My Leatherman post #2
-
@dks said:
A question: Are victorinox plier's heads cast or forged??
(Forging could also be done with a machine, by the way, not with a blacksmith using an anvil)Damn good question

@Mr. Whippy said:
@50ft-trad said:
Agreed. Even if you didn't belt it with a hammer it would still likely have been subject to shock loading and castings don't tend to like that, their grain sturcture just isn't up to it (they're not as bad in compression, but poor with bending/tensile/torsional forces). Forged heads would be altogether a different matter, but we'd all be paying a massive premium on our multitools if that was the case. Also, I personally wouldn't feel comfortable sending it in as I would feel that I was at fault rather than the tool ... but your views may differ of course

I will be sending this in. To me, if you market something as a pair of pliers, it should function like a pair of pliers. Holding a nail (or screw) as you drive it to keep it straight is a pretty standard function of a pair of pliers. If I were using the pliers as a drift, or prybar, I'd agree with you. However, grabbing and holding something firmly is well within the description of what one does with a pair of pliers.
BTW, to finish the job, my wife tossed up and old pair of cheapo cast pliers I've owned for 30 years. No problem with those. ;)
I think the thinness of the jaws at that point really concentrates the forces there. I am likely the unusual case in that I use my Charge nearly every day in a hard use capacity. Numerous cycles of loading and unloading tends to form microcracks in cast parts, which lead to sudden failures like this.
Fair play to you mate
If you feel that you used them in a way you think they should perform comfortably, then yeah they should go in :)As an aside, stress cracking / fatigue generally tends to look different if that's the case, you tend to have a smooth shiny (almost like rippled or volcanic glass) part to the fracture where the crack has been opening and closing against itself and extending into the parent metal, then a more crystalline part where the actual final break occurred. If it's a crystalline break throughout, it's generally a more acute failure in my experience, even on castings. Occasionally a crystalline appearance with colour variations across the break can indicate something taking a little longer to develop.
Anyhow .... My views of not sending it in are purely based on my own expectations from a given tool, not a reflection of your use
Maybe I feel that way with this partly because I know if I did that, I probably would have brayed them repeatedly with a hammer 
-
@50ft-trad said:
A question: Are victorinox plier's heads cast or forged??
(Forging could also be done with a machine, by the way, not with a blacksmith using an anvil)Neither would be my guess, for sure not cast. I would guess they are stamped out of sheet stainless like every other part they make, then riveted together.
-
If the sheet is pressed with rollers can they be considered "forged", at least strength wise? (like Sandvic mora steel)
-
@dks said:
If the sheet is pressed with rollers can they be considered "forged", at least strength wise? (like Sandvic mora steel)Forging and rolling are two methods of hot working and for the purposes of this discussion have similar effects on the grain structure of the metal. If they are cut from a rolled material, they will have a better grain structure than cast, but not necessarily as good as a closed die forging
-
..so the conclusion is that Victorinox pliers should be a lot tougher than LM ones! (..and I use an ST300 >:( ) :D
-
If the ST300 are cast, and the Vic's are forged or via stock removal from rolled plate that's certainly leaning in the Vic's favour - depends on materials used and heat treatments and such too though
-
Where is nutnfancy with a destruction test when you need him... :D
-
I would agree. If the Vic pliers are forged, they are definitely a stronger pliers design.
BTW, I know Leathermans are cast because my brother was a chemical engineer at a precision casting compony (NOT Precision Cast Parts, btw) when they were manufacturing pliers for Leatherman. In fact, he was the project engineer when the plant was moved to Mexico for casting (Leathermans stuff for one, but other things too).
-
From the surface markings (and price, remember how much wire EDM cut multitaskers cost even though they are made in China), I'd say Vic pliers are cast as well.
-
My understanding is that almost all MT pliers are cast, with Multitasker being the exception.
-
Didn't realize that LM plier heads were cast. I'm surprised any premium tool would be cast, as it is such a terrible production method. Sort of a bummer, but oh well.
-
Leatherman plier heads may be cast, but they have been performing in their intended function for more than 25 years. There are plenty of cases of them breaking, but they are not dedicated tools and should not be classed in the same league. Multitools are a compromise between function and convenience. Like others have said, if we had a forged head tool we would not be able to afford it!
Nate's tool broke doing something that any Multitool user would have done, and I agree with him that it shouldn't have. That's what the warranty is for. Let's not start bashing cast plier heads, because all the good MT's have them.
-
So just how many pics have we seen of broken Swisstool/Spirit broken plier heads ?
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
So just how many pics have we seen of broken Swisstool/Spirit broken plier heads ?
It's hard to really grip down on them. They're too slippery.

Boom tish :D

Seriously I think Victorinox suffers less broken pliers then Leatherman , I think I've only ever seen one photo of a broken Swisstool and the guy had used it while welding

-
@Mr. Whippy said:
So just how many pics have we seen of broken Swisstool/Spirit broken plier heads ?
It's hard to really grip down on them. They're too slippery.

Boom tish :D

Seriously I think Victorinox suffers less broken pliers then Leatherman , I think I've only ever seen one photo of a broken Swisstool and the guy had used it while welding

I've only seen a few broken swisstool (big or spirit) plier heads on the interwebz. I have a feeling, however, that it may have more to do with the sheer number of LMs out there when compared to the swisstools than any inherent design or manufacturing differences.
This is coming from a die-hard Vic fan too :o
My be worth bringing up this thread.
-
The number of SAKs pliers tools will/may depend on which continent you are on. Whilst in the American continent there may be more LM tools I do not think that this will be the case worldwide, at least regarding the larger pliers tool, competing with the spirit and the swisstool...
Here a Micra costs 50Euro remember. LM tools are very rare/unknown and considered more of an expensive gadget or fashion accessory. I have not (I think) ever seen anybody carry a LM tool, that was not gifted by me.Any statistics anyone??
-
@dks said:
The number of SAKs pliers tools will/may depend on which continent you are on. Whilst in the American continent there may be more LM tools I do not think that this will be the case worldwide, at least regarding the larger pliers tool, competing with the spirit and the swisstool...
Here a Micra costs 50Euro remember. LM tools are very rare/unknown and considered more of an expensive gadget or fashion accessory. I have not (I think) ever seen anybody carry a LM tool, that was not gifted by me.Any statistics anyone??
50 Euro!? :o I know LM's are expensive, but I believe we get them for about 30, here...
-
50, last time I checked which was a year ago... Only one dealer. The bigger ones (Charge etc) are 100, 150...
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

