New Star Wars
-
Personally I think they should've left well alone after the first three films were made. True classics of their time and to me far far better than the later trilogy.
The original worked simply because if it was fresh and with virtually no-name actors it became almost believable.
The second attempt episodes IV-VI are quite simply appalling in my view. A ridiculous amount of poorly executed CGI's coupled with famous actors thus bringning type-cast problems with it too. I could actually have forgiven the CGI effect's (bit like shoulder pads in the 80's). But the use of Ewan McGregor was a huge mistake, along with Liam Neeson. It just completely destroyed the whole illusion to me. Their characters should have been played by unknown actors, thus bringing a real sense of originality to the franschise or failing that an actor of Johnny Depps calibre may well have worked too. As it is, I and many others simply couldn't get "in to it".
Rubbish in my view - but I guess the money was more important. -
Sadly, when the creator of a successful franchise departs the scene, it seems all too rare for the followers to carry the torch.
-
Yeah, they should have used all unknown actors like the original trilogy... because Alec Guiness and Peter Cushing were both no-names. ::)
The things is, for most of us, the original trilogy got that grandfather clause thing where we somehow overlook all the flaws, and focus on what was good. NO ONE seems to remember the stupidity that is the Ewoks.
Ep 1 was frustrating, because it had the terrible Anakin story, and Jar Jar, but the pretty awesome Qui Gon/ Obi Wan / Darth Maul bits.
(And, by the way, when I want to show my lack of enthusiasm for something, I have adopted saying 'Woo-hoo... now THIS is podracing' in the most monotone emulation of the line I can muster.)
Ep 2 is a pretty huge improvement. Much less terrible, much more awesome.
Ep 3 was (except for ANY scene with both Anakin and Padme) FRICKIN AWESOME!
As for bad effects... Hmmm... you remember the original version of the scene in Jabba's throneroom with the singer and slave dancers? No? How about the stop-motion Taun-Tauns from Ep 5? No? Hmmm.... How about... those BIG UGLY chroma key marks around the tie fighters throughout the entire original Star Wars? You know, the ones that have now been digitally fixed in the newer versions? No? Hmmm...
Most every visual effect will eventually start looking bad. ILM has consistently been the people pushing the boundaries of what is doable.
Let me stop to ask maybe the single most obvious question so many obsessive Star Wars fans (myself included) often overlook: Do you think maybe we're expecting too much from movies that are at their essence supposed to be fun romp reinventions of the saturday matinee serials?
I hear the angry grumbles already...
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
NO ONE seems to remember the stupidity that is the Ewoks.I thought everyone loved Ewoks
:'(I quite honestly enjoy all six movies! Though I do find Luke to be very whiny and irritating at times, and Jar Jar, well..... yeah, they really could have done without him, okeday.
Hmm, this makes me want to start reading Star Wars books again! Kindle, here I come. :ahhh
-
Again I've got to side with Lynn on this. I would also add that Hayden Christensen (the relatively unknown actor of the group) had all the acting skill of a piece of pine and the charisma of a damp flannel. THAT was what really annoyed me about the films, the fact they were totally centred around a character that was played by, not one, but TWO actor who couldn't get a single iota of my sympathy or empathy.

Phew, that feels better. :D
-
@Gareth said:
Again I've got to side with Lynn on this. I would also add that Hayden Christensen (the relatively unknown actor of the group) had all the acting skill of a piece of pine and the charisma of a damp flannel. THAT was what really annoyed me about the films, the fact they were totally centred around a character that was played by, not one, but TWO actor who couldn't get a single iota of my sympathy or empathy.
Phew, that feels better. :D
Is it because he is Canadian??
:tool:The 3 original ones had Harrison Ford and an evil Darth Vader. The new ones did not. The actors were adult.
Also episode one starts with a stupid race round the desert, which the 1st time I saw it made me think that they were just trying to find something to make a computer game out off later. (I have no idea if they did) Also too many young actors that made it look like you were watching a teen/kid TV movie rather than a proper film.I must have watched the original ones again and again many times, and the new ones maybe twice... no atraction there.
-
If you want to see some really silly Star Wars, take a look at the Star Wars Holiday Special on youtube.
http://m.youtube.com/index?desktop_uri=%2F&gl=NO#/watch?v=Mz550T3QeAo

-
@Grathr said:
If you want to see some really silly Star Wars, take a look at the Star Wars Holiday Special on youtube.Do NOT take a look at the Star Wars Holiday Special. I thought it was bad when I was 7. YOU ARE WARNED! :D
EDIT: Although... it WAS the first introduction of Boba Fett. So... No, it was terrible.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
Do NOT take a look at the Star Wars Holiday Special. I thought it was bad when I was 7. YOU ARE WARNED! :DEDIT: Although... it WAS the first introduction of Boba Fett. So... No, it was terrible.
While I will admit that it is horrible, if one remembers that it was produced at a time when anything with "Star Wars" in the title was like printing money, it's understandable.
Plus, it's the only time you get to hear the lyrics to the Star Wars theme music

-
I agree pretty much with everything Lynn said. Hayden Christiansen is an awful actor; they easily could have found someone better.
That said, I think the choice of Ewan MacGregor for Obi Wan was brilliant, although I thought his performance in Ep. III, especially at the end, was rather wooden as well. Even Obi Wan would have been more emotional at the discovery of Anakin's betrayal of the Jedi, and then having to cut down his former padawan... Ewan MacGregor is a phenomenal actor in general, and I've like pretty much everything I've seen him in, all different kinds of things, from Blackhawk Down, to Big Fish. His range is outstanding.
I also think Ep. I should have focused more on Obi Wan really, rather than child-Anakin. Other than Anakin, he really is the fulcrum of the first three episodes, and it would have been nice to see more character development with him, and also with Qui Gon. But of course, no one bothers to consult me on any of this, do they?

-
If you see an actor (like Ewan McGregor) who is great in a bunch of movies, and kinda bad in one or two, I always put that down to the director. The actor has shown the ability to act, repeatedly. Same with Natalie Portman. She's very good... in other movies. Gotta be the director at that point.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
If you see an actor (like Ewan McGregor) who is great in a bunch of movies, and kinda bad in one or two, I always put that down to the director. The actor has shown the ability to act, repeatedly. Same with Natalie Portman. She's very good... in other movies. Gotta be the director at that point.Absolutely.

Ewan McGregor has also gone on record saying just how much he didn't like making the films. Not to say he didn't give the performance he was asked to, just that it's very hard to give it your all when you're not enjoying your job. :-\
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
If you see an actor (like Ewan McGregor) who is great in a bunch of movies, and kinda bad in one or two, I always put that down to the director. The actor has shown the ability to act, repeatedly. Same with Natalie Portman. She's very good... in other movies. Gotta be the director at that point.
Absolutely.

Ewan McGregor has also gone on record saying just how much he didn't like making the films. Not to say he didn't give the performance he was asked to, just that it's very hard to give it your all when you're not enjoying your job. :-\
Hard for me to imagine saying you didn't like doing something that pays you millions.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
Hard for me to imagine saying you didn't like doing something that pays you millions.
The job that paid most in my life was probably the one I liked least. It sometimes happens. Tons of money doesn't always bring happiness... although I'd risk finding out. :D
If you don't like doing something, don't do it, but if you're doing it for the money, obviously you liked it well enough to do it.
-
I wish I could find something more profound to say, but all that comes to mind is this: "I felt a great disturbance in the Force, as if millions of voices suddenly cried out in terror and were suddenly silenced. I fear something terrible has happened. "
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
Hard for me to imagine saying you didn't like doing something that pays you millions.
The job that paid most in my life was probably the one I liked least. It sometimes happens. Tons of money doesn't always bring happiness... although I'd risk finding out. :D
If you don't like doing something, don't do it, but if you're doing it for the money, obviously you liked it well enough to do it.
I think the terms "under contract" and "being professional" would seem relevant here. :)
@ironraven said:
I wish I could find something more profound to say, but all that comes to mind is this: "I felt a great disturbance in the Force, as if millions of voices suddenly cried out in terror and were suddenly silenced. I fear something terrible has happened. "
-
Gizmodo seems to think that jj abrams as the new director might be a good idea.
http://gizmodo.com/5979720/heres-what-itd-look-like-if-jj-abrams-directed-the-original-star-wars
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


