Any love for Wenger?
-
I think that the alox machine is delemont must be on fritz and they are using up old stock. That wod be the only reason to make it in that manner IMO. It might end up being very rare!
-
I've had my first three Wenger 85mm's for about a week now and have to say I'm underwhelmed. Two needed pins to be hammered tighter to prevent atrocious side to side play. The third had a scissors screw go from tight to literally falling out with just a few uses. I was able to put it back in, but I'll have to be vigilant about tightening that screw often. All three have weak springs relative to Victorinox. I think the step down in quality would be obvious to most knife users.
These three were all used models, probably more than ten years old, and, hence, may only be a reflection of 1990's or early 2000's Wenger quality. But I've bought quite a few used Victorinox knives of similar age and condition and have never had problems like these. My sample is admittedly small and non-scientific. But I'll shop for Wengers with caution in the future.
I would like to try an newer Evo model, however, as I've heard Wenger quality rose after the Victorinox acquisition.
-
It also depends how hard a life it's had before. If the previous owner has been working the tools hard and sprained the pins, it could account for at least some of the issues you're finding. Whilst many of my Wengers don't shout as loud on the snap on opening and closing, it's certainly not affected the functionality of them in use. Not sure what you mean by screwdriver screw though

-
Sorry, meant to say "scissors screw" and misspoke. And, yes, the current condition of these Wengers may well be a reflection of past use and abuse. But the same would be true of used Victorinox knives I've bought as well. It could be just chance that these Wengers were used harder. But it seems unlikely.
I don't wish to convey that I don't like the Wengers or regret my purchases, all of which were at pretty bargain prices. For the money paid, these Wengers are fun and functional. But their construction seems a bit delicate compared to similar Victorinox models. These will be users, so I'll see how well they hold up to hard use (but not abuse).
I also bought a 1990 SI a couple weeks ago (had a thread about restoring a snapped tip). I find the quality on it to be equal to the Victorinox alox models.
-
Ah, ok - I'd suggest taking the screw out and putting a bit of threadlock or something gummy on the thread before putting it back. Threads wear, and temperature changes for such small threads can make a difference too sometimes
Oh - and don't over tighten the screw either, there is meant to be some play on the Wengers for them to work properly. The underside of the scissor arm has a chamfer, and a corresponding chamfer on the top of the spring lever. This is to kind of push the arms apart, which in turn pushes the blades together ;) Nip the screw up too tight and it will have an adverse effect 
I'd say 85mm Wengers aren't quite as robust as 91mm Vics, but a bit more robust than 84mm Vics. In some ways they are a little more robust with having the locking drivers, but that might lead people to work them a bit too hard ... which might have happened to yours :)
I'd definitely give one of their newer models a try if you can to remove the "past abuse" issue. You'll still find the springs to be a little softer, but should eliminate all your other issues
-
Understood. I had already planned to pick up some Lock-Tite this weekend and give the Tradesman some attention. Lock-Tite is good stuff to have around anyway.
I was lucky I didn't lose the screw altogether. What a pain that would have been to replace .... probably easier and possibly cheaper just to buy another used knife.
-
@Mud Shrimp Moe said:
Understood. I had already planned to pick up some Lock-Tite this weekend and give the Tradesman some attention. Lock-Tite is good stuff to have around anyway.I was lucky I didn't lose the screw altogether. What a pain that would have been to replace .... probably easier and possibly cheaper just to buy another used knife.
Absolutely :ahhh Good luck with it all, and don't forget to post how you get on

-
@Mud Shrimp Moe said:
I've had my first three Wenger 85mm's for about a week now and have to say I'm underwhelmed...These three were all used models, ...
As has already been mentioned... "There's your problem!"

My new Evo S14 is a great little SAK! It's been my primary pocket carry SAK from the day I got it. F & F are just as good as Vic's IMHO and there are some things I like about the Evo better than the comparable Vics.
I've got an S16, S52, and S557 all on my wish list now.
-
@Heinz Doofenshmirtz said:
As has already been mentioned... "There's your problem!"
My new Evo S14 is a great little SAK! It's been my primary pocket carry SAK from the day I got it. F & F are just as good as Vic's IMHO and there are some things I like about the Evo better than the comparable Vics.
I've got an S16, S52, and S557 all on my wish list now.
You prefer the evo scales over the classic scales then?
-
My first encouter with a Wenger was just as negative. I picked up a used Forrester on ebay and it was awful; bent blade, loose spring action, bent saw etc. Finally I had to pull the whole thing appart and I rebuilt it as a Traveller, much better knife now. I have had no such issues when buying a new Wenger though.

-
I definately give folks the warning light on picking up too many Wengers online at once unless the seller has a good rep for honesty and good descriptions. After handling several from ye old auction site, the conditions have been all over the place. Of special note is the scissors, scissors pivot can be very squirelly (I suppose that could be true for Vics as well). Luckily my key Wengers- a Metal 50, Master, and Galahad Lock have been pretty good. The MB spring in the Master seems to be extra soft though, so it might be going in to the shop.
-
@50ft-trad said:
Absolutely :ahhh Good luck with it all, and don't forget to post how you get on
Well, I bought some Lock-Tite last night and redid the scissors screw. The Lock-Tite is less viscous (i.e. more watery) than I had expected and, consequently, I'm not sure how much of it is actually on the the threads. It's more than a bit fiddly to align the scissor blades and get that tiny screw threaded and screwed in with only two hands and a Vic mini screwdriver. But I'm sure at least a tiny amount of Lock-Tite is in there now and am hoping for the best.
If this doesn't hold well, I may try unscrewing it slightly and applying the Lock-Tite from the bottom and then retightening (but not over tightening) the screw. I put the drop of Lock-Tite in the hole before putting in the screw, which is a delicate operation as described above.
Anyway, a boring story for you ... but you asked! ;)
-



Fly fisherman catch, new.
-
@Mud Shrimp Moe said:
@50ft-trad said:
Absolutely :ahhh Good luck with it all, and don't forget to post how you get on

Well, I bought some Lock-Tite last night and redid the scissors screw. The Lock-Tite is less viscous (i.e. more watery) than I had expected and, consequently, I'm not sure how much of it is actually on the the threads. It's more than a bit fiddly to align the scissor blades and get that tiny screw threaded and screwed in with only two hands and a Vic mini screwdriver. But I'm sure at least a tiny amount of Lock-Tite is in there now and am hoping for the best.
If this doesn't hold well, I may try unscrewing it slightly and applying the Lock-Tite from the bottom and then retightening (but not over tightening) the screw. I put the drop of Lock-Tite in the hole before putting in the screw, which is a delicate operation as described above.
Anyway, a boring story for you ... but you asked! ;)
Nice one
I'd allow it twice the cure time it says on the packaging then try it with a screwdriver. At least that way you can have another crack at it by backfilling the hole as you said 


Fly fisherman catch, new.
Nice one - never seen those before

-
@50ft-trad said:
Nice one
I'd allow it twice the cure time it says on the packaging then try it with a screwdriver. At least that way you can have another crack at it by backfilling the hole as you said 
Yep.
The packaging says it sets in 10 min and fully cures in 24 hours. I put it away for about 90 minutes and gently tested it by working the scissors a couple times (couldn't quite resist ... plus I wondered if any Lock-Tite got between the scissor blades and might be a problem). Then I put it up and am not carrying it today. I'll test it with a screwdriver. I don't expect it to feel super-glued in there, but hope it's firm. Thanks for the advice.
-

Portrait Session with my 557
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login