting thread. I don't have a CC permit (almost impossible to get in Jersey), but I've been shooting almost all my life. There have been some great suggestions so far. The one thing I will add is no matter what you end up with, KNOW YOUR WEAPON. Get some snap caps and dry fire it some (never with nothing in the chamber!). Get plenty of range time, know how to strip it down and reassemble. Do it until it becomes second nature. Hell, my mother can field-strip my M1 blindfolded, just like her father (a former Marine) taught her to decades ago. I happen to be a revolver guy personally, despite being a lefty. Small automatics like the PPK and knockoffs don't get along with me. My hands are fairly large, and I get bitten by the slide. The only left-handed revolver I've ever fired is definitely NOT a realistic carry piece (Mle 1892 Lebel. A left-handed service revolver?
)
BTW: @ DTH- thanks for that moon-clip link, I'm going to have to explore that a bit. Half moon clips are required for my father's (well, half mine :)) M1917 Colt because there's no rim on the .45 ACP for the extractor to act on. We have a few, but they're hard to find. -
@jerseydevil said:
The only left-handed revolver I've ever fired is definitely NOT a realistic carry piece (Mle 1892 Lebel. A left-handed service revolver?
)A MLE 1892???Theres a rare bird!Pics?

-
The only left-handed revolver I've ever fired is definitely NOT a realistic carry piece (Mle 1892 Lebel. A left-handed service revolver?
)A MLE 1892???Theres a rare bird!Pics?

Wasn't mine, sorry :(. I might have some pics of it somewhere, I'll take a look. Strange piece, the butt is almost a cylinder, and nearly perpendicular to the frame. The nice thing that I remember is that aside from the cylinder opening to the right, the cartridge is so underpowered there was almost recoil :). Definitely not a combo I'd stake my life on.....
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login