Can Opener Test
-
Short version: Approximately 40 sec in a single try. With a small amount of practice, I could drop 5-10 sec. When we talk about MT's, we recognize they are a trade off, convenience of carry for the efficiency of a dedicated tool. The hand crank can opener is a useful kitchen utensil and so should perform well in a test such as this. However all things considered, 40 seconds kicks it pretty well.
As a sidenote, try opening the #10 can with any other MT can opener. I think you'll see the time required go up by magnitudes of order. My original point was, you're handicapping MT's in a direct comparison to a dedicated kitchen utensil if you don't include the Victorinox opener.
Enjoy the video! :D
Here's pictures of the can lid and edge of can after draining the water.


-
First off, thanks for the video. That was a good test. I think what you show there is a reasonable (not trying for speed records) kind of showing for the tool, and I appreciate you taking the time to make and post it. You should also note you blew the previously posted Army times out of the water with that, and on a #10. Nice.
However, my point in the previous few posts is refuting this statement:
@Mr. Whippy said:
Once you know the technique, it's as fast as the manual crank can opener.And I reiterate that this simply isn't true. That's my only point.
In my tests, I wasn't 'racing'. All those tested were used at a normal pace. I was dealing with how well the tool cut, not my technique. Because I'm pretty sure if I cared to improve my technique in all of them, I could outpace a Vic can opener with the Sheffield 1200E. I'm equally certain that I could (with equal technique in all tools) outpace it with a P-38. This may be because I find backward cutting can openers simply more naturally comfortable, and the forward cutting style of the Vic is excruciatingly awkward to me right off the bat. That in itself might be a function of me being left-handed. I'm not sure. I would be willing to agree that in best conditions, a well-versed user of a Vic could beat me with the Sheffield and maybe with a P-38. Me against me, I'd take the P-38, then the Sheffield before any Vic style opener.
I will say the Vic style (in most of those tested) works better than the hooked bill type on most Leatherman tools (Wave, Wingman, for instance).
I feel fairly certain that knock-offs in the same style as Vics are a fair analogy, but I'll hold final judgement for testing the real deal. I've seen enough of two similar-but-not-same tools performing with fairly different levels of success to put money on an almost-vic being the same as a vic. Anyone who cares to send me a vic for testing may feel free. :D
Here is one minor advantage to the vic style: since it's fairly short, it seems to work better on cans with smaller diameter lids. You don't dig into the side of the can once the cutter pierces the lid. I had this happen with a few of the 'hookbill' type openers. Not enough to do anything more than leave scratches in the side of the can, but somewhat annoying nonetheless. The P-38 has this same advantage.
Anyway, again, I very much appreciate the time test on the Vic.
-
I'll stand by my comments. In comparison to Wenger, Leatherman, SOG,etc, the Vic can opener is equivalent to a dedicated kitchen utensil. 22 vs 40 sec is essentially the same when you look at 2 min, 3 min etc for other style lever openers.
Yes, yes 22<40 but the difference is has no practical significance in any real world setting.
-
Hehehe, where else would people get into argument about can openers. :D
-
Mr. Whippy: On Vic being 'as good as' a crank can opener, I'll just say the numbers don't support your position, IMO.
Also, please note my time on opening a #10 with the crank was about 20. I think you got the 22 from the best time I could find of someone opening a 14oz can with a Vic (22 seconds). I'll try to get a more accurate number on the crank's time when I can get more #10s for testing, but that will be a while since I have no real-world need for cans of that size, and convincing my husband to buy industrial cans of peaches for my crazy doesn't fly real well.
In all seriousness, what would you consider the order of magnitude that WOULD be important? My estimates in my original post assumed either doubling or tripling times. I assumed a best-time from a can opener about 2 to 3 times that of a P-38. I'm pretty sure someone good with one could open a can at the same speed as a Vic. I assumed twice this speed for the Sheffield. If I could open a #10 in 80 seconds with a Sheffield, and I think it seems a reasonable task, that doesn't hardly seem like orders of magnitude longer, if you're arguing that there's no practical difference between 20 and 40.
jzmtl: Where else would you ever get this kind of real-world data on can openers? This here is good stuff, IMO!
Airballrad: It's all about argument while remaining civil. Things can be argued and learned that way, instead of two people stone-walling and just screaming at each other.
-
Hehehe, where else would people get into argument about can openers. :D
With very polite verbal fisticuffs, no less. :D

:D :D :D
-
Let me add a few rebuttal comments here:
-
I cannot think of even one scenario where the difference of 20 sec and 40 sec could ever make a difference, when opening a #10 can (Which, btw, is a very handy size for kennels, stables, boy scout camps etc where large portions are used). Can you? (NB: I doubt it will ever come into play in Iron Chef--cans of stewed tomatoes have never come up as the secret ingredient).
-
In the setting of an individual with rheumatoid arthritis, the handcrank would certainly be more painful and slower than the Vic opener (although an electric can opener would likely come into play)
-
Until you've run your kitchen utensil through a hundred or so #10 cans, this test isn't exactly apples to oranges. I guarantee you the cutting wheel will lose it's edge after a few dozen cans and you may find cutting the lid a bit more difficult. I've never resharpened a can opener, have you?
-
Orders of magnitude generally implies a 10 fold increase in time. Try your Wenger opener on a #10 can, then report back the time and effort involved. I think your opinon of the Vic may be modified.
-
Re: #10 cans vs weeny small cans: More and more, smaller cans (15-16 oz size) are coming with pull tabs, like soup cans. That trend renders your kitchen utensil obsolete. Not so with my Farmer.

:D
-
-
Ermmm .... sorry, can I step in a sec ...
-
Point to Nate here. 20 seconds slower isn't going to make any difference to anyone unless they start selling epi-pens in tins :ahhh
-
Moot point mate sorry. I suffer with my hands and find a conventional crank can opener MUCH easier to use than a SAK
-
Point to Lynn I reckon! Mr W just said that can openers never get sharpened ... yet they keep on working (they do in our house anyway) ... and they're still easier (for me) to use than a SAK after they've done a few years work
-
Until you put that vid up I had no idea whatsoever what a #10 can was ... how popular are they over there? I think I've seen catering sized cans in wholesale stores here, but not in the supermarket
Are you measuring this against something very unusual for most folk? -
Pasta comes in packets, milk in bottles and cooked meats in paper bags ... doesn't make the can opener useless. That's like saying my pen isn't very good because I can't inflate my car tyre with it :D :D :D
Sorry! Carry on guys, as you were ... this is funny

:D :D :D :D
-
-
@50ft-trad said:
Ermmm .... sorry, can I step in a sec ...- Point to Lynn I reckon! Mr W just said that can openers never get sharpened ... yet they keep on working (they do in our house anyway) ... and they're still easier (for me) to use than a SAK after they've done a few years work
But since you don't use it on the thicker steel of a #10 can, you can't appreciate how much the larger cans dull and loosen a crank opener. We've broken or dulled 2 or 3 hand crank openers in 4-5 year period. They just don't hold up well.
These larger sized cans are much more cost efficient if you go through a lot of product (like green beans to dogs, carrots to hide the flavor of medication to horses, etc). Of course, there are industrial can openers for this sort of thing, but that's not really the point to this, is it?
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
@50ft-trad said:
Ermmm .... sorry, can I step in a sec ...
- Point to Lynn I reckon! Mr W just said that can openers never get sharpened ... yet they keep on working (they do in our house anyway) ... and they're still easier (for me) to use than a SAK after they've done a few years work
But since you don't use it on the thicker steel of a #10 can, you can't appreciate how much the larger cans dull and loosen a crank opener. We've broken or dulled 2 or 3 hand crank openers in 4-5 year period. They just don't hold up well.
These larger sized cans are much more cost efficient if you go through a lot of product (like green beans to dogs, carrots to hide the flavor of medication to horses, etc). Of course, there are industrial can openers for this sort of thing, but that's not really the point to this, is it?
Of course not mate ;) -
For the record,
This is the can opener we had in the bakery when I was growing up:

And we opened a fairly large number of #10 cans (condensed milk, fruit, etc)
-
Not sure whether I agree on 20 seconds making no difference. If you open three cans, it'll just make dinner a minute later. Which is of little practical importance. But, let's say you run a kennel and open 10 cans a day (I'm pulling this example out of my a**, I have no idea whether it is reasonable to open those 10 cans, especially since most kennels will have most of the feed in bags), that's 200 seconds a day, or just under three and a half minute. In a month, that will add up to 1:40 of working time. That's real money for a company.
-
Mr. Whippy, how about you go get a EZ-DUZ-IT can opener...
http://www.amazon.com/Made-in-USA-Can-Opener/dp/B007DK6SG0/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1334166298&sr=8-1And I'll get a vic, and then we can have a rational, and hopefully non-biased discussion.
-
@Steinar said:
Not sure whether I agree on 20 seconds making no difference. If you open three cans, it'll just make dinner a minute later. Which is of little practical importance. But, let's say you run a kennel and open 10 cans a day (I'm pulling this example out of my a**, I have no idea whether it is reasonable to open those 10 cans, especially since most kennels will have most of the feed in bags), that's 200 seconds a day, or just under three and a half minute. In a month, that will add up to 1:40 of working time. That's real money for a company.But what about the time you loose when you have to go to the drawer and get (or even worse: search for) the manual crank can opener while your VIC is in your pocket ...
Note to myself: you told yourself to stay out of this and look what you just did ...

P.S. Love the "can opening videos" here ;).
-
Why would** a man** be opening cans anyway??
-
@Top-Gear-24 said:
But what about the time you loose when you have to go to the drawer and get (or even worse: search for) the manual crank can opener while your VIC is in your pocket ...The crank can opener hangs/lies in a fixed spot right where you use it, or has a chain (or is mounted on the wall), and since you always have a SAK or multi-tool on your person, you use that immediately instead of searching for the manual opener which has been removed for cleaning/replacement/whatever. :)
Note to myself: you told yourself to stay out of this and look what you just did ...

You are discussing a hypothetical example meaning to evaluate whether an argument used by the two who actually have done tests have merit. So, not only have you joined the thread, you have joined the meta-discussion instead of the actual topic as well.

-
@Steinar said:
Not sure whether I agree on 20 seconds making no difference. If you open three cans, it'll just make dinner a minute later. Which is of little practical importance. But, let's say you run a kennel and open 10 cans a day (I'm pulling this example out of my a**, I have no idea whether it is reasonable to open those 10 cans, especially since most kennels will have most of the feed in bags), that's 200 seconds a day, or just under three and a half minute. In a month, that will add up to 1:40 of working time. That's real money for a company.To put this in real world scenario, IF I were opening 10 large cans per day at a kennel, I'd purchase the above commercial can opener and never touch a portable hand crank or Vic opener. We had the above opener in my parents' bakery, and it'll rip through a can in 10 sec or less with virtually no effort. (Due to the length of the crank handle).
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
