Green question:Hard copy vs e-copy
-
I've gone 99% paperless myself, and not for environmental reasons either, both at home and at work. Few things can't be scanned and used electronically I find, and viewed on a smartphone, tablet or PC. Believe it or not, I find it easier to keep track of scanned paper personal documents, than keeping them in a file cabinet at home.
When I started heading up the operations at work, one of the first changes I made was transition nearly everything we did to paperless digital. Everyone uses dual monitors, which is nearly a necessity when doing everything digitally. The only real paper we use is for printing out our final reports (which BTW is being requested less and less by our clients) and the field notes we take out in the field. These are scanned to digital anyway as soon as the crews get back to the office. We also have a custom iPad app in the wings, for taking all our notes digitally in the field. I can see us being virtually 100% paperless very soon.
I don't think I am the only one; printed paper is going out of style fast, and not for the environmental reasons we were preached at for, for all these years. We are improving, but it seems never in the way the social activists would have wanted us to.
-
if your going to read it many times id say a book is more eco friendly but then it depends where the paper came from what sort of ink and all the transportation costs for the various bits. i imagine though it takes alot of books to be put on an ipad to offset the carbon footprint of making one.
One pet hate of mine is over packaging
i bought a wireless xbox headset last year
this amount of packaging for something the size of my thumb is ridiculous in my mind! sorry for poor quality pic

-
@ryan1835 said:
if your going to read it many times id say a book is more eco friendly but then it depends where the paper came from what sort of ink and all the transportation costs for the various bits. i imagine though it takes alot of books to be put on an ipad to offset the carbon footprint of making one.One pet hate of mine is over packaging
i bought a wireless xbox headset last year
this amount of packaging for something the size of my thumb is ridiculous in my mind! sorry for poor quality pic
Its a conspiracy I tell ya!

-
I think when energy to run a device is factored in, there is a tipping point where it's more eco friendly to buy the hard copy. The longer you intend to possess a book, the more you should consider the dead-tree version.
Newspapers, and more ephemeral periodicals are probably better suited to digital from an eco friendly perspective.
However, like others have said already, I got a Kindle, and read books on it, and KEEP books on it. I do this because I realized several things. 1) I have three shelves of books I've collected, and don't use anymore (role playing game books). 2) e-version of those same books cost about 1/3 to 1/4 the hard copy version. 3) within 2 years, the difference in that cost pays for the Kindle, and doesn't leave me with literally a hundred pounds of books I no longer need or want.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
I think when energy to run a device is factored in, there is a tipping point where it's more eco friendly to buy the hard copy. The longer you intend to possess a book, the more you should consider the dead-tree version.Newspapers, and more ephemeral periodicals are probably better suited to digital from an eco friendly perspective.
However, like others have said already, I got a Kindle, and read books on it, and KEEP books on it. I do this because I realized several things. 1) I have three shelves of books I've collected, and don't use anymore (role playing game books). 2) e-version of those same books cost about 1/3 to 1/4 the hard copy version. 3) within 2 years, the difference in that cost pays for the Kindle, and doesn't leave me with literally a hundred pounds of books I no longer need or want.
Hard to imagine anything more eco-friendly than a Kindle. The power consumption is practically nothing. I'm not sure what the eco-footprint for the manufacturing would be, but nothing like what it takes to produce thousands of books.
-
I like paper as much as the next guy (ever try wiping your bottom with a tablet?) but it all depends. If it's something I want with me at all times (like a book I'm reading) then I prefer a digital copy. If it's got technical drawings or some kind of reference material I prefer paper.
Def
Sent from my Motorola Atrix digital multitool.
-
You can't wrap up fish and chips in an iPad.
-
Maybe not, but according to YouTube it makes a great cutting board!
Def
Sent from my Motorola Atrix digital multitool.
-
In general, any life-cycle analysis will be horribly complex. Now, what if the thing you used to read the newspaper electronically had other uses as well? Like, for instance... posting on MT.o, then getting rid of the paper version of the newspaper would be a pure win. I have no idea of the different greenhouse gas budget when absolutely everything is factored in, but I do believe fewer doodads and thingamajigs, but with more capabilities sounds like a way to keep emissions down, but still have nice things. When we compare dead trees and LCDs and e-paper we are comparing three very different beasts. My wife loves her kindle, and here it's simply a question of space. We have the walls covered with double stacked bookshelves already.
I would be very surprised if hardcopy newspapers were greener than e-copy, though. A few horrible factories, supplied by several nasty mines, supply the tablets and whatnots for all the world. Printing presses, newspaper deliveries, producing equipment for printers, ink, etc, is distributed all over the world, close to the reader, so it must be a huge apparatus.
-
Packaging is a huge pet peave for me too.... drives me mad, the amount of crap things turns up in.
As for the OP debate, I use both happily depending on my needs and the application. Never print anything I can look up on my phone, read mostly online and iphone, but for school I have to buy books and write on paper. I like books, but I tend to only buy and keep text books. I recycle everything I can, but the market for that is also controversial as China were buying most of our paper and they don't need it all now... that's a whole other problem! ::)
-
I really much prefer to read on my Kindle than a paper book. Mines one of the older ones, and you can read a few books on one charge, and to charge it doesn't take very long by plugging it in via usb on my computer.
-
I have brought up several times that I'm at that 'my eyes aren't what they used to be' stage. It is a huge benefit to be able to adjust font size on e-books, whereas printing a book in larger font means many more pages, which means more paper, etc.
-
I love ebooks.
The paper/ink on cheap paperbacks makes my skin dry, crack and peel.
Plus, I never have to read into the binding (a problem in thick paperbacks). Overall, I'm a huge fan of e-books.
-
Here where I live we receive 5 or 6 different phone books every year. The books are left at our (rural) mail box. So we do not have a chance to say no to accepting them. I usually keep one small phone book, and have to discard the rest. I probably use the book maybe once or twice per year at the most.
I use my smart phone to look up phone numbers. Plus most cell phone number are not put into the phone book.
I think the phone book printers are the only people who like these books. They make money from printing and selling advertizing in the books.
I think there are most likely a few people who only have "land lines" and still use the books. But it does not justify printing one for every address.
Another example of wasted resources. -
@THE_LONGBOW said:
I think the phone book printers are the only people who like these books. They make money from printing and selling advertizing in the books.
I think there are most likely a few people who only have "land lines" and still use the books. But it does not justify printing one for every address.
Another example of wasted resources.Here the phone books got so unpopular for exactly those reasons they are no longer distributed. The printers tried defending their revenue stream, but when most people are dropping their landlines, their arguments were just too silly.
An interesting effect of mobiles is that nobody remembers phone numbers anymore, since the phone does the work. A little like a large local hosts-file for DNS. I'm pretty certain some telephone company already is trying to figure out making "DNS for phones", i.e. an integrated, cental phone book integrated in the smartphone OS, yet another service they trick people into paying for.
-
My 80smth year old mother-in-law loves her kindle touch that we bought her... it allows her to read lots of books she normally wouldn't be able to due to adjustable text sizing... which is always going to be an issue with paper books... She doesn't own a computer, but brings it to us and we load up several books she's interested in reading and she's good for another while. That's the one thing I'd like to see is to be able to take an e-reader to a shop, and for a fee have them load books on to it. I think this would be very popular with elderly people who aren't bothered with owning a computer with internet access.
We also have an older kindle and my wife uses it to read a lot of the course related reading for her studies... she finds it much more comfortable than sitting at the desktop or elsewhere with the laptop.
Since I got my new Nexus 7 I've been reading a bit more with my tablet than I did with the previous one... also things like Google Currents opened my eyes to a whole different sort of publishing... really looking forward to more E-reading in the future!
-
@Whoey said:
That's the one thing I'd like to see is to be able to take an e-reader to a shop, and for a fee have them load books on to it. I think this would be very popular with elderly people who aren't bothered with owning a computer with internet access.My husband works for a Library system. What that means is multiple libraries work together to share resources, so if library X has a book, or video, then a patron from Library Y can request it, and the system my husband works for is the entity that deal with all the inter-library loans. He's the guy that keeps track of their electronic information. Some of the libraries and library systems have electronic lending, where you can check out books for Kindles and such. What you're talking about is very much the direction libraries are headed. it just takes a little time.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login






