The Wingman has been shot down!
-
Ugh. I just used the RRT to pry the blade open and it ain't pretty.
Def
Sent from my MB860 using Tapatalk 2


-
This makes me appreciate my Vic stuff even more...

-
That looks pretty grim to me mate. Has ANY other tool you've carried at work corroded that badly? What's tool of choice to replace it?
-
I'm wondering if there is a case of some dissimilar metal corrosion going on here? If the grades of steel are different enough it could be possible I think. Just a stab in the dark.

-
@sawman said:
Have you considered sending it into LM for warranty repair?I probably wouldn't send it in for a variety of reasons like this could be considered abuse, I have other tools so no worries if this one doesn't see any more use and its too much of a hassle since this one is almost cheap enough to be replaced rather than send it in with delivery confirmation, tracking etc.
As for the other tools, the Zilla Jr is the only one I have subjected to vest carry, and it was with me for about a year in my work vest while the Wingman has been riding along for 2-3 months. Usually tools are on my belt in a sheath and rotate but I found myself a few times without a tool and decided to remedy that by assigning one permanently to my vest. Plus when I put on my coveralls it makes the tool on my belt difficult to access but my vest always goes on over top of the coveralls so that means anything in a vest pocket is always accessible.
As for what to replace it with, I haven't decided yet. Ideally I'd like something with a pocket clip so that narrows the choices considerably. I have a spare eClipse somewhere so I could modify a non clip tool into a clip tool if need be. Honestly, I'm giving serious thought to a Spirit or SwissTool, or even my Octane.
Def
Sent from my MB860 using Tapatalk 2
-
I live nowhere near the sea and my wave looked very similar after a week in my slightly damp garage. That was what ended leathermans for me as the go to tool and my full size Swiss tool took over that role.
Complain all you want about slippery drivers, but that polish is there for a reason, and its to provide no micro nicks for rust to even think about grabbing hold of.
I still like and use leathermans too, but I wish they'd use better steel.
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
The Wingman I've had as part of my work gear for the past few months will be retired and replaced as soon as I get home. The Wingman, or should I say Rustman has developed far too much rust for continued use, and if it doesn't get replaced soon, there won't be a Wingman left to use.This isn't another Rusty Leatherman thread, check the photos at the bottom.
It is noteworthy that I live in a very corrosive atmosphere (right on the ocean, with all the rain and temperature changes that implies) and that the Wingman is in my work vest, exposed constantly and put away wet, however the Zilla Junior was my work tool prior to the Wingman's extended sortie and the only significant rusting on it was the screwdriver ends.
This Wingman will be cleaned, oiled and find it's way into the drawer and probably won't come back out any time soon. I'm very disappointed in it.
Def
Sent from my MB860 using Tapatalk 2
What a shame,glad you shared this story,I am just so surprised,and bewilder.
-JS
-
that is not a Wingman...it is a Rustman!
Sorry to hear and see this. If the Tini SOGs were not so hard to find, I would suggest that, as I do think the finish would last in such a harsh environment.
Just be glad you're not made out of stainless Def. :D
-
Mayne not all of me but my left foot has a good chunk of it!
Def
Sent from my MB860 using Tapatalk 2
-
-
@Syph007 said:
Complain all you want about slippery drivers, but that polish is there for a reason, and its to provide no micro nicks for rust to even think about grabbing hold of.I still like and use leathermans too, but I wish they'd use better steel.
I totally agree with you

Grant, that really is a sorry looking tool dude!
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
How many of you regularly spray down your monkey wrenches after each use?Mine get enough motor oil and grease on them it's like they are constantly being oiled. :D
Maybe you should try some of that ceracoat stuff, consider wingman is already much more polished compare to other LM, pretty much as slick as swisstool.
Or some tuff cloth, people use them always praise how they keep protecting even long after application.
-
That is tragic man. I'm sorry to see that it rusted on you. On the plus side, I won't cost $100 to replace.
Maybe it's time for Leatherman to look into using some H1 steel (a la Spyderco and Benchmade in some of their blades). I wonder if H1 would work well or be cost efficient in a multitool form factor? It presumably wouldn't rust.
I've always had a gut feeling that the shiny Vic Spirit steel would do well in a more humid or corrosive environment.
-
Just yo emphasize some details here- this tool is still functional. It needs to he cleaned and oiled but I doubt there is any permanent damage, so I won't be replacing it or sending it in for repair or replacement.
The reason this is going off duty is because prolonged use in my environment would be detrimental to it. Being on my work vest it gets exposed to sea air, salt spray, heavy rains, wind, snow and radical temperature shifts. And, unlike a tool kept safely in the sheath under a coat, it's right out in the open getting wet, getting sprayed, heating up in the sunshine and cooling down in the wind. This is something of an extreme situation for a tool.
That having been said, the Wingman, regardless of treatment has failed me as an EDC model. That isn't to say its a bad tool or that people should avoid it or Leatherman sucks or anything like that. Yes, I could try Tuff Cloth, yes, I could spray it with oil every night or I could keep it in a temperature controlled humidor and sing softly to it before I go to bed.
What I am saying is that this tool is simply not the right one for this application or circumstances. I am disappointed in it but these things happen. For folks who want a tool they don't have to think about or baby, this may not be your thing. I want a tool that can stand up to what I do on a daily basis and I don't have to worry about it- and it has to be ready when I am. It's a good thing I didn't need the blade today though..... of course if I did then I could have just reached for my Compact- after all, two is one, right?
Def
Sent from my MB860 using Tapatalk 2
-
Dang, did you type all that on your phone? Would've taken me ages.
-
Sadly I did.... my thumbs are about to fall off!
Def
Sent from my MB860 using Tapatalk 2
-
This is one thing that makes me appreciate living in Calgary. It's absolutely bone dry, which causes dry skin and nosebleeds but I couldn't get something to rust that badly if I tried.
-
Bummer about the Wingman Grant. I am not a fan of that tool to begin with, but seeing it rust like that with the level of polish it has is just disappointing.
In Leatherman's defense though, I have carried plenty of their tools for years now, and I live in a VERY humid environment. My tools all live in leather sheaths, and I don't clean them every day or even every week. My hands are sweaty most of the time, and I don't wipe the tool off before stowing it in the sheath. I get them wet all the time. I have never had one develop any rust that would have bothered me. Hell, I kept my sideclip in the rear pocket of my pants for a year, and that is one sweaty place. Not a speck of rust. My Charge has recently seen a full dunk in water, and I forgot about it in it's sheath for two days before cleaning it back up. No rust.
The only Leatherman I have had rust on me to the point it bothered me was my C33X. That blade lived in my right rear pocket every day for three months, and was flecked with rust by the end of the second week. But not near as bad as your Wingman Grant. I guess your environment is pretty extreme!
Sorry about the rant, and it wasn't due to your post Grant, I just get so sick of seeing Leatherman bashed by users here saying "Leatherman's rust, shoulda bought a Vic". That's akin to saying "A gerber pinched me once, I'll never buy another".
I use Leatherman products daily, and always will. I also use Gerber and Vic products. Each has their shortcomings, and none is definitely better than the others overall.
-
Have you considered your acidic abrasive personality as the root cause of the problem -

I do think that a TiNi SOG P3 would be a good test candidate in your vest. You just need to figure out the pocket clip part.
Bruce
-
Here's a photo of me that my boss took at work the other day:

In my right pocket you see my tape measure with eClipse pocket clip while on the left you see my Fisher Bullet, Photon Proton and Wingman. You can see how exposed it is there, and I spend hours at a time out in the weather.
Maybe the Wingman is the right tool for the consummate indoorsman? :D
Def
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login