Which sharpenter system? lanky or Smith's
-
i am hooked to this thread. a German academic who knows pretty much all better products and studied the sharpening of knives (he also owns a Swisstool Spirit X!!) is
Am glad that i know some German language.. ::)
He uses lots of Lansky and Spyderco sharpening products. -
Also:
http://www.exduct.com/Special-Limited-Products/SP931D-Precision-Sharpener.htmlsame idea, cheap, should be decent coming from Exduct, diamond stones, I do not know if anybody tried it.
The hones themselves are awesome. Not sure of the exact grit but they made quick work of reprofiling blades however it's downfall is the rail system, made of plastic and would flex too much under use.
The Rods are attached directly via a thread on the back of the hones so they tend to get loose and they don't sit straight. Good for the price but not good in the long run.
From the last q&a on that page:
**
360grit,480grit, 600grit,800grit **Very good coments and options..Thanks,
This exduct system looks good, good price and its diamond stone, but fisrt time I hear about it, there is a good option to try but for know I believe I will go for the Lansky. -
oops, there is much more to sharpening (it's an art, it's science!) than simply buying a fool-proof Smith's, Lansky's or portable knife sharpener. without knowing what you're doing and why, you would could do more harm than good to the edge.
today in the afternoon i found a steel rod in a kitchen drawer and did some simple tests with it on old pocket knives and kitchen knives, and a Ganzo MT. The manufacturing quality of the Ganzo factory edge is a disaster and there was no way to get a perfect 50/50 edge along the blade. i managed to sharpen the knives with free-hand steeling (in a similar uneducated manner as most teenagers on youtube demonstrate their sharpening skills), so i am good. However, i dont really dare to touch up a Swiss made factory edge (which is very sharp already) of the Spirit without knowing anything about it. The above German link is quite helpful; it even points to literature (books on sharpening knives) and has lots of serious videos.A great series of serious videos on sharpening by a real pro is:
http://www.youtube.com/user/MrEZCooking/videosI guess that the subject of sharpening was already discussed at length on this forum and for sure on the many many knife forums on the WWW (i am not going there). Am just saying that restoring the super sharp Spirit edge is a challenge and not as simple as buying a 50$ Lansky kit and following generic instructions from the product manual.
Once one knows the fundamentals, has acquired the practical skills and got all sharpening tools (e.g. in a semi-professional set/kit), one could easily sharpen anything in the household: scythes, scissors, kitchen cutlery, lawn mower, pocket knifes, serrated blades, the special tools of a SAK and SwissTool, etc.
The most general sharpener seems to be the handheld rod and one would want/need different types and coarseness (steel, ceramic, diamond).Gosh.. restoring the Spirit factory edge (i.e. a precision 50/50 grind) with such quality tools could easily cost more than the cost of a new Spirit!
i think i will get just 1 fine "DMT Diafold Serrated Knife Sharpener"-type of rod or the Smith's PP1. Personally i have only very few blades to maintain (Spirit, Minichamp, old pocket knife).. so getting a Lansky or even the Spyderco system is outta line. Maybe i dont even need to resharpen these few blades. Wishful thinking.
Reminds me of flashlights and the topic of rechargeable batteries and their chargers, a wide topic and some users dedicate much much energy and money in it.
Is the Smith's PP1 more or less sufficient for MT's like the Swisstool or does it barely restore the Vic factory edge?
-
The 20 degree setting on the lansky works fine on the Victorinox knives. As long as you take your time and regularly check the edge as you sharpen it's reasonably easy.
Victorinox 111mm Lansky sharpening angle
I got 3 used Victorinox 111mm locking knives, 2 rucksack and a cowboy (pictures later). Their blades could do with some sharpening, so, from anybody using th...
Multitool.Org Forum (forum.multitool.org)
-
If Ganzo is the manufacturer of many rebranded MT's which are sold worldwide, then Taidea might be the manufacturer of sharpening systems which are sold worldwide, possibly rebranded as Lansky or Smith's. For this assertion to verify or check upon, please go to:
http://www.taidea.com/download-3.html ("No. 50", Operation: Down)In the downloaded 2012 PDF catalog browse thru the pages and you'll recognize quite a few products which are sold by Lansky and Smith's (and similar products are seen in Gerber's, Buck's and Schrade's catalog .. so it is rather unclear who the real originator of a particular product model is). Maybe these are knockoff's, maybe not.** If nobody can prove me wrong, i will from here on assume that Taidea is the OEM of some of the products in Lansky's and Smith's sales program.**

If you examine the very professional looking website of Taidea, then it becomes clear that this is a serious big company specialized in manufacturing (or providing) a large variety of nice-looking sharpening tools and i would readily assume that they are, like Ganzo, an original manufacturer or designer of the products which are then rebranded by others, incl. Exduct!
In any case i ordered this here (the shipping costs include tracking number):
http://www.exduct.com/Taidea-Sharpeners/T0931D-Precision-Sharpener.htmlOn the product photos it looks like well-built stuff and Dinodirect, which was one of my favorite flashlight sellers last winter, charges up to 165.99US$, how crazy is that? For our info, on the WWW there was already some talking and even a passaround (which i should have read before placing the order lol; i will read the thread tomorrow).
Once i receive the product and have tested it, i will report back here and let everybody know what i think about this product. Actually i was about to order the Smith's CCD4 3-in-1 sharpening system off ebay but the total would have been the same (~31US$). If the Taidea (rebranded Exduct) system really works well and is of high built quality, then no doubt it beats the Smith's CCD4 at the same price!
-
@dks said:
The 20 degree setting on the lansky works fine on the Victorinox knives. As long as you take your time and regularly check the edge as you sharpen it's reasonably easy.
Victorinox 111mm Lansky sharpening angle
I got 3 used Victorinox 111mm locking knives, 2 rucksack and a cowboy (pictures later). Their blades could do with some sharpening, so, from anybody using th...
Multitool.Org Forum (forum.multitool.org)
Wise words, no matter what system you are using or what blade you are using it on.
-
The 20 degree setting on the lansky works fine on the Victorinox knives. As long as you take your time and regularly check the edge as you sharpen it's reasonably easy.
Victorinox 111mm Lansky sharpening angle
I got 3 used Victorinox 111mm locking knives, 2 rucksack and a cowboy (pictures later). Their blades could do with some sharpening, so, from anybody using th...
Multitool.Org Forum (forum.multitool.org)
Wise words, no matter what system you are using or what blade you are using it on.
Good to know, I have a few Victorinox I would like to re-sharpining for first time.
-
The best tip I have had is to run a marker pen/sharpy over the edge of the blade
This will help you to see where you are removing metal
A good light and magnifier also helps

-
@sparky415 said:
The best tip I have had is to run a marker pen/sharpy over the edge of the blade
This will help you to see where you are removing metal
A good light and magnifier also helps

Good tip also...
Thanks
-
So what exactly is supposed to be happening with the black marked line if i am filing in the perfect angle, i.e. the angle of the factory edge? A line (on the factory edge) may have the width of 2.0mm (milimeters).
If i do one stroke on a precision sharpener (e.g. Lansky system), should the whole 2mm width be affected and get scratched away by the filing movement, or just the very tip (maybe 0.1mm) of the 2mm wide marking?
-
Sorry, I will try to explain
If this is the cross section of a blunt blade and you are sharpening to the exact angle, you will remove the marker and metal (yellow) across all the edge
If you look at the blade from the top (as its in the clamp) you will see a black line where the metal is not touched by the stonedid that make any sense?

-
After it will look like this

-
@kreisler said:
So what exactly is supposed to be happening with the black marked line if i am filing in the perfect angle, i.e. the angle of the factory edge? A line (on the factory edge) may have the width of 2.0mm (milimeters).If i do one stroke on a precision sharpener (e.g. Lansky system), should the whole 2mm width be affected and get scratched away by the filing movement, or just the very tip (maybe 0.1mm) of the 2mm wide marking?
This would mean that you are sharpening too steeply,
On the lansky for example at 30* and it should be about 20* for a SAK
-
well understood, thanks a million for the explanation and illustration!! it's what i had thought and was wondering about. because the 2nd picture shows that very much material has to be filed/ground if one wants to resharpen the edge just a little (after it got less sharp after 1 day of slicing paper for example). however in practice i found out that treating just the very tip of the edge of a dull-ish pocket knife (0.1mm) with a honing rod suffices to make the blade sharp.
mostly i was wondering about the pen marking technique by this guy:
watch from 07:06 to 10:20
who uses 20° on one side and 25° on the other side of the dull edge.anyway. so you're saying that, even on a honing rod, the contact point between rod and knife is the full 2.0 (or 1.0) milimeter line, and not the tip (=point; extreme end of that line)?
There's much material loss then with rounded tips of dull blades (as shown in picture#2)!
-
I just order the Lansky delux 5 stone sharpening system....
Thanks for all jour comments and help. -
I think yoy made a good choice. I can not vow for the other systen as I don't have it.
However I am using the Lansky kit since 1988 and it never let me down. The spares are cheap and freely available, but I never had to replace something yet. The results are consistent. -

My most important lesson, that I learned, is to allways take a picture of each knife you are sharpening whilst in the clamp with the stones set at the right angle, once you find out which is the correct angle to use for sharpening that knife.
That way, next time you have to sharpen that same knife you do not need to go through all the trouble of trying to find which is the right angle for it; you just look at the picture.
This helps a lot if you sharpen several knives.
For example the attached picture reminds me which setting to use for Victorinox knives
:B:
-
Dks, that's a very good idea

@Kreisler
Sadly my German only extends to ' Tri beer bitter' :-[
I don't understand what hes saying but I think his technique is right (I think thats what I do)
I don't understand 20° on one side and 25° :-\Firstly I should have said I'm no expert, still learning and this is all just my understanding :)
Just a couple of things that have popped in to my head
When you use the lansky for the first time on each knife you are re-profiling the edge to suit one of lansky's fixed angles (17, 20, 25, or 30) (The size of the blade also affects the angle)
Also if the blade is blunt you might have to remove a lot of metal the first time you use it
Once you have sharpened the blade for the first time it should be a quick job the next time you do it depending on how bad the blade isOn some bigger knives, as you get to the point of the blade the geometry has changed so I jump up to the next hole
You will understand what I mean as you clean and re-apply the sharpy every few minutes
(this is useful to see if you need to change what you are doing or missing)Also, My picture 'blade after' was just an illustration you should work on both sides at the same time
I don't think you need to sharpen every day if you are cutting paper, I think you should use a strop which 'lightly sharpens' the edge by creating a 'micro bevel' (I think this is what you are doing with your hone)

You keep doing this until the strop doesn't work because the edge is too worn/damaged then you go back to the lanskyHope some of my disjointed ramblings help

-
I spent some time with my new TTi and my spydie sharpmaker last night. The blade was almost factory so it didn't need a lot of work, but my lord, it is now the sharpest blade I have ever owned bar none. Scary sharp, if it so much as looks at armhair, the hair flies off my arm in fear!
-
@Mercury said:
I spent some time with my new TTi and my spydie sharpmaker last night. The blade was almost factory so it didn't need a lot of work, but my lord, it is now the sharpest blade I have ever owned bar none. Scary sharp, if it so much as looks at armhair, the hair flies off my arm in fear!Funny thing those sharpmakers. I use mine at my computer desk when I'm watching shows, and it's deceiving how sharp it is making the knife. I was working on a SwissTool plain blade and every few strokes I would wipe the flat of the blade on the leg of my sweat pants to wipe off any metal filings. Well a few days later I pulled the same pair of sweats out of the clean laundry, slipped them on and walked into the kitchen. My wife says "What happened to your leg?" I looked down and it looked like the leg of my pants had been in a sword fight. And this was just from the sharp edge gliding slightly touching the folds of the material when I wiped the flat side of the blade :o
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
