Do you use two layers models?
-
My first SAK was a Tourist. Still got it, and it does come out to play occasionally.
I really like my 91mm Compact and 84mm Golfer, and the only reason I don't carry my Timekeeper is I don't want to damage the timepiece.
I do have other 2 layer SAKs, but they don't get much glory, purely due to lack of scissors -
I don't like having one knife for around the house and then changing to another when I leave so I pretty much stick with a 2 layer like the Soldier, and supplement as necessary. On my keys I have a Leatherman Style PS for the pliers and scissors and they only go in my pocket when I leave. In the vehicles I have Spirits that rarely need to be used.
-
I carry a Scientist day in, day out. The blade is the most frequently used tool on it by far but the magnifier gets plenty of use and the philips driver is pretty handy too.
I'd consider a three layer for pocket carry but anything bigger I think would bug me.
-
I think 2 layer models can offer a lot. Look at how popular the Cadet is. Even if you are not one that uses the driver layer much, it can prevent you from abusing the blade one those rare occasions you are not thinking and try to do some prying or worse, there-by making the knife last a lot longer. I still like using the bottle opener myself, even with trwist-tops, but that is more of a personal preference. If the secon layer is scissors, well then we have a really nice addition. Even a Executive or classic is really just 2 layers, but more tools because they are double sidded.
So I think lots of good stuff in two layers... I think my next custom needs to be a metal, or other material, handled Compact.
-
@jzmtl said:
I just bought an adventurer, and it got me thinking. On the two layers models, you don't really gain many useful functions compare with a regular folder, you get the openers, but really how often do they get used? However you lose many conveniences like quick and easy access/deployment. With the addition of a third, maybe 4th layer, that's when you really get useful tools added.I disagree.
I agree that the openers don't get used that much, but the screwdriver tips on the openers get used a LOT.
I also feel that a 2 layer SAK (for example) is only a bit thicker than a single layer tactical folder and offers a lot more usefulness.
The tactical guys try to convince themselves otherwise, but it is just not the case, unless you're not handy at all. ;)
-
A little more useful, yes, but the screwdrivers along are not enough to justify losing the quick access features on folders. Quite often when I need to cut something I'm already holding it in my hands, with a folder I can take it out, cut, fold and back in pocket, whereas with SAK I need to either open it beforehand or put the object down (not always possible), then leave it open either in hand or somewhere, just not as convenient or safe.
May have to do with your environment as well, I rarely encounter any screws that the openers will work on.
-
I have less use in my day to day life for a quick access blade than I do for the opener layer tools.
My daily carry at work is a cadet, and I use the drivers quite a bit, and the can opener for pulling staples. The blade is primarily for eating my apple and orange in a more "civilized" manner ;)
I do wish there was an option for a SAK like tool with a OHO blade, but with tools for when you need them. Something like a smaller sized OHT.
I've tried things like the LM wave, but I didn't gel with the tools. The bits were too short, and all tools were almost impossible for me to deploy without using something to pry them out (something I've experienced on every single newer LM I've tried, with the exception of the skeletool...)
Because I haven't come across something that is a good blend of both features, I've stuck with the cadet or alox soldier for carry.
-
@gustophersmob said:
I have less use in my day to day life for a quick access blade than I do for the opener layer tools.My daily carry at work is a cadet, and I use the drivers quite a bit, and the can opener for pulling staples. The blade is primarily for eating my apple and orange in a more "civilized" manner ;)
I do wish there was an option for a SAK like tool with a OHO blade, but with tools for when you need them. Something like a smaller sized OHT.
I've tried things like the LM wave, but I didn't gel with the tools. The bits were too short, and all tools were almost impossible for me to deploy without using something to pry them out (something I've experienced on every single newer LM I've tried, with the exception of the skeletool...)
Because I haven't come across something that is a good blend of both features, I've stuck with the cadet or alox soldier for carry.
Sounds to me like you need to try a Buck X-Tract

-
Al's got a good point. The X-Tract is one of those MTs that didn't appeal until I got to handle one. They really are quite impressive.
Its a locker, so not something I'd buy to carry over here unfortunately. But if I lived elsewhere I'd own one.
-
Spartan a lot of time,the awl/blade/flatdriver are my most used tools actually...and that opener also does a great job on some phillips

+++++you can save the night with the corkscrew
-
Hello,
I have a Midnight Manager in my pocket 24/7 and also carry a Tinker or an Alox Pioneer in my jacket pocket most days.
The Midnight Manager is amazingly useful for such a small knife/tool, I could quite happily carry this fella as my only tool.
But I won't! Heh heh!
-
Big fan of the 2-layer SAKs. Tinker the most, but also Soldier, Scientist, and Pocket Pal. For me, slim is in.
--Larry
-
Yep tinker for me too, great little SAK and i prefer the phillips to the CS, unless on the explorer as that has the inline phillips and the CS is handy for the eyeglass driver ;)
-
@EddieEnzyme said:
I have a Midnight Manager in my pocket 24/7Now THAT is impressive. You must keep it in your pajama pockets while sleeping then? And you wear clothes into the shower too? I won't even comment on lovemaking... :D
-
@50ft-trad said:
I have less use in my day to day life for a quick access blade than I do for the opener layer tools.
My daily carry at work is a cadet, and I use the drivers quite a bit, and the can opener for pulling staples. The blade is primarily for eating my apple and orange in a more "civilized" manner ;)
I do wish there was an option for a SAK like tool with a OHO blade, but with tools for when you need them. Something like a smaller sized OHT.
I've tried things like the LM wave, but I didn't gel with the tools. The bits were too short, and all tools were almost impossible for me to deploy without using something to pry them out (something I've experienced on every single newer LM I've tried, with the exception of the skeletool...)
Because I haven't come across something that is a good blend of both features, I've stuck with the cadet or alox soldier for carry.
Sounds to me like you need to try a Buck X-Tract

@Neil said:
Al's got a good point. The X-Tract is one of those MTs that didn't appeal until I got to handle one. They really are quite impressive.Its a locker, so not something I'd buy to carry over here unfortunately. But if I lived elsewhere I'd own one.
Thanks for the tip, I always had the impression it was a large tool like the OHT. I need to check it out more closely.

-
I have a Midnight Manager in my pocket 24/7
Now THAT is impressive. You must keep it in your pajama pockets while sleeping then? And you wear clothes into the shower too? I won't even comment on lovemaking... :D
It's always in my pocket but I didn't say where the trousers were ;) :D
-
@jzmtl said:
On the two layers models, you don't really gain many useful functions compare with a regular folder, you get the openers, but really how often do they get used?Are you kidding me!? We don't even own a normal can opener in my house, the SAK opener is the only way we open our tins! Likewise bottles of beer! I EDC a farmer, but the saw only ever sees action in the woods, so I'd happily go down to a pioneer/soldier.
-
Two layer SAKs that I own and love are; Vic Compact, Sportsman, Scientist, Cadet, Wenger Commander and SI.
-
Amici,
Don't use anything that small. All by SAK models are a 4 to 8 layer minimum.. I say go with the gusto!Cheers,
Serge -
I'd kill for a reintroduction of the Scientist. A Phillips driver is one thing I'd like to have handy, even though the SD tip on the Classic works VERY well as a 2D Phillips. That, plus the great spearpoint blade would make me a happy camper. Not much else outside those two tools and scissors gets used in my day to day.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login