Super DIY SAK Liner Cutter
-
I dreamed this up while stuck in a boring meeting, and it took most of today to prototype, but this thing works!
I was spending a loooong time hand cutting a liner with a jewlers saw and hand finishing, and well, I was never really satisfied with the final result anyway. There had to be a better way! But how??? :ahhh :ahhh
In wood working I use a router and pattern bit to make copies of parts, so this is bascially the same idea, but with some challenges. I couldn't clamp the parts down so I had to come up with a way to hold the pattern and work piece stable, level and a fixed distance from each other. There is also no pattern bit with a bearing at 1/8 size that I'm aware of.
Anyway, here's what I came up with. It looks rough at this stage since I just used carpet tape to hold the parts together, it will be properly bolted in the end.
Here's my dremel with a carbide straight cut bit and router attachment. I had to use a diamond file to score and snap the bit in half as the cutting portion was twice as long as I needed it to be.
Here's the fancy templating bracket system. 1/4 inch polycarbonate pieces with bolts coming up from the bottom part (which is drilled and tapped), through the cut material and template (2 stock SAK liners). The top provides a nice level surface to move the router around and not catch on the top of the bolts. This was the part that took me the longest to figure out. Using nuts and bolts keeps everything nice at tight.
Routing in action. This works by having the bare part of the bit with no cutting teeth ride along the template, while the cutter part cuts the work piece to the same shape.
Example of a roughly cut piece with proper holes drilled, the template, and finished copy. What I'm doing here is that I want a nice thick template so my first cut was to make a template copy out of 1/4 polycarbonate, which in turn will get used to make the new metal liners.
I'm glad this worked out, you have no idea how fiddly this was to come up with and implement. It should save significant time for me now though. The procedure will be to rough cut liners from brass/aluminum/titanium then drill all the holes. Then I just have to stack up a couple parts to cut, and route! The ultimate test of course will be to compare a finished liner to a stock one and have it be 100% exact, but I'm optimistic this will work! :D
I thought I should share this to help others who also hate liner making by hand! :D
Cheers!
Edit: Original pics from this post lost, but it was before I started using a proper router, and was using a dremel with router stand instead.
-
Congratulations. You've created great jig. I had to do the same thing all the time when I built furniture. 3 hours of laying out everything and figuring out the jig to cut out 2 pieces that take 15 minutes to cut.
-
I like it.

-
Looks good!
Probably a real time saver in the end if you do multiples. -
Yes, it'll save me lots of time and aggravation. You guys that saw cut liners and have them look good have my respect, its a skill I just dont have the energy to develop, but template routing I can do! :D I have a pile of sad looking hand cut liners in the shop that were just a complete waste of time. At least investing time into this I can actually use it to knock out a bunch of brass liners fast. I should be able to cut a few at once I hope, Im short about 40 liners for mods so I had to figure something out.
-
very nice! i guess you can also make scales using that setup! very clever

-
@Sidhartha said:
very nice! i guess you can also make scales using that setup! very clever
Yep, its what I'm going to be making do with until I get my CNC mill. Poor mans manual 2D CNC! :D I can make holes in the bottom plate to accommodate different parts to copy... 84, 91, 93 liners and then the scales will fit too since the holes are the same. At least this is my plan.. i have no idea how many liners I can cut with one carbide bit, but I hope alot. :D
Cheers!
-
Impressive! Looks very good

-
Whoa !! :o that thing is amazing ! great idea

-
Very clever Syph, very clever indeed!

-
This is brilliant! It might even work on titanium as a finishing pass after they are rough cut close to the line instead of the careful hand sanding I've been doing.
-
@bushidomosquito said:
This is brilliant! It might even work on titanium as a finishing pass after they are rough cut close to the line instead of the careful hand sanding I've been doing.Ya it's exactly that careful hand sanding that was driving me nuts. I don't have the precise finishing background you do. My plan is to use the jewelers saw to cut just at the score line when I trace out a scale, and it should trim up really easy. Just 1 mm or so of material should shave right off with a carbide bit no problem. I test cut brass and alum with the bit and it breezed through that. Then hopefully I just need to polish up the edges with fine emery paper.
I haven't got a chance to get back to the shop since, but maybe I'll get some time tonight.
-
For a liner in a 93mm I think .025" CP titanium would be just fine since it's not as structural as the 91 liners and not much harder to trim than aluminum. It's more corrosion resistant and easier to polish than the hard grade 5 stuff I use and you can still call it titanium. Definitely a huge step up from the nickle silver stock liners, especially after a few years around salt water.
Dangit, I have a roto-zip that never gets used and a few chunks of mic 6 aluminum for the rest of the apparatus and I like making specialty jigs for stuff like this. It's only a matter of time before I have to make my own. Looks like a fast way to put enough knives together to fund a CNC mill that can do it even faster.
-
@bushidomosquito said:
For a liner in a 93mm I think .025" CP titanium would be just fine since it's not as structural as the 91 liners and not much harder to trim than aluminum. It's more corrosion resistant and easier to polish than the hard grade 5 stuff I use and you can still call it titanium. Definitely a huge step up from the nickle silver stock liners, especially after a few years around salt water.Dangit, I have a roto-zip that never gets used and a few chunks of mic 6 aluminum for the rest of the apparatus and I like making specialty jigs for stuff like this. It's only a matter of time before I have to make my own. Looks like a fast way to put enough knives together to fund a CNC mill that can do it even faster.
Ya grade 2 stuff is pure Ti right? The G5 alloy is much stronger though?
-
Grade 1 and 2 are pure and work like hard rolled brass. Grade 5 is 6% aluminum and 4% vanadium and it works like spring tempered stainless. An alloy called 3al2.5v is sort of in between and would probably stand up to high speed freehand machining just fine but the Grade 5 stuff just does not like high speed tools touching it without everything being locked down tight and the tool path being very specific without vibration.
As always, anything is worth a try. I should warn you, I was that kid that stayed out of trouble by making suggestions to other kids so they would get in trouble if things went awry. Go ahead and drop that cherry bomb in the sewer. What could go wrong?

-
Well I ordered a small piece of grade 2 Ti to play with, it's a new material for me so I'm curious.
I was just out in my shop and the lexan template isnt going to hold up. I started making a much tougher template from 1/8 flat steel bar stock I had. Harder to work, but this will last a good while. This is what prototyping is all about...and it felt nice to be showered in hot sparks again! lol I got it roughed out, lots of filework left though, and then edge finishing.
-
I've never seen it happen, but they say thin flakes/chips of titanium will catch fire in a nasty sort of way if they get hot enough...
-
@J-sews said:
I've never seen it happen, but they say thin flakes/chips of titanium will catch fire in a nasty sort of way if they get hot enough...Yes, there is that issue too. It burns white hot like a welding arc. I burned up my first belt sander grinding ti and thought the white sparks were cool until the dust built up so much inside that it was basically a pile of thermite burning it's way through the steel sander shell and a 3" thick oak benchtop. It melted the iron pillow block and ball bearing inside the sander like they were made of wax. I actually save the fine oily drill shavings for tinder because one spark hits it and you have a white hot orb that will dry anything out real fast. If you keep the area blown or brushed off and don't let the shavings build up it shouldn't be a problem.
-
I've never seen it happen, but they say thin flakes/chips of titanium will catch fire in a nasty sort of way if they get hot enough...
Yes, there is that issue too. It burns white hot like a welding arc. I burned up my first belt sander grinding ti and thought the white sparks were cool until the dust built up so much inside that it was basically a pile of thermite burning it's way through the steel sander shell and a 3" thick oak benchtop. It melted the iron pillow block and ball bearing inside the sander like they were made of wax. I actually save the fine oily drill shavings for tinder because one spark hits it and you have a white hot orb that will dry anything out real fast. If you keep the area blown or brushed off and don't let the shavings build up it shouldn't be a problem.
Thanks for the tips, that sounds like something I'd do. I like modding SAK knives, not making DIY thermite...lol :D I'll be more prudent about cleaning up my piles of shavings, I often get got up in what Im working on and let things get too messy.
-
Well this is how far I got making my steel template... I peened on a liner to use as a guide and this is after 3 reinforced cutting disks, and 2 grinding bits. Lots more rough shaping to do, then im hoping I can do my carbide cutter trick to shave the last 1mm off or so. If all goes well, this will be the template to make many many liners from. :D

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login