Can openers: Times on the #10
-
I'm just trying to wrap my head around shoveling down a No.10 can of chili :ahhh :D
-
@Spork, Lord of Lime Jello! said:
I'm just trying to wrap my head around shoveling down a No.10 can of chili :ahhh :DI shoveled down 1/6 of one of the cans. And there are still... side effects. And, it's not even chili... it's just chili beans! Agggg!!! The lengths I go to for insane testing! Now, as I said, my freezer is full of zip-lock bags of chili beans portioned into 15oz servings. So, no need to buy more for... emm.. (do some math)... forever.
EDIT: Funny side note. The only two products in #10 cans that were in my local grocery store were these chili beans, and cans of green beans. Mr. Whippy's dieting dogs would have loved the options. :D
-
Soooo.... I used the can opener on my SOG PPP, which is the same as the can opener on the PowerLock (minus the locking part). This was not a #10 can; just a normal-sized can of beans.
:o :o :o
Oh my, but that thing is useless! I gave up about 1/4 of the way around the can when the opener began to bend the side of the can so badly that I was afraid I'd spill the contents. I have been using LM openers for years without much trouble, and I used the Vic and Boy Scout openers before that. The SOG version was not at all impressive.
-
This should also put to rest the silly notion that keeps popping up: that a Vic can opener is just as fast as a good dedicated can opener like the Swing-A-Way.
-
@smiller43147 said:
This should also put to rest the silly notion that keeps popping up: that a Vic can opener is just as fast as a good dedicated can opener like the Swing-A-Way.Hmm...
Devil's advocate: I can open a #10 can with a vic in less than 1/2 the time posted here. However, what I will say is:
Using the new OXO can opener, I could open a #10 can slightly faster (10-15 sec faster, so around 25-30 sec). It had problems too, mostly where it pushed the metal down without cutting it, requiring a couple more passes in a couple of places.
The effort required to open the can was much less than a Vic tool.
That is as far as I'm willing to concede. (ie, a higher end dedicated can opener is marginally faster and significantly easier than a Vic).
-
I think we could ALL agree that the best answer for both speed and fail-safe operation would be to have both. See? I CAN be diplomatic!

-
I guess its a speed of the operator thing as well then, im going to time me using my PT's can opener and my tinkers as a comparison ,although off to work now :D

-
Any thoughts on using the kitchen can openers/knife sharpeners? I found one quite handy in my kitchen for putting a quick edge on a knife.

-
I use a Zwilling Twinsharp knife sharpener. No power needed. A few passes brings back the edge just fine.
Also, I probably should have put this in this thread. The #10 can tests were part of a larger discussion on can openers in general. Here's a link to that 'main' thread, which links to time tests on both this thread and a thread on 15oz can testing.
</topic/36802
-
@Landrew said:
Any thoughts on using the kitchen can openers/knife sharpeners? I found one quite handy in my kitchen for putting a quick edge on a knife.
The older combo can opener/sharpeners were renowned for overheating the blades and being too aggressive in metal removal. I received an electric knife sharpener from my brother a few years ago and found it was quite good at removing big chips quickly and putting a reasonable edge on the blade. Finishing on a Sharpmaker tuned the blade edge nicely.
In short: I'd be very careful using a non-dedicated electric knife sharpener.
-
I bought an old Leatherman PST original with a broken off blade tip. A little careful work on the power grindstone put the point back to where you probably couldn't tell it from the original without measuring it. The secret was to use short presses on the grinding wheel, allowing it to cool between each pass. No heat discoloration at all.
-
I must be missing something again....compairing apples (swing-a-way) to oranges (multitools)? Is the Tinker 84 or 91mm?
Farmer canopener clearly wins from my experience, it's fastest, long lasting, smooth push cutting, save, no metal shavings,
and above all you can put it in your pocket ::) -
No, the test was comparing can openers to can openers. I had used the Swing-Away as a control, but it was suggested by someone that the victorinox SAK was the best can opener... period (specifically for these big cans).
The Tinker I used was a regular 91mm.
I have since tested the Tinker Small and Farmer. My preference among them is the Tinker Small, because it weighs least, and semees easiest to use. In theory, the thicker stock of the 93mm line should make can opening slightly more difficult, but I didn't notice any difference in practice compared to a 91mm. Although I've never run one vic against another, it's an interesting idea for a test.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
No, the test was comparing can openers to can openers. I had used the Swing-Away as a control, but it was suggested by someone that the victorinox SAK was the best can opener... period (specifically for these big cans).The Tinker I used was a regular 91mm.
I have since tested the Tinker Small and Farmer. My preference among them is the Tinker Small, because it weighs least, and semees easiest to use. In theory, the thicker stock of the 93mm line should make can opening slightly more difficult, but I didn't notice any difference in practice compared to a 91mm. Although I've never run one vic against another, it's an interesting idea for a test.
I hear my memory being invoked...
As an update, I'm on my second Swing Away can opener for the #10 cans. The first one became wobbly in the gear and wouldn't hold on the can edge anymore. I went back to my Vic Farmer (same one) to open the #10 cans. Although the Swing Away is faster (and a bit easier on the hand--but not by much), It's cheaper for me to occasionally touch up the Farmer can opener on a wet stone than buy new can openers every 8 months or so...

-
Yeah, and every tool on the Farmer is top notch (best handle too, beside that sharp eyelet) :D
Edit: I feel the 93 canopener works better then the 84mm because of the larger rake.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
@Mr. Whippy said:
As an update, I'm on my second Swing Away can opener for the #10 cans.Swing Away or EZ-Duz-It? If it's the EZ-Duz-It, that's a bit disappointing.
You are correct. It's the EZ Duz It opener (Amazon.com, made in America). I think it's based on the old Swing A Way opener.
Another thing: If the can rim has a dent in it, the EZ Duz It will ALWAYS jump off there. If there are 2 dents, it becomes problematic getting the lid off.
-
That's a bummer. But, realistically, you're the only person I know that could have tested this. So, I guess Vic wins #10 cans for long-duration.
Wootz, now you've got me thinking I need to compare 93, 91, and 84s. I would have to do it on regular size cans, since I don't get #10 cans, and I'm not sure that would tell us anything useful.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login