Kydex
-
@micky d said:
I love kydex, while it's nowhere near as good looking as leather, it is way tougher and more practical :)Actually I think Kydex is better looking than leather, but I don't think a Kydex sheath is as tough as a good quality leather sheath. (Low quality leather makes for about the worst possible sheath.)
Good quality leather - if oiled occasionally to prevent it drying out and cracking - is amazingly tough and will last for many years of use. Kydex will wear much faster than good leather.
Even brand new Kydex, if exposed to very cold temps, may crack completely through. Leather will be unaffected by the same temps.
.
-
Thats very true mate, my main problem with leather on these shore's (uk) is it's very easy for the leather to become saturated, and takes an absolute age to dry out again ::)
-
Kydex has got to be a god send for people who like to fish and hunt .Kydex just washes clean but imagine the state of a leather sheath after a good days fishing .
Dunc
-
Plus leather retains moisture on the tool or knife, increasing the likelihood of rust or corrosion. I got a vintage Cold Steel tanto a year or so ago that had never been used, but the blade was a mess because it had been stored in leather.
Besides, if it's cold enough to crack kydex outside, I doubt I'd be out there myself! :o :ahhh
Def
-
I do think it is just about the most practical sheath material out there at the moment, that said I quite like the sheath/scabbard design on the Buck M9, loose the wire cutters and you've got a very good little sheath :)
-
@micky d said:
Thats very true mate, my main problem with leather on these shore's (uk) is it's very easy for the leather to become saturated, and takes an absolute age to dry out again ::)If treated with SnoSeal (or a similar quality leather preservative) a leather sheath shouldn't become saturated from rain or brief immersions in water. If it becomes saturated with water, it means it hasn't been treated properly.
I have leather sheaths over twenty years old. They've seen lots of outdoors use in every kind of weather and are still going strong. They all get SnoSealed at least once a year, and more often if needed. Good leather, if kept properly treated, will last a long time.
If you're going to be in the water a lot - fishing, caving, duck hunting, etc. - where the sheath will be frequently immersed, then leather obviously isn't the best way to go.
.
-
@Defender said:
Plus leather retains moisture on the tool or knife, increasing the likelihood of rust or corrosion. I got a vintage Cold Steel tanto a year or so ago that had never been used, but the blade was a mess because it had been stored in leather.Besides, if it's cold enough to crack kydex outside, I doubt I'd be out there myself! :o :ahhh
Def
A cautionary tale about Kydex:
A buddy of mine lost a fairly expensive custom knife due to Kydex sheath failure during a winter backpacking trip. He was seriously bummed out when he went to use his knife and discovered it missing!
Temps had been ranging from -10F lows to +15F highs for several days. The Kydex had cracked all the way through and released the knife at some point during the afternoon walk, because he remembered having used it at lunch.
He almost decided to backtrack along the trail to try to find the knife, but didn't because it was basically hopeless due to the depth of snow.
.
-
We have that kind of weather here too- I call those "Inside Days." If God (or Darwin) had wanted me to go out in that weather, I'd have fur as thick as my husky's!
I've been out in it, I've worked out in it, and I've even come home and had my uniform frozen to my skin, and I figure I've done my time in it! And, I've been out in even worse than that, and so my rule is now that I just don't go out in that weather!
Besides, anything other than a fixed blade knife is virtually useless at those temperatures. You may get away with operating a set of pliers like on the PowerLock, but one handed opening blades and other implements are pretty well negated by thick gloves or mitts.
Def
-
@ringzero said:
A cautionary tale about Kydex:A buddy of mine lost a fairly expensive custom knife due to Kydex sheath failure during a winter backpacking trip. He was seriously bummed out when he went to use his knife and discovered it missing!
Temps had been ranging from -10F lows to +15F highs for several days. The Kydex had cracked all the way through and released the knife at some point during the afternoon walk, because he remembered having used it at lunch.
He almost decided to backtrack along the trail to try to find the knife, but didn't because it was basically hopeless due to the depth of snow.
The F1 sheath i have from Fallkniven (as mike will know) shouldn't be a problem in cold conditions even if the kydex did break as the knife is held in by a nylon (i'm guessing) bit at the top too.

-
I'm pretty sure it's abs plastic on that sheath mate, I don't think the swedes would make a sheath outa some brittle plastic given how cold it gets out there :o
-
Is it not kydex? my bad! but the point still stands....i think!
-
@Defender said:
We have that kind of weather here too- I call those "Inside Days." If God (or Darwin) had wanted me to go out in that weather, I'd have fur as thick as my husky's!I've been out in it, I've worked out in it, and I've even come home and had my uniform frozen to my skin, and I figure I've done my time in it! And, I've been out in even worse than that, and so my rule is now that I just don't go out in that weather!
Besides, anything other than a fixed blade knife is virtually useless at those temperatures. You may get away with operating a set of pliers like on the PowerLock, but one handed opening blades and other implements are pretty well negated by thick gloves or mitts.
Def
It's all in the gear, Def! Given the right gear, winter backpacking, snowshoeing, cross country skiing, etc. can make for very enjoyable recreation. In some ways it's more comfortable than summer. I almost always sleep better and more comfortably on winter trips.
The best part for me is that there are zero bugs! You can usually put on enough clothes to stay comfortable. In summer, often you can't take off enough clothes to stay comfortable.
Plus, in wintertime, you generally have the trails all to yourself.
.
-
-
@micky d said:
I'm pretty sure it's abs plastic on that sheath mate, I don't think the swedes would make a sheath outa some brittle plastic given how cold it gets out there :oSwedes, Finns, and Russians have traditionally been good at manufacturing things that won't fail due to the cold.
I wouldn't expect cold weather failure in a sheath from any of those countries.
.
-
Not out here it's not. Inland winters are nicer than they are on the coast. The recent blizzard that hit much of the eastern US also hit us, but while everyone else has nice fluffy snow as a result, we have wet ice and slush everywhere. It was colder where I grew up than it gets here, but I'd take that winter over this one any day! Here any layers you wear get wet and you'll freeze to death much faster than you will anywhere else as a result.
We have less snow now than we did before the blizzard hit, because it turns to freezing rain here.
I plan on doing a comparison shortly about which tools are best with gloves- I'll try to film some of it and we'll see what works and what doesn't! :D
Def
-
@micky d said:
, hmm it think I bought it late spring early summer time in 2007 so it's almost certainly zytel then :)Been looking over that forum and i would have to agree with you, mainly due to daming evidence! Here's a link to a topic with a pic of the kydex sheath, its completely different to the zytel one.
http://knifeforums.com/forums/showtopic.php?tid/805314/ -
@Defender said:
Not out here it's not. Inland winters are nicer than they are on the coast. The recent blizzard that hit much of the eastern US also hit us, but while everyone else has nice fluffy snow as a result, we have wet ice and slush everywhere. It was colder where I grew up than it gets here, but I'd take that winter over this one any day! Here any layers you wear get wet and you'll freeze to death much faster than you will anywhere else as a result.We have less snow now than we did before the blizzard hit, because it turns to freezing rain here.
I plan on doing a comparison shortly about which tools are best with gloves- I'll try to film some of it and we'll see what works and what doesn't! :D
Def
Yeah, I agree that winter rain can be miserable.
32F and 100% humidity can feel far colder than 10F and 20% humidity. The higher humidity reduces the efficiency of insulating layers.
I've been on a few winter trips where it rained or sleeted for days. I was able to stay warm, but when you have to constantly fight the weather it doesn't make for the most pleasurable outing. Luckily, winter rain isn't that common in the areas I favor for backpacking.
Having decent rain gear can be a matter of life and death in wintertime.
.
-
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login