Phantom Menace in 3D
-
I'll probably go see it with my son when I go home for Spring Break. He's a major star wars fan, and until this year since I've been away for my job, we had a weekly ritual of watching every new episode of Clone Wars together.
My beef with EP I is that Obi-Wan is my favorite SW character, and he plays such a pivotal role in the entire story, that I was sorely disappointed by how shallow they made his character in that episode. There was such a great opportunity to see what made him the Jedi he was (and I don't just mean Qui-Gon) and how that in turn influenced Anakin, but they totally blew it!!!

-
I don't think I could tolerate Jar Jar Binks in 3D :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh

-
While I never really cared for Jar Jar as a character I never developed the hate for him that lots of others seem to have. You simply can't like every character, and it's the same as real life. I'm certain we all have people around us that we really don't care for and annoy us at almost every turn, yet we can't get rid of them, so we roll our eyes and get on with life. To me, having a character that you don't like in a movie and not have them turn out to be instrumental in the end (either as the bad guy all along or as a hindrance to the hero) just makes the movie a bit more realistic even though the obvious subject matter of Star Wars is a major work of fiction.
You can tell that no one in the movie likes Jar Jar either, but they are stuck with him, not because of any importance he has, but largely because he has no where else to go and so follows them around. And, it helps illustrate the Jedi mentality that all life, even the really annoying, is important. Otherwise, they would simply abandon him because he was virtually useless to them, which would make them appear to be self important pricks.
Def
-
I can live with Jar Jar, annoying yes, but no need to skin him alive and throw him in a bath of vinegar. ;) Actually the one thing that bothers me the most about the film is that the young Anakin Skuwalker manages to destroy an entire battle fleet; by accident! :ahhh Far to much "oops" and "what does this button do?" for me.
Now if he'd been trying to do it and succeeded, that would be OK, but the fact he just happens to crash land pointing right at the "do not blow up, it would be very bad for us" bit of the ship and then just happens to press the missile launch button just stretches the idea of the Force beyond what I can find credible, even given the nature of the Star Wars universe.
OK I feel better for that little rant. :) Oh, and the script sucks as well. :D
-
I can cope with Jar Jar in 2D, but 3D might be pushing it. Kind of the type of character you can cope with "over there", but you might do something regrettable if they started getting in your face. Anyway, he does do something important doesn't he? Introducing the Jedis to slobber-chops (whatever his name was)
@Gareth said:
he just happens to **crash land pointing right at the "do not blow up, it would be very bad for us" bit of the ship and then just happens to press the missile launch button ** just stretches the idea of the Force beyond what I can find credible
Why did that make me think of Mr Bean as a Jedi? -
I sort of agree with you on that one but sort of not. Yes it does seem a bit far fetched, but it's not like Luke had a lot of training or know how when he ignored his targeting system and fired a couple of photon torpedoes in exactly that spot on the Death Star.
Furthermore, you'd think that Darth Vader would have remembered that instance and made sure they didn't include a button like that on the Death Star in the first place.
BTW, I hate that kid that played Anakin. He bugged me a lot worse than Jar Jar ever did. It really bugged me that the ultimate in cool bad guys started off as such an annoying little poop. I realize they all had to start somewhere, but I think it might have been better had he started off as a tough streetwise kid who had to steal to survive rather than living in gorgeously appointed "slave" housing. I just can't see a Sunshine and Lollipops type kid casually breaking a guy's neck during an impromptu interrogation or stepping over the lifeless corpses of soldiers, both his own and those of his enemies.
Def
-
I'm absolutely with you on that one boss, far far to nice to believably become Vader. :-\ Sadly I don't think they did a much better job with him in the later films either. Big question is; why would a beautiful, intelligent woman who has worlds at her feet, fall in love with a spoilt, whiny, petulant oik of a teenager? ???
-
Because when he was six he asked her if she was an angel and made her a little charm necklace? If that was realistic then I'd have had a lot of kids by now with a lot of the teachers I had in school!
Def
-
Def had a crush for a teacher, Def had a crush for a teacher!
;) -
Several over the years in fact.... my Grades 2 and 3 teachers, a few French teachers and a science teacher that I can think of off the top of my head. Oh, and a math teacher in high school, but that wasn't nearly as innocent! >:D
Def
-
A long, long time ago
In a galaxy far away
Naboo was under an attack...And I thought me and Qui-Gon Jinn
Could talk the federation in
To maybe cutting them a little slack...But their response, it didn't thrill us;
They locked the doors and tried to kill us.
We escaped from that gas,
Then met Jar Jar in Boss Nass.We took a bongo from the scene...
And we went to Theed, to see the Queen,
We all wound up on Tatooine;
That's where we found this boy...Oh my my this here Anakin guy,
Maybe Vader someday later;
Now he's just a small fry.He left his home and kissed his mommy goodbye
Sayin' "Soon I'm gonna be a Jedi"
"Soon I'm gonna be a Jedi"Did you know this junkyard slave isn't even old enough to shave?
But he can use the Force, they say...Ahh...
Do you see him hitting on the queen?
Though he's just nine and she's fourteen?
Yeah, he's probably gonna marry her someday...Well, I know he built C-3PO
And I've heard how fast his pod can go...
And we were broke, it's true;
So we made a wager or two.He was a prepubescent flyin' ace
And the minute Jabba started off that race,
Well, I knew who would win first place...
Oh yes,
It was our boy...We started singin'
My my this here Anakin guy
Maybe Vader someday later, now he's just a small fry
He left his home, and kissed his mommy goodbye
Sayin'
"Soon I'm gonna be a Jedi"
"Soon I'm gonna be a Jedi"Now we finally got to Coruscant,
The Jedi Council we knew would want,
To see how good the boy could be...So we took him there and we told the tale,
How his midi-chlorians were off the scale,
And he might fulfill that prophecy...Oh the Council was impressed of course;
Could he bring balance to the Force?
Well, they interviewed the kid...
But, training they forbid!Because Yoda sensed in him much fear...
And Qui-Gon said "Now listen here";
"Just stick it in your pointy ear"
"I still will teach this boy"He was singin'
My my this here Anakin guy
Maybe Vader someday later, now he's just a small fry
He left his home and kissed his mommy goodbye
Sayin'
"Soon I'm gonna be a Jedi"
"Soon I'm gonna be a Jedi"We caught a ride back to Naboo
'Cause Queen Amidala wanted to;
I frankly would've liked to stay...We all fought in that epic war,
And it wasn't long at all before,
Little hotshot flew his plane and saved the day...And in the end some Gungans died,
Some ships blew up and some pilots fried,
A lot of folks were croakin'...But the battle droids were broken...
And the Jedi I admire most;
Met up with Darth Maul and now he's toast...Well, I'm still here and he's a ghost;
I guess I'll train this boy...And I was singin'
My my this here Anakin guy
May be Vader someday later, now he's just a small fry
He left his home and kissed his mommy goodbye
Sayin'
"Soon I'm gonna be a Jedi"
"Soon I'm gonna be a Jedi"We were singin'
My my this here Anakin guy may be Vader someday later
Now he's just a small fry
And he left his home
And kissed his mommy goodbye
Sayin' "Soon I'm gonna be a Jedi" -
-
I've only got one thing* to say:
Star Wars: The Phantom Menace Review (Part 1 of 7)
*The narrator's character is a bit...hmm, odd... but he does a great job of explaining why exactly EP 1 is soooo bad. Well worth watching all 7 parts!
-
For me it's the event more than the movie. Sure it's not the greatest movie, but it's tradition that I go to see each movie when it's released.
Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
For me it's the event more than the movie. Sure it's not the greatest movie, but it's tradition that I go to see each movie when it's released.Def
Totally understand.
Even though I'm not a fan of the prequels, I will definitely be seeing the original 3 if they come out in 3D!
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Not even going to post the video? :D"Weird Al" Yankovic - The Saga Begins

Def
Sorry boss... had to get to class so I didn't have time to track down a link for it... So fire me.

-
You know what, I didn't really think the movie was all that bad. It wasn't perfect, but I liked it well enough.
Def
-
The new Star Wars movies are just awful. Awful
The downward slide started early with Return of the Jedi.
-
@shamus said:
The new Star Wars movies are just awful. AwfulThe downward slide started early with Return of the Jedi.
There's a lot of truth to that.
I've always said that Lucas and Spielberg were the Lennon and McCartney of movie making. Spielberg is an incredibly technically talented and knowledgeable director, but without an milligram of creativity, insight, or vision. Lucas on the other hand is everything Spielberg is not, and similarly, nothing that he is. Put them together and they make great stuff. Either one on their own, and you end up with the cinematic equivalent of the pedantacism and amateurism of "Wings", and the originally and creativity of Yoko Ono's B-sides. (isn't there a puking smiley we can use?)
-
I liked the newer prequel trilogy enough, but didnt love them. The original ones are classic though. All I have to say about the newer ones is jar jar binks...

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login




