Black Oxide Question
-
Great explination Steve.

-
I had a feeling you would come through with the answer Steve

Seems like the whole process is not unlike putting a patina on a carbon steel blade, just with stronger chemicals and neutralizers.
-
Ok I was curious so I looked up the MSDS sheet for Magnetite (Fe3O4) the type of iron oxide black oxide is.
http://fscimage.fishersci.com/msds/09765.htm
Seems like mostly an 'irritant' in most cases. But it would have to come off to even be that irritant. Hot caustic applications shouldn't, but the cold method can come off more readily.
No LD50 was listed ( the amount mice/lab rats had to ingest to kill half of them).
I havent worked in chemistry for a decade, but I remember reading all the MSDS sheets for the nasty stuff I was working with at the time, and it made me change my career.
-
I'm not sure about the sciencey part of it, but I have used my BO Crater to cut steak while camping more than once and I'm still here!
-
-
@turnsouth said:
I had a feeling you would come through with the answer Steve
Seems like the whole process is not unlike putting a patina on a carbon steel blade, just with stronger chemicals and neutralizers.
Anytime. I have done countless hours of research on this.
@syph007
Yes the cold process leaves chemicals on the surface, and even if you clean it, you get 2 solutions.
1- the cold black oxide surface is gone
2- the metal stays pitted and looks horrible, also it rusts very easyI know, I tried, and the cold process, without use of a better word, just plain sucks for knife use.
-
I had a feeling you would come through with the answer Steve

Seems like the whole process is not unlike putting a patina on a carbon steel blade, just with stronger chemicals and neutralizers.
Anytime. I have done countless hours of research on this.
@syph007
Yes the cold process leaves chemicals on the surface, and even if you clean it, you get 2 solutions.
1- the cold black oxide surface is gone
2- the metal stays pitted and looks horrible, also it rusts very easyI know, I tried, and the cold process, without use of a better word, just plain sucks for knife use.
Ya from what I heard, on stainless steel its pointless to try the cold. I dont know about regualar steel as it would be easier to oxidize, it may be better.
Is the hot method an option for DIY? Ive never heard of a home version, but im sure its possible.
-
I had a feeling you would come through with the answer Steve

Seems like the whole process is not unlike putting a patina on a carbon steel blade, just with stronger chemicals and neutralizers.
Anytime. I have done countless hours of research on this.
@syph007
Yes the cold process leaves chemicals on the surface, and even if you clean it, you get 2 solutions.
1- the cold black oxide surface is gone
2- the metal stays pitted and looks horrible, also it rusts very easyI know, I tried, and the cold process, without use of a better word, just plain sucks for knife use.
Ya from what I heard, on stainless steel its pointless to try the cold. I dont know about regualar steel as it would be easier to oxidize, it may be better.
Is the hot method an option for DIY? Ive never heard of a home version, but im sure its possible.
Yes and no. You can DIY if you want to spend a grand or 3.
-
I had a feeling you would come through with the answer Steve

Seems like the whole process is not unlike putting a patina on a carbon steel blade, just with stronger chemicals and neutralizers.
Anytime. I have done countless hours of research on this.
@syph007
Yes the cold process leaves chemicals on the surface, and even if you clean it, you get 2 solutions.
1- the cold black oxide surface is gone
2- the metal stays pitted and looks horrible, also it rusts very easyI know, I tried, and the cold process, without use of a better word, just plain sucks for knife use.
Ya from what I heard, on stainless steel its pointless to try the cold. I dont know about regualar steel as it would be easier to oxidize, it may be better.
Is the hot method an option for DIY? Ive never heard of a home version, but im sure its possible.
Yes and no. You can DIY if you want to spend a grand or 3.
"Just" 3 grand?
Sing me up :D -
We can all put our money together and get one!! :D
I have used gun-blue on shotguns which is a cold process and after a bit of time the, remaining, coating stops coming off (a lot cheaper than paying someone to do it for you). The coating has survived fine for many years, by the way.
Of course, with a shotgun you worry about a lot more toxic chemicals than the coating on the barrels. My most recent shotgun has the hot-process coating (from looking at it) from the factory. -
On steel a chemical works better because it's not resistant to those chemical. Stainless is that's why it's called stainless.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login