Leatherman Micra and Victorinox Midnite Minichamp and ??? Comparison/Review
-
great write up. i carry the micra and luv it but it does have its times where is a pain having to open it to get to the tools inside.
i would like to give the mini champ a go to see how it goes as a replacement for the micra. maybe ill get one and start a pass around one day
-
Excellent comparison dks, and I'd agree that on paper the micra does seem a much more capable tool than a manager or rambler ... but in use I'm with Kirky, and prefer to carry and use the Vics on my keys.
I have a Manager paired up with a Photon light and have found that to be an excellent configuration for me. I do like the Micra, but it's not a tool I'd want to use regularly - inboard tools and chisel grind don't win me over. It's gone in my (Altoids) micro tool tin - the whole purpose of which is a small lightweight kit to carry when I don't expect to need stuff, but I've got a ton of options should I get caught out. For me the Vics make a far better everyday tool, but the Micra is the better tool as part of a small "kit" for occasional use be it an otterbox, altoids tin, or organiser pouch.
As for the minichamp, I've never been tempted to be honest. It's like a manager with a lot of extra stuff, bulk and weight I personally don't need :-\
-
Here is a summary of the Pros and Cons **from the comparison ** and the follow up posts. I tried to keep to 3 Pros and 3 Cons for each though truthfully **they are all quite good ** for what they are.
Leatherman Micra:
Pros:
Better Scissors and screwdriver selection/quality (flats)
More discreet (in silver…)
Tools protected inside the solidly build and scratch resisting handlesCons:
Heavier
Not universally recognisable
Inside opening tools and no pen or light provided – maybe too many flat screwdrivers for a small toolMidnite Minichamp:
Pros:
Universally recognisable
Has a lot of tools including a pen and a light, in a small package
All tools accessible from the outsideCons:
Some of the tools are of limited use (e.g. Cuticle pusher) or unnecessary in a small tool (e.g. second blade)
Too thick and heavy for what it actually offers
The plastic scales can be scratched easily and the tools can get damaged or covered with dirt or fluff since they are more exposed.Midnite Manager:
Pros:
Universally recognisable
Has enough tools, including a pen and a light, in a very small and light package
All tools accessible from the outsideCons:
May be too minimalistic for some people
Possibility of getting damaged if washed.
The plastic scales can be scratched easily and the tools can get damaged or covered with dirt or fluff since they are more exposed. -
Another good SAK alternative to the Micra is the Wenger Pocket Tool Chest (PTC). The two are almost one-to-one in terms of tools/functionality.
I've carried a PTC in my front pocket for about 12 years and use it almost daily. Both are excellent tools (I do have both), but the PTC is noticeably lighter and more "pocket friendly". Also, I like being able to access the tools directly and I get a fair amount of use out of the awl and toothpick.
A good comparison review of the Micra and Wenger PTC were posted on SOSAK Online back in 2008:
-
Great comparison of some useful keychain tools, personally I use Midnight manager and have done for quite a few years now,
I find that the set of tools are a good compliment to full size multi without adding much duplication. I agree with Garth that the ease of assess of the tools on a SAK is better than the micra. I also prefer the feel of it in use, its just fits my hand better.
-
Well, I know that appearance is very subjective, but I actually love the looks of boththe Micra and the Minichamp, but for very different reasons. The Micra looks like a fine piece of well engineered tooling, fit for it's purpose. The Minichamp looks like a sculpted mini pocket tool/knife that exudes quality, precision, practicality, and maximum tool density.
Each has their own particular niche, and so that I am not forced into making carrying decisions that I might regret, I carry both. The Micra on my keyring, and the Minichamp on a longish lanyard hooked around my front belt loop, hanging in my front pocket.
It's astonishing how many different tasks can be completed with one, or both of these two fine tools. -
I've carried either a SOG Crosscut or Micra constantly for about 15 years, and just a week ago switched over to carrying a Rambler.
The blade on the Crosscut and Micra, in theory, should be harder for me to sharpen. In practice, I ran 15 years without needing to sharpen my Crosscut. It was still paper cutting sharp.
What I use the blades for... cutting boxes and letters open, both Micra and the 58mm SAKs work equally well. The scissors are better on the Micra (and Crosscut) for larger/heavier tasks. The SAK scissors are better for fine tasks, in my experience. Both are fine for paper, but as you pointed out, the Micra is faster with more distance per cut.
The drivers on the Micra amaze me every time I use them. They are really solid and surprisingly durable for such a small tool. The little flathead on the end of the file on SAKs is seriously weak in comparison. But the phillips on the SAK is surprisingly capable for its size.
I am NOT impressed by the cap lifters on either, but this isn't an area of critical need. I can waste a few extra seconds making a second and third attempt to pop a cap, since I open 2 caps every 2 weeks.
The files on both the Micra and SAKs suck compared to the file on a Crosscut. The only thing I give the Micra over the Crosscut is that it has a phillips instead of a toothpick. It makes the micra seem much more like a small tool kit over a grooming tool.
I've considered getting a Midnight Manager, for the pen/light, but in truth, what I'd like is Light/Tweezers. I guess a little scale swapping would fix that.
I don't carry the Crosscut/Micra on a keychain, so issues of weight aren't that important to me, but I have to say the Rambler is fine on a keychain. I'm not sure how the scales wear on the SAKs, but the stainless of the Crosscut and Micra make them virtually indestructible.
While I'd like to give a flat-out 'Crosscut beats Micra' statement, I can't. I replaced my original Crosscut with a new one recently, and fit-and-finish has fallen off significantly on the tool. While the scissors are still a little better on the Crosscut, I think the overall winner is the Micra these days. Which makes me sad.
As for appearance... I care not a bit. As long as the tools are not flat-out ugly, I don't judge either. The SAK is certainly more likely to be recognized for what it is. What people think if they see me with a tool is something that doesn't concern me. I'm certain if I pulled my Vic OHO Trekker out, THAT might have some reactions I didn't care for. At this scale, I don't think even the most moronic fear-monger would freak out over the murder-blade on that vicious 58mm assault Rambler.
-
^ that there is a proper post

I've never had a Crosscut - sadly missing from my small tool collection!
Love the Micra, Minichamp and others but the Rambler is my top keychain tool currently.
-
I find it strange that nobody apart from me seems to use the pen on the 58mm much.
It is used more than the other tools... Maybe everybody else carries a pen :DAs a sidenote I now use the plain, no light, Manager as I carry a keychain torch
-
@dks said:
It is used more than the other tools... Maybe everybody else carries a pen :DThis is exactly the case for me. I'm super picky about my pens, and the only commercial ball-point I like is the Pilot Precise V5 (extra fine). So it gets split away from any addition to a Multitool. I can't speak for others in this regard.
-
Yeah, always have a pen. Don't mind a SAK pen as an emergency back up, but prefer writing with something more substantial. Space pen at the bare minimum usually.
I'm a left handed scientist/artist type... need all the help I can to make things legible! ::)
-
I keep losing my pens (BIC... ), but the Manager pen is attached to the keys and thus harder to leave behind...
-
@dks said:
I find it strange that nobody apart from me seems to use the pen on the 58mm much.
It is used more than the other tools... Maybe everybody else carries a pen :DAs a sidenote I now use the plain, no light, Manager as I carry a keychain torch
I actually do use it, quite a lot. Got a signature, and I think that indeed the pen is the most used part.
-
@dks said:
**I keep losing my pens **(BIC... ), but the Manager pen is attached to the keys and thus harder to leave behind...I used to be really bad for doing that as well, right up to the point I got some pens I cared about. I then found myself taking much better care and making sure I kept track of them. :)
-
Really good and comprehensive review! I like the Manager most, ultimate tool setup for a mini multitool. The Phillips screwdriver is the best especially for electronics and such things :D
-
Thanks for the reviews :)
Thanks for taking the time for all the great opinions on either tools. -
I have the minichamp and I can suggest that there are actually 4 screwdriver options on it. You have:
- the philips on the combo tool
- the nail file tip that is great for small screws like those on toys (just like the philips)
- the standard flat tip on the ruler that is good for medium philips or straight slot screws
- the cuticle pusher/drug spoon that can be used for larger slot screws as a last resort, it is last resort as usually for larger screws more torque is needed to break to move. So it may damage your minichamp if you attempt too large screws. The cuticle pusher can also be used as a tiny tiny pry bar.
-
Good to see some new ideas on how to use the cuticle pusher
-
I used to have a Micra on my keys, but I botched it when I tried to mod it. I did not have loki's wrenches and I scratched the screws, and after lots of efforts removing a screw, I could not get it back in because of the backsprings.
I retired it and put a Manager on my keys. Significantly lighter, I still had good scissors, and it also has a pen.
I've since fixed my Micra with my loki wrenches. But I do not like the massive cut-out for the tweezers, especially since the tweezers themselves are sub-par. But I do have a Micra with alumin(i)um handle covers, and I rarely use the Manager's pen anyway, so I might try the Micra again.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
