Time to get nasty!
-
The prices on the Charge series seem like a very bad joke to me. Take the original two for example, the Ti and XTi- they can be found for about a hundred dollars if you shop around. A little better sometimes, a little worse, but usually around the $100 mark. To me, the question is why? Ok, so it has titanium on it... but titanium isn't that expensive that such a small amount added to a tool would make it cost 30% more than a similar tool (Wave). And, the benefits of titanium are pretty well useless- it's lighter than steel, but it's such a small quantity that it doesn't matter. It's stronger than steel, but it's not used in a structural or load bearing capacity. It's non-magnetic, but 90% of the tool is steel so it would have a significant magnetic signature. Titanium is corrosion resistant, but it only covers a small percentage of the tool so the useful parts will still suffer from rust. So basically, the fancy titanium scales are there for the "cool" factor, so folks will think they are getting something better because it's titanium and it costs more. This is nothing new, you see it in every industry. Who needs a factory tweaked 550hp Mustang to sit in traffic and go to the grocery store in?
Then Leatherman took one step further and took the Charge series from "off the wall" into "land of the certifiable" in my opinion. They discontinued the Ti and XTi and replaced them with aluminum scaled versions at the same price point as the old titanium models. But, figuring the same folks who bought the overpriced titanium models would still want to feel cool, they also came out with the TTi with a retail price of $150! Half again as much as the old Charges or the aluminum Charges just so you can pretend you have a cool tactical ninja plier tool? With the Wave retailing at around $60-70 most places I think the TTi has gone a little too far. But then the "budget conscious" AL and ALX are at the same price of the older "premium" models? Seems like a screw to the customers to me...
Def
-
I agree with the price issue with Leatherman.I also think that with the SuperTool 200 they dropped the ball.I am posting a link to an article that I submitted awhile back to SOSAK about my experiences with a few MultiTools,good and bad.It has been awhile since I submitted the article and I have a few new thoughts.At least with the Supertool
200.I think that the SuperTool 200 was a stopgap model until they could bring the new line.
I also feel that after looking at the "New" Leatherman's that all they really needed to do was improve on the
existing line,instead of coming out with a brand new one.I have looked at some of the cheaper models as possible Christmas Gifts for my boys.I dont like the idea of the plastic handles as well.Plastic breaks,and I feel that when you pull that tool out of your pocket,sheath,bag or other favored mode of conveyance you are potentially doing so because you have no access to conventional tools and are stuck in a "Run what You Brung" scenario.That to me is the worst time to have your tool fail because of inferior materials.Despite what I have said about my SuperTool 200,now the property of my oldest,and my Wave now the property of my youngest,they are probably better off now with those models than any of the entry level models Leatherman produces.With Gerber I do not have much experience with them other than their first effort.I have seen many Gerbers on others belts,and in use.They look beat.A few drivers who I have spken with on why they picked the Gerber stated,that "Price" was the number one issue.I think that Gerber's edge might be their saturation of major retailers.
Leatherman's might be the reputation that their prior offerings have built with the product.Hope I ruffled no feathers here.I respect each person's choice in tool.Since 05' mine has been the Swisstool.I feel that Victorinox looked at what made Leatherman,Well "Leatherman" came up with their entry,built on that along with their reputation for qualityand came out with the Swisstool and Spirit.I bet if Vic's MultiTools were just as heavily marketed in the same places that Leatherman and Gerber are they would be just as successful.
To be fair I do have a bit of a Rant against Victorinox,and i am sure that many other members here will agree.What is the reasoning behind not offering the OH series of folders with a plain edge as an item that someone does not have to go to a limited run,special offering to get.I feel that Vic is missing the boat on this,myself.The have an excellent product with the OH series,but are failing to capitalize on it.
Just my 2cents......Thanks for letting me get nasty,hopefully no one will get nasty with me over my comments.
Dtrain
http://www.sosakonline.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=119&Itemid=35
-
@Defender said:
PST II- 5.27 oz
Juice Cs4- 5.39 oz
Juice Kf4- 5.42 oz
Kick- 5.29 oz
Fuse- 5.97 oz
SideClip- 5.02 oz
SwitchPlier- 5.43 oz
SOG PPP- 5.06 ozNote that the Pocket Power Plier actually weighs less than the PST. Given the weight/function difference I would probably opt for the Juice Kf4 or the Fuse out of that list over the PST.
Def
Thanks Def - I stand corrected and will reconsider getting a SOG PPP. For some reason, I was under the erroneous belief that it was heavier than the original Leatherman Tool.
I don't care for the Juice lineup at all - they seem over-priced, over-weight, and under-strength.
I've seen a couple of Juices break in use on backpacking trips. In both cases, my original Leatherman was able to complete the task that had broken the Juice. (One broke while repairing a white gas stove and the other broke while repairing a pack frame.)
.
-
the boss has "enlightened" me (straightened me out!) several times, that's why he's the man!
-
@ringzero said:
I don't care for the Juice lineup at all - they seem over-priced, over-weight, and under-strength.I've seen a couple of Juices break in use on backpacking trips. In both cases, my original Leatherman was able to complete the task that had broken the Juice. (One broke while repairing a white gas stove and the other broke while repairing a pack frame.)
That's a shame really as I would say the Juice is a very solid tool. I do however completely agree with the price! They do seem very high, but a quility tool nonetheless. I have a KF4 and I really like it and would chose it over my PST for EDC.
-
I'm thinking about getting a KF4. I like the fact it doesn't have that useless can opener.
-
@ducktapehero said:
I'm thinking about getting a KF4. I like the fact it doesn't have that useless can opener.There seems to be quite a few of us that like the KF4. I liked it as it didn't have scissors but had the diamond file.
-
Kinda funny; Leatherman listened, came out with the features people asked for, but now we don't want them after all!
That's what good customers do.
My biggest complaint is the price of Leathermans, 120.00 usd for a Charge XTi?! (I'm talking retail)
I pay more than that Wholesale, quit yer bitchin'.
Def-pricing suspicious an' all, the Charges do have fancier blades. It might be better for your sanity if you consider that's what you're paying for, instead of the scales.
-
NOMAD, VERY HARSH!
-
I dont like the idea of the plastic handles as well.Plastic breaks,and I feel that when you pull that tool out of your pocket,sheath,bag or other favored mode of conveyance you are potentially doing so because you have no access to conventional tools and are stuck in a "Run what You Brung" scenario.That to me is the worst time to have your tool fail because of inferior materials
I thought the same thing when I got the Kick but I must say that I used that tool fairly often and never had an issue with the plastic. However, I do agree with the tools getting bulkier and having less tools. With a little thoughtful engineering I think the Kick could be as thin and sleek as the Side-Clip.
-
I think plastic is alright in the beginning, especially when new, but over the years it gets brittle and breaks.
We'll see how these petroleum products hold up over the next few decades! -
I'm all keen now for a "Pocket" multi showdown and/or big Pic comparison.
SOG PPP
Vic Spirit (?)
LM Sideclip
LM Kick
LM PST
LM Juice.is the MP400 Gerber's official offering for "pocket sized" multis? (As opposed to Keychain, Full Size, or Large - as defined by Leatherman)
The ? on Spirit is because I am not sure if this is considered a Pocket or Full size (as the Swisstool is generally considered Large), I guess since it is the only option from Vic, it will have to do.
-
I don't care for the Juice lineup at all - they seem over-priced, over-weight, and under-strength.
I've seen a couple of Juices break in use on backpacking trips. In both cases, my original Leatherman was able to complete the task that had broken the Juice. (One broke while repairing a white gas stove and the other broke while repairing a pack frame.)
That's a shame really as I would say the Juice is a very solid tool. I do however completely agree with the price! They do seem very high, but a quility tool nonetheless. I have a KF4 and I really like it and would chose it over my PST for EDC.
Well, Juices do have the advantage of greater compactness for EDC, but no advantage in weight over a PST. Juices are too heavy for pocket carry for me (as is the PST) and I don't EDC a tool in a belt sheath.
For the same weight, I'd as soon have something more robust as a backup/repair tool.
After seeing a couple of the Juices break in action, I don't really trust them as backup tools. They're better than nothing, but not that good for their weight.
.
-
LOL I pocket carry my Supertool sometimes and it doesn't bother me. Maybe you need bigger pockets. :P
-
I've heard Benner packs, I always thought they meant something else!

-
@WhichDawg said:
I've heard Benner packs, I always thought they meant something else!
:D
-
How's the fam boss Benner? and where's all the new pictures with the new camera huh?!
-
@WhichDawg said:
How's the fam boss Benner? and where's all the new pictures with the new camera huh?!There good ta! :D
As it so happens, I have just done a load more! :) Stay tuned for a new topic in the general tool discussion forum in the next few minutes.
-
The ? on Spirit is because I am not sure if this is considered a Pocket or Full size
I pocket carry a Spirit and it is a bit big but it's also much smoother than anything else it's size so I think it makes a great pocket carry tool. I'd include it in a test.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



