Les Stroud Interview Camillus Booth, Shot Show 2013
-
Just a little something to substantiate what I'm saying ... what's that he says in the vid? We're the only folding knife on the market with a firsesteel in the handle? Tool Logic have done it for YEARS ... and they had a whistle and (pretty poor) flashlight on it too. Of course LMF have done it on fixed blades too in their collaboration with Mora(?). So he's either lying or he doesn't know any better. Take your choice on that one, my healthy scepticism remains intact either way :D
Stroud has more applied knowledge in the field of survival that I will EVER possess, I'm not taking that away from the guy - but as regards the products, he's a very highly paid Poster Boy
-
@50ft-trad said:
It does matter. If you don't have the time or money to test everything out yourself, it makes sense to trust the word of someone who isn't purely doing it for the cash. That's integrity.
No, it's naive and gullible ;) (did you know the word gullible isn't in the Oxford English Dictionary?)You think he's going to say "those two are OK but this one isn't as good as we hoped", or "they are a bit limited but we daren't put the price up to make them better as they won't sell enough units to give me my skip full of cash every month" or "Yeah it's a fishing tool - we cheaped out" :D
He's in it for the cash

It does matter. If you don't have the time or money to test everything out yourself, it makes sense to trust the word of someone who isn't purely doing it for the cash. That's integrity.
I trust the word of many experienced tool owners on this forum - they aren't paid to tell me what's worth buying.
Very few of us have the time or money to test everything, that's one of the main reasons a lot of people come here in the first place.
Absolutely, there are people here I would and do trust - not the guy who's being paid to put his name on it

Naive and gullible is believing someone who has only talked the talk, over someone who has walked the walk.
-
Hey listen, you're obviously either unwilling or unable to see past the marketing and Celebrity branding thing ... and that's fine
You spend you're money where you think it's best spent, but I'll be judging the tool rather than the branding :)I do genuinely look forward to hearing some user reviews on this stuff to see what they're actually like. It'll be solid hardworking tools, not corporate branding, marketing techniques and celebrity endorsements that'll make me buy Camillus though :D
-
@50ft-trad said:
Hey listen, you're obviously either unwilling or unable to see past the marketing and Celebrity branding thing ... and that's fine
You spend you're money where you think it's best spent, but I'll be judging the tool rather than the branding :)I do genuinely look forward to hearing some user reviews on this stuff to see what they're actually like. It'll be solid hardworking tools, not corporate branding, marketing techniques and celebrity endorsements that'll make me buy Camillus though :D
Thanks for the lecture, even though I'm probably older and more experienced than you.
Maybe I'm old fashioned, but I take more stock in someone who has actually earned their reputation through hard work and honest effort. Much less so, for someone from a privileged background, who can afford to take every shortcut money can buy.
-
Landrew, I'm talking about a bunch of guys I have got to know over a few years, met up with many and had plenty of time to judge if they have got a clue about this stuff or not. I have knowledge of their experience which is why I trust their opinions over a celebrity... that's my opinion, and I have a right to it.
As for this thread, if it gets personal, it gets locked so let's try and be civil shall we?

-
@50ft-trad said:
Hey listen, you're obviously either unwilling or unable to see past the marketing and Celebrity branding thing ... and that's fine
You spend you're money where you think it's best spent, but I'll be judging the tool rather than the branding :)I do genuinely look forward to hearing some user reviews on this stuff to see what they're actually like. It'll be solid hardworking tools, not corporate branding, marketing techniques and celebrity endorsements that'll make me buy Camillus though :D
Thanks for the lecture, even though I'm probably older and more experienced than you.
Maybe I'm old fashioned, but I take more stock in someone who has actually earned their reputation through hard work and honest effort. Much less so, for someone from a privileged background, who can afford to take every shortcut money can buy.
:D I don't take stock in any celebrity endorsements ;) I'm far more willing to take the word of trusted friends here on the forum over some bloke pedalling his latest money making venture
BTW No lecture - just opinion and exchange of ideas :) I've not changed your perspective and you've not changed mine - you'll buy "Les's" knife because he says it's good, and I'll wait for third party reviews

-
A celebrity endorsement would never take precedence over my own experience with a product, or over a preponderance of authentic and unfiltered user reviews, but dealing <u>only</u> with how one celebrity endorsement ranks over another, I've made my case.
-
Marvellous.... let's move on then.
-
that's a shame I was enjoying Nurph cracking the whip

-

What's peoples thoughts on the blade profile on the machete? I'm far more used to the parang/khukri-esque style blades with the long sweeping belly, and to be honest I have no experience with that style blade. I can see it working well with a slim blade on grassy stuff, but with a thick blade on denser "north woods" materials it just seems to be a little odd.
The curve of a parang is supposedly always presenting and angle to the cut, and axes always have a convex curve. just wondered if there's any performance benefit to this style that I've missed

-
-
Long and short of it is that Les Stroud might well have a great reputation (and I am a fan) but the modern Camillus brand does not. :-\ So until these have had a good independent review I'll be reserving my judgement.
That and the fact I think they are ugly as hell. :D
-
@Gareth said:
Long and short of it is that Les Stroud might well have a great reputation (and I am a fan) but the modern Camillus brand does not. :-\ So until these have had a good independent review I'll be reserving my judgement.That and the fact I think they are ugly as hell. :D
+1 :D Especially the last part. ;)
But it is nice to see a "new" manufacturer entering the multitool world, assuming that Camillus is making that multitool, not just selling a rebranded Ganzo or the like. Les has carried the the Supertool, Swisstool, Spirit and Charge (great taste for tools :) ) during the previous seasons and always emphasized the usefulness of a multi in the survival situation. So hopefully this will be a good tool. Though as others have said, I'll wait on independent reviews.

-
- 2 on the 'ugly'

i like the 'new' Bear Grylls offering
that 'looks' well designed, but i would buy one without the BG logo if i had the choice.
- 2 on the 'ugly'
-
Oh, I don't know ... I think those Spanish ones look quite nice :D The more I look at the lime green items though, the more confused I am as to the decisions. The machete shape, the blade shapes, the styling ... again like I said before I'll reserve full judgement when I've seen more pics and reports ... but it's not so much a "no" as a "why the smurf ... ?"
-
"Scissors built in. You don't see that very often." The presenter in the MT video doesn't know the MT market very well.
When I freezeframe on the MT (at 4:11), I can see large gaps between the tool layers. This probably means thin stock with washers between the tools. There is also no visible tool lock, so these are almost certainly non-locking tools. That is one crazy short saw. It looks like about a standard 4" frame length (based on it being about as long as the speaker's palm is wide). All inside access tools. I have to say I'm not seeing much to excite me, but I'll let other folks get their hands on this thing and give some reviews before I completely write it off. This thing REALLY puts me in mind of the Husky tool sold at Home Depot. I'd have to get a close hands-on to say more definitively, but yeah... kinda disappointed at first glance.
The fixed blade knives look a little more promising. Unfortunately, I have absolutely no need for a fixed blade knife. I think the machete has some promise, and looks like the kind of blade that'd take a serious beating.
-
Totally off topic, but will someone please tell Les to STOP DOING SCENE/ANGLE CHANGES IN HIS SHOW EVER FIVE BLOODY SECONDS?

I swear, I get motion sick watching his bloody show when he does that! Sheesh!!!
-
I watched a lot of MTV when I was younger. I'm immune to blipverts.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
