Which sharpenter system? lanky or Smith's
-
The best tip I have had is to run a marker pen/sharpy over the edge of the blade
This will help you to see where you are removing metal
A good light and magnifier also helps

-
@sparky415 said:
The best tip I have had is to run a marker pen/sharpy over the edge of the blade
This will help you to see where you are removing metal
A good light and magnifier also helps

Good tip also...
Thanks
-
So what exactly is supposed to be happening with the black marked line if i am filing in the perfect angle, i.e. the angle of the factory edge? A line (on the factory edge) may have the width of 2.0mm (milimeters).
If i do one stroke on a precision sharpener (e.g. Lansky system), should the whole 2mm width be affected and get scratched away by the filing movement, or just the very tip (maybe 0.1mm) of the 2mm wide marking?
-
Sorry, I will try to explain
If this is the cross section of a blunt blade and you are sharpening to the exact angle, you will remove the marker and metal (yellow) across all the edge
If you look at the blade from the top (as its in the clamp) you will see a black line where the metal is not touched by the stonedid that make any sense?

-
After it will look like this

-
@kreisler said:
So what exactly is supposed to be happening with the black marked line if i am filing in the perfect angle, i.e. the angle of the factory edge? A line (on the factory edge) may have the width of 2.0mm (milimeters).If i do one stroke on a precision sharpener (e.g. Lansky system), should the whole 2mm width be affected and get scratched away by the filing movement, or just the very tip (maybe 0.1mm) of the 2mm wide marking?
This would mean that you are sharpening too steeply,
On the lansky for example at 30* and it should be about 20* for a SAK
-
well understood, thanks a million for the explanation and illustration!! it's what i had thought and was wondering about. because the 2nd picture shows that very much material has to be filed/ground if one wants to resharpen the edge just a little (after it got less sharp after 1 day of slicing paper for example). however in practice i found out that treating just the very tip of the edge of a dull-ish pocket knife (0.1mm) with a honing rod suffices to make the blade sharp.
mostly i was wondering about the pen marking technique by this guy:
watch from 07:06 to 10:20
who uses 20° on one side and 25° on the other side of the dull edge.anyway. so you're saying that, even on a honing rod, the contact point between rod and knife is the full 2.0 (or 1.0) milimeter line, and not the tip (=point; extreme end of that line)?
There's much material loss then with rounded tips of dull blades (as shown in picture#2)!
-
I just order the Lansky delux 5 stone sharpening system....
Thanks for all jour comments and help. -
I think yoy made a good choice. I can not vow for the other systen as I don't have it.
However I am using the Lansky kit since 1988 and it never let me down. The spares are cheap and freely available, but I never had to replace something yet. The results are consistent. -

My most important lesson, that I learned, is to allways take a picture of each knife you are sharpening whilst in the clamp with the stones set at the right angle, once you find out which is the correct angle to use for sharpening that knife.
That way, next time you have to sharpen that same knife you do not need to go through all the trouble of trying to find which is the right angle for it; you just look at the picture.
This helps a lot if you sharpen several knives.
For example the attached picture reminds me which setting to use for Victorinox knives
:B:
-
Dks, that's a very good idea

@Kreisler
Sadly my German only extends to ' Tri beer bitter' :-[
I don't understand what hes saying but I think his technique is right (I think thats what I do)
I don't understand 20° on one side and 25° :-\Firstly I should have said I'm no expert, still learning and this is all just my understanding :)
Just a couple of things that have popped in to my head
When you use the lansky for the first time on each knife you are re-profiling the edge to suit one of lansky's fixed angles (17, 20, 25, or 30) (The size of the blade also affects the angle)
Also if the blade is blunt you might have to remove a lot of metal the first time you use it
Once you have sharpened the blade for the first time it should be a quick job the next time you do it depending on how bad the blade isOn some bigger knives, as you get to the point of the blade the geometry has changed so I jump up to the next hole
You will understand what I mean as you clean and re-apply the sharpy every few minutes
(this is useful to see if you need to change what you are doing or missing)Also, My picture 'blade after' was just an illustration you should work on both sides at the same time
I don't think you need to sharpen every day if you are cutting paper, I think you should use a strop which 'lightly sharpens' the edge by creating a 'micro bevel' (I think this is what you are doing with your hone)

You keep doing this until the strop doesn't work because the edge is too worn/damaged then you go back to the lanskyHope some of my disjointed ramblings help

-
I spent some time with my new TTi and my spydie sharpmaker last night. The blade was almost factory so it didn't need a lot of work, but my lord, it is now the sharpest blade I have ever owned bar none. Scary sharp, if it so much as looks at armhair, the hair flies off my arm in fear!
-
@Mercury said:
I spent some time with my new TTi and my spydie sharpmaker last night. The blade was almost factory so it didn't need a lot of work, but my lord, it is now the sharpest blade I have ever owned bar none. Scary sharp, if it so much as looks at armhair, the hair flies off my arm in fear!Funny thing those sharpmakers. I use mine at my computer desk when I'm watching shows, and it's deceiving how sharp it is making the knife. I was working on a SwissTool plain blade and every few strokes I would wipe the flat of the blade on the leg of my sweat pants to wipe off any metal filings. Well a few days later I pulled the same pair of sweats out of the clean laundry, slipped them on and walked into the kitchen. My wife says "What happened to your leg?" I looked down and it looked like the leg of my pants had been in a sword fight. And this was just from the sharp edge gliding slightly touching the folds of the material when I wiped the flat side of the blade :o
-
Thanks so much sparky415

I cant wait to get my hands on the Lansky knockoff product!! It's about time to re-profile the edge of so many knives in the household and garage hehe ::)i wont have to resharpen my Spirit (because i'd seldom use the main blade; i mainly use the pliers.. ) but all the many other knives and scythes in the garden :ahhh
-
That's scary! I have gotten pretty good with my sharpmaker, it's an awesome investment.
-
@Turnsouth
:D :D :D@Kreisler
We will need some pictures please and Good luck
-
@kreisler said:
i wont have to resharpen my Spirit (because i'd seldom use the main blade; i mainly use the pliers.. ) but all the many other knives and scythes in the garden :ahhhThat is kooky-talk, Kreisler. The factory edge on any Vic is good, but not great. The angles and consistency are good, but the grind itself is still relatively coarse. Since the steel is on the soft side, you can easily make it twice as sharp. You aren't nervous about using it for the first time, are you? ;)
By the way, I don't think the Lansky system will work well on a scythe or other large edge, as the rods are not long enough.
Lastly, unless your tool needs are vastly different than mine, you'll find you need the knife a lot more than the pliers. That's why I switched to SAKs.
-
cookie talk .. i had to look that up lol
@Smaug said:
You aren't nervous about using it for the first time, are you? ;)haha. got me!! :D
but before i approach the brand-new Spirit edge, i would practice the marker and angle technique with the two crappy 3$ pocket knives i got. also looking forward to making use of my dad's loupe. Okay, for the scythe i'll have the kitchen's steeling rod, no prob. True, in one of his video clips the German academic uses Spyderco Sharpmaker to oversharpen his Spirit X. At the end he slices balled kitchen paper like a tomato, funny.you switched to SAK's.. i see. my daily tool needs are very little and i use (or need) something like a "multi-tool" mostly at home, indoors or around the house; yep and that's typically pliers what i need the most. if my needs change and the minichamp frustrates me ;) , i will think of buying a SAK. I like their price, many 3-5 layer'ed Vinox SAK's cost about the same, in the lower 20's € range. I do need my flashlights daily, i simply luv flashing them >:D
-
A youtube channel of immense interest (actual use of many Japanese and American knives, sharpening, etc.), an authentic man whose life literally depends on his collection of super sharp knives and who has many years of genuine wisdom and true experience, a Japanese who lives in the mountains and is fluent ;) in English. i am in awe :o
http://www.youtube.com/user/virtuovice
may be a descendant of the Samurai

-
@sparky415 said:
@Kreisler
We will need some pictures please and Good luck
Got it today, yay!
I dont have any camera (not even on my old cell phone), sorry.Anyone else interested in the TAIDEA Precision Sharpener, maybe someone wants to review it? The reasons why i got it is obvious, the LANSKY set would have cost me ~50EUR shipped which is the price of Spirit (ebay) or double of the TAIDEA's price.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
