Livarno, Romisen, C8, Small Sun cheap HID torches
-
Note: If you are in any way made unhappy with my review you are free to perform your own one. <u>Complaining to me will not make you happier</u>.
After waiting for a few months we finally got these Livarno torches back in LIDLs.
I got 2 of them to try.
The cost was €5.99 each; about $9.
The cost, compared to some other cheap Chinese made Cree led torches I have on order, is not negligible, but LIDLs always includes batteries (Panasonic!!) and even tie the strap on for you, so you do not have to stress over these things. If you do not like it you can get your money back easily. Note that proper LED lights are not a widely used product here, that you expect to find in a supermarket.--
The torch has an 1Watt LED, producing 50Lm, 10000hrs of life, splashproof, unknown runtime, plastic reflector and lens.
They are imported for LIDL by a UK company, Milomex : http://www.milomex.com/milomex/index.html who imports items from Asia, so they are probably made in China.
Here is link to LIDL for more: http://www.lidl-service.com/static/11544359/66776_A_ES_PT_EN.pdfIt is operated by a, decent, rubber covered switch on the side and has one mode only, with no possibility for switching it on for a second with just a bit of light pressure on the switch, for the tactical folk here.
It can tailstand. It will also easily roll on its side, without stopping and fall of a table. So, you do not need a dog for tricks if you have this light.
The specifications are shown below* in various languages*, for your pleasure.

--
The torch is made from heavy gauge aluminium and feels quite solid and heavy; it survived an 1m drop test
on thin carpet with no problems and should be solid enough to hit someone with, if such action is deemed necessary. ;)
--
The threads work well but are not extremely precision ground so there is some squeaking when screwing or unscrewing its parts.
--
Taking the, substantial, bottom cap off the 3 battery carrier comes out.
All contacts are plated, shown by the gold colour, though the plating material is unknown.Looking through the opening you see the, unplated, contact for the switch/light module. The abovementioned module takes about 1/3 of the length of the torch and is of unknown design/make.

--
On the other end, after taking the lens/reflector module off, you see the single LED.
The only brand marking on the plate with the LED appears to be NH or HN….
Taking the torch apart even more seems possible, but was beyond what I wanted to do.
The LED module appears to be secured by a bezel that should turn with circlip pliers, for those interested.The LED is centred but the reflector hole is not so the LED appears a bit off-centre with it on.

...and a comparison with the, more expensive, Jetbeam BA20

--
The beam *without the reflector * has a very uniform spread, with a white-bluish tint.I also compared the beam profile and intensity, with the reflector on, with some of my other lights for verification purposes. This comparison was done indoors, on a sunny day with natural light at a distance of 10cm from the end of each torch, on a door. From the left we see: 9LED 3AAA cheap torch, Jetbeam BA20 on the low setting, Livarno and Fenix E05 (borrowed…).

As seen, the beam, especially at the centre, is visibly brighter than both the Jetbeam and the Fenix. Considering these give out about 30Lm each, the 50 Lm claimed by Livarno looks realistic. The beam profile looks similar to the Jetbeam, with a hot spot in the middle and a weaker, round penumbra. The Jetbeam beam is smoother. The Livarno tint is similar to the cheap 9 LED torch and the Jetbeam has a similar tint to the Fenix.

The Jetbeam *at high beam * is, as expected, significantly brighter.

I will do some better, nighttime, testing in the near future when some more lights arrive.
--
Overall, worth a try and since LIDLs has probably sold thousands of them it should last well.
Pros:
Low priced complete package
Good beam
Solid and backed with a money-back guaranteeCons:
Plastic lens and reflector
Not that cheap compared to some online deals
Not branded
enjoy!
-
I think it'll get the proper attention in the flashlight section..

-
@AHB said:
I think it'll get the proper attention in the flashlight section..
I did post a link to it there too.
I see reviews here that are not for multitools; I assume the idea is to put all reviews in here, for all subforums
EDIT:
I just realised this has been moved...
If the review section is to be used specifically for multitools from now on then let it be. -
We'll just keep it in the review section then.. :)
-
well, maybe it will be better in the Flashlight section


No worries, if possible clarify whether the Mod/Admin team prefer that non multitool reviews are posted in their specific forums and we will follow

-
-
While I'm not a huge fan of lights that use 3xAAA this does seem like a perfectly good light for the money. Thanks for taking the time to do the review dks.

-
@Gareth said:
While I'm not a huge fan of lights that use 3xAAA this does seem like a perfectly good light for the money. Thanks for taking the time to do the review dks.
YES !!!I got an actual reply !!!


Thanks Gareth, I am sure some people here could easily replace that battery carrier with a single battery like an 18650 lithium -
It looks like a big step up from the cheap 9 led no-name lights. I have one of those and it works good enough.
Do you know what the run time is?Good review

-
No, there were no details on runtime.
I assume it will be a few hours, based on the wattage of the battery, but since we have no idea on the efficiency of the LED system it is hard to make any accurate calculations.<u>Addition:</u>
Last night I compared the ability of this light to light up a room, by bouncing its light off the ceiling, with the Jetbam on low power and with a multi LED cheapie (same battery capacity, fully charged)
The Livarno was noticably better at this, veryfying that it is indeed giving out more total light than the Jetbeam and a lot more than the multi LED one

-
What I don't like on these kind of lamps is that they break the big 3xAAA advantage (for me): compactness.
-
Yes Carlos, if you see the beam comparison picture the Cheap multi LED light and the Livarno both use exactly the same 3AAA battery carrier system, but the Livarno is thicker and nearly twice as long because it has a switch module, separate from the battery container (different section incorporating the LED and the electronics it needs too) and a reflector section, which the multi LED one does not have.
If you take the reflector/lens section off you end up with a pure smooth fan beam torch with little throw, and a much shorter one too. -
I got one more low cost light so until I post more about it I decided to add it here:
It is an Ultrafire (apparently...) possibly a variation of their C8 model, with 5 modes (3 intensities and 2 disco)

The ad claimed 1300Lm though I expect around 800, as that is what the manufacturer gives.
http://www.ultrafire.net/showproducts.asp?id=156

You can see a beam comparison pictures, in which it is brighter than the Jetbeam BA20 (270Lm) and the LIDLs Livarno.

Came with a charger and two batteries. The charger is supposed to be inteligent and the batteries protected, though my tests show otherwise.
-
Current testing using my Blackspur DT-100
Lidl, .38A, not bad
C8:
High 2A
med 1.4A
Low 0.32A
with a fully charged. 4.28V battery, alas a cheap one... -
@dks said:
Current testing using my Blackspur DT-100Lidl, .38A, not bad
C8:
High 2A
med 1.4A
Low 0.32A
with a fully charged. 4.28V battery, alas a cheap one...Just adding that with a different, charged to 4.3V battery I actually got 2.3A. I will do a better test when I get some new batteries.
Also, when my focalprice torches arrive ::) I will do some comparison shots of all of them.I got brave and took the Ultrafire apart further so here are some pictures of the remaining pieces. (I put it back together too and it works!!)
The scratch on the pill was my fault. :D -
I missed your review when first posted , sorry. I enjoyed your style :)
Its good to see a review of cheaper torches that we can pop out and pick up. I was a bit worried when I saw that battery holder but it looks to be quite a sturdy torch with decent output.
-
@Carlos said:
You lost me on this one. ??? What is the DT100, a multimeter? And are you measuring current? Can you detail your test a bit?Yes, it is a cheap but decent enough digital multimeter; bought in the UK over 10 years ago and surprisingly still being sold.
I basically take the bottom cap of the torch (with the switch in the case of the Ultrafire) leaving the battery in as it is and connect the lower part of the battery (-ve) with the body of the torch (the non painted/anodised thread area) through the multimeter thus creating a complete circuit. (Unfortunately I need two hands for that, so I have no pictures).
I then use the ammeter setting (10A max) and read the current passing through. With the Ultrafire every time I break the circuit (stop touching the body of the torch) it changes mode from higher to lower etc, so I can see the current passing through for each mode.This is a, sort of, standard way to measure the current, used in the light forums. It is not perfect as you do not take into account any other resistances or how the control system of the light may react differently if the current goes through the switch etc. but it gives a good indication of how much current is allowed to go through at each mode.
With a fancier light you will see that as the battery “weakens” the current is altered to keep the luminance constant, though I do not expect anything like that in these cheap torches.@Neil said:
I missed your review when first posted , sorry. I enjoyed your style :)Its good to see a review of cheaper torches that we can pop out and pick up. I was a bit worried when I saw that battery holder but it looks to be quite a sturdy torch with decent output.
I am used to being ignored... I posted some knife pictures a week ago and nobody has commented on them yet... :D
The torches work fine and are a lot brighter than what 99.9% of the people use.
I did order some really cheap Cree LEDE torches from focalprice over 2 months ago to compare but they have not arrived yet.
EDIT: added some really bad pictures from a shop from yesterday, to show what is available in DIY shops here.


-
**The Romisen RC-K4. **
Romisen is considered a decent torch maker.
http://www.szromisen.com/zh-en/product_show.asp?id=91

General quality and sealing seems OK, but the LED is below the reflector hole by a bit and is not centred well. Aluminium Body.
Single mode, 160Lm max,
Q3 Cree LED with its circuits protected by a plastic cover.

regulated, can not tailstand, waterproofed.
No coloured plating.

OP Aluminium reflector


Runs for, (on):
6 hours (2xCR123A)
4 hours (1x18650)
2.5 hours (3xAAA)
There are springs in the bottom cap and the inside of the tube so as to accomodate the longer batteries.
The beam *appears brighter * when using the 18650 instead of the 3 AAAs.
A size comparison:

and a beam comparison with the:
Romisen, Ultrafire, Jetbeam, Livarno and 9 LED cheapo.
With the jetbeam and Ultrafire on High

and on Low

Current wise, with the 3AAAs giving 3.85V it draws 0.66A.
With a 3.8V 18650 it draws 0.70A, about the same then.
However with a 4.09V 18650 it draws 0.92A, thus with a fully charged 18650 it should draw around 1A. (for comparison the ultrafire draws from over 2A to 1,3A)
I would *estimate * that you will get the full 160Lm with the 18650 but maybe a bit less with the 3AAAs.Will do more when I get the rest of the light I ordered!
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login