Les Stroud Interview Camillus Booth, Shot Show 2013
-
@Landrew said:
I'll be looking for that north-woods machete, and getting one as soon as it's available.No celebrity endorser I know of would claim to be doing it only for the money, but it boils down to the level of trust and respect you feel that person has earned, whether you take them on their word about an endorsed product or not. Les has earned it all the hard way, unlike some others who appeared to have taken every shortcut money could buy...
If integrity means anything at all, then they couldn't have found a better spokesman.
-
-
So:
Saw
File
Knife
Scissors
Dehooker
Phillips
Flathead
TweezersAnd **SPRING LOADED **pliers.
Looks promising. And the $29 is MSRP I think, maybe we'll see it at lower prices when it hits the stores.
-
It's certainly cheap - looks a little cheap too, but that doesn't mean it won't be worth it

-
-
The styling, multitool, sheath with firestarter and flashlight ... they all look like they're taking Gerber Head on with their BG range. I have absolutely no idea what a "dehooker" is is that a fishing hook remover tool? They've gone straight in with a cheapo multitool with fishscaler

Initial impressions only - and I'll reserve full judgement till I've seen more - but I think I like the BG Strata configuration better. That saw looks tiny! The "signature" knives also don't strike me as being any more special than the BG designs (though lets hope they don't have the same manufacturing issues)
I'll be looking for that north-woods machete, and getting one as soon as it's available.
No celebrity endorser I know of would claim to be doing it only for the money, but it boils down to the level of trust and respect you feel that person has earned, whether you take them on their word about an endorsed product or not. Les has earned it all the hard way, unlike some others who appeared to have taken every shortcut money could buy...
If integrity means anything at all, then they couldn't have found a better spokesman.
Oh, C'mon - Wake up ... it's marketing!!!
An ailing knife maker (or at least one that doesn't have a strong purchase on the market) has enlisted a well known and popular knife user and are paying him money by the van load to be an "ad campaign" for their gear. Les Stroud's popularity does not make the knife any better! Is he willingly going to put his name on a pile of junk - not knowing, of course he isn't ... but he's also openly admitted in another vid he's not a metals man. He knows how to make a good knife pay dividends in the field, he's a survival expert, but hasn't got the first clue about metallurgy and/or manufacturing knives to build a decent knife. If you believe otherwise, you are a PR guys dream customer. This is a very clever strategy by Camillus to try and carve off (pun intended) a slice of the market to boost sales - nothing more
The whole reason manufacturers pay celebrities great swathes of cash is because people will and do believe the con - and people will buy "Les's" knife - when Les hasn't got the foggiest idea about making them. You're playing right into their hands and proving that these silly little mind games that marketing people play really works very well indeed. The deciding factor should be, if it didn't have Beardy's name on it - would ya buy it then?
... Oh, and whether you buy Gerber's stuff because of who they drive a van load of cash to every month, or whether you avoid buying Gerbers stuff for the same reason ... you're still missing the point ... what is the tool like? So far I'm not seeing anything that tells me the cheap knives with the lime green are significantly better than the cheap knives with bright orange
If it had Postman Pat on the handle, the tools wouldn't work any better or any worse

-
It does matter. If you don't have the time or money to test everything out yourself, it makes sense to trust the word of someone who isn't purely doing it for the cash. That's integrity.
-
@Landrew said:
It does matter. If you don't have the time or money to test everything out yourself, it makes sense to trust the word of someone who isn't purely doing it for the cash. That's integrity.I trust the word of many experienced tool owners on this forum - they aren't paid to tell me what's worth buying.
Very few of us have the time or money to test everything, that's one of the main reasons a lot of people come here in the first place.
-
@Landrew said:
It does matter. If you don't have the time or money to test everything out yourself, it makes sense to trust the word of someone who isn't purely doing it for the cash. That's integrity.
No, it's naive and gullible ;) (did you know the word gullible isn't in the Oxford English Dictionary?)You think he's going to say "those two are OK but this one isn't as good as we hoped", or "they are a bit limited but we daren't put the price up to make them better as they won't sell enough units to give me my skip full of cash every month" or "Yeah it's a fishing tool - we cheaped out" :D
He's in it for the cash

It does matter. If you don't have the time or money to test everything out yourself, it makes sense to trust the word of someone who isn't purely doing it for the cash. That's integrity.
I trust the word of many experienced tool owners on this forum - they aren't paid to tell me what's worth buying.
Very few of us have the time or money to test everything, that's one of the main reasons a lot of people come here in the first place.
Absolutely, there are people here I would and do trust - not the guy who's being paid to put his name on it

-
Just a little something to substantiate what I'm saying ... what's that he says in the vid? We're the only folding knife on the market with a firsesteel in the handle? Tool Logic have done it for YEARS ... and they had a whistle and (pretty poor) flashlight on it too. Of course LMF have done it on fixed blades too in their collaboration with Mora(?). So he's either lying or he doesn't know any better. Take your choice on that one, my healthy scepticism remains intact either way :D
Stroud has more applied knowledge in the field of survival that I will EVER possess, I'm not taking that away from the guy - but as regards the products, he's a very highly paid Poster Boy
-
@50ft-trad said:
It does matter. If you don't have the time or money to test everything out yourself, it makes sense to trust the word of someone who isn't purely doing it for the cash. That's integrity.
No, it's naive and gullible ;) (did you know the word gullible isn't in the Oxford English Dictionary?)You think he's going to say "those two are OK but this one isn't as good as we hoped", or "they are a bit limited but we daren't put the price up to make them better as they won't sell enough units to give me my skip full of cash every month" or "Yeah it's a fishing tool - we cheaped out" :D
He's in it for the cash

It does matter. If you don't have the time or money to test everything out yourself, it makes sense to trust the word of someone who isn't purely doing it for the cash. That's integrity.
I trust the word of many experienced tool owners on this forum - they aren't paid to tell me what's worth buying.
Very few of us have the time or money to test everything, that's one of the main reasons a lot of people come here in the first place.
Absolutely, there are people here I would and do trust - not the guy who's being paid to put his name on it

Naive and gullible is believing someone who has only talked the talk, over someone who has walked the walk.
-
Hey listen, you're obviously either unwilling or unable to see past the marketing and Celebrity branding thing ... and that's fine
You spend you're money where you think it's best spent, but I'll be judging the tool rather than the branding :)I do genuinely look forward to hearing some user reviews on this stuff to see what they're actually like. It'll be solid hardworking tools, not corporate branding, marketing techniques and celebrity endorsements that'll make me buy Camillus though :D
-
@50ft-trad said:
Hey listen, you're obviously either unwilling or unable to see past the marketing and Celebrity branding thing ... and that's fine
You spend you're money where you think it's best spent, but I'll be judging the tool rather than the branding :)I do genuinely look forward to hearing some user reviews on this stuff to see what they're actually like. It'll be solid hardworking tools, not corporate branding, marketing techniques and celebrity endorsements that'll make me buy Camillus though :D
Thanks for the lecture, even though I'm probably older and more experienced than you.
Maybe I'm old fashioned, but I take more stock in someone who has actually earned their reputation through hard work and honest effort. Much less so, for someone from a privileged background, who can afford to take every shortcut money can buy.
-
Landrew, I'm talking about a bunch of guys I have got to know over a few years, met up with many and had plenty of time to judge if they have got a clue about this stuff or not. I have knowledge of their experience which is why I trust their opinions over a celebrity... that's my opinion, and I have a right to it.
As for this thread, if it gets personal, it gets locked so let's try and be civil shall we?

-
@50ft-trad said:
Hey listen, you're obviously either unwilling or unable to see past the marketing and Celebrity branding thing ... and that's fine
You spend you're money where you think it's best spent, but I'll be judging the tool rather than the branding :)I do genuinely look forward to hearing some user reviews on this stuff to see what they're actually like. It'll be solid hardworking tools, not corporate branding, marketing techniques and celebrity endorsements that'll make me buy Camillus though :D
Thanks for the lecture, even though I'm probably older and more experienced than you.
Maybe I'm old fashioned, but I take more stock in someone who has actually earned their reputation through hard work and honest effort. Much less so, for someone from a privileged background, who can afford to take every shortcut money can buy.
:D I don't take stock in any celebrity endorsements ;) I'm far more willing to take the word of trusted friends here on the forum over some bloke pedalling his latest money making venture
BTW No lecture - just opinion and exchange of ideas :) I've not changed your perspective and you've not changed mine - you'll buy "Les's" knife because he says it's good, and I'll wait for third party reviews

-
A celebrity endorsement would never take precedence over my own experience with a product, or over a preponderance of authentic and unfiltered user reviews, but dealing <u>only</u> with how one celebrity endorsement ranks over another, I've made my case.
-
Marvellous.... let's move on then.
-
that's a shame I was enjoying Nurph cracking the whip

-

What's peoples thoughts on the blade profile on the machete? I'm far more used to the parang/khukri-esque style blades with the long sweeping belly, and to be honest I have no experience with that style blade. I can see it working well with a slim blade on grassy stuff, but with a thick blade on denser "north woods" materials it just seems to be a little odd.
The curve of a parang is supposedly always presenting and angle to the cut, and axes always have a convex curve. just wondered if there's any performance benefit to this style that I've missed

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
