Who is cooler?
-
Lately I have been really enjoying episodes of The Deadliest Warrior TV show which pits two soldiers that would have never met against each other to see who would win- pirates vs knights, samurai vs vikings and so on. They take experts in the weapons and fighting arts of each warrior, test them for lethality, then punch it all into a computer simulator that runs a thousand battles and the warrior who wins the most is crowned The Deadliest Warrior.
Recently they did an episode that pit zombies vs vampires, so I thought it would be neat to see what the folks around me thought of this ultimate Sci Fi matchup.
Captain Han Solo:

Or Captain James T. Kirk:

Personally I think Han Solo is the coolest. When you compare them this is what you get...
<u>First Officer</u>: When put in a dangerous situation, Chewbacca roars and rips the offenders' arms out of their sockets. Spock raises an eyebrow and says "Fascinating."
<u>Romance</u>: Han got a princess. Kirk got a green woman.
<u>Ship</u>: The USS Enterprise breaks down a lot despite a huge government funded budget. The Millenium Falcon breaks down a lot due to a lack of a huge budget.
<u>Weapon</u>: Solo packs a Blastech DL-44 heavy blaster pistol that burns through stormtrooper armor. Kirk uses a Federation issue phaser pistol that looks like an electric razor.
<u>Clothes</u>: Style aside, no one ever managed to rip Han's shirt, while Kirk either shredded or fell out of his every week.
<u>Friends</u>: When Han's friend got his whole right hand chopped off he got a new one, got special training, then chopped the hand of the guy that took his. One of Kirk's friends lost a finger and therefore always went out of his way to hide his right hand on camera.
<u>Afterward</u>: When he no longer had a ship, Ford got a fedora and a bullwhip and chased magical artifacts around the world while Nazis chased him. After Star Trek Shatner got a girdle and a police uniform and chased 80's bad guys around with Heather Locklear.
So there you have it- Han Solo is WAY cooler than Captain Kirk. Feel free to make a case for The Shat, after all:

Def
-
Don't think anyone ever accused Kirk of being a scruffy looking nerf herder... But overall I agree
sent from my Firespray-31-class patrol and attack craft via tapatalk 4 beta
-
Not too scruffy looking for Uhura!

Def
-
Hmmmm, smoking cigars on The Practice or was it Boston Legal vs playing with the LAPD 2019 Blaster.
I vote for Chewbacca.
-
I really enjoy The Deadliest Warrior show, very cool to see the analysis of the weapons and styles. They do decent enactment of the fights too. I haven't seen it in a while though, and wasn't even sure it was still going, but it's good to know it is.
As for who is cooler, I would say you made a good case for Han Solo, but I find Shatner to be a funny guy. However, Shatner is not in question, but the character of Kirk. I know Han got a princess, but Kirk got who knows how many various alien chicks, so that could be cool in its own way. Yeah, I'll go with Kirk, even though I like your breakdown of the various factors :D
-
how much cooler can you get than frozen in carbonite?

-
KIRK ! it has to be Kirk :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh
maybe to settle this you could arrange a 'fight' between some members ?
Hanksolon V (the one and only) Kirk13 -
Han Solo is imaginary. James T Kirk is real and therefore cooler.

-
Hey you forgot one! JR
What about,

-
Personally I think it should be Capt. Malcolm Reynolds...
Cool ship?Yes
Hot first officer? Yes!
Funky handgun?Yes!
Achingly pretty engineer? He'll yes!
Man called Jane? I believe he's the only so far to have one!
-
1980's Heather Locklear vs 1980's Carrie Fischer
I could think about that dilemma for weeks :D :D :DSolo vs Kirk is easily a win for Solo
Friends: Vulcan traits compared with Jedi Knights abilities. Logic and mind melding compared with telekinesis and the ability to read minds and control minds without having to lay hands on. Even the dead ones lend a hand occasionally. Plus lightsabers are WAY cooler - I know, I have one :P I'd rather have a mechanically minded Wookie than a 9 fingered slightly overweight Scottish dude (who isn't even Scottish) to back me up when things get messy too. If you look at the last film, Spock had to tell Scotty the formula that he had supposedly invented .... so he never even managed that :-\ Scotty's reputation was caused by saying things were too tricky or he didn't have enough time so he looked good - Wookies don't care they just rip limbs off
Fighting style: When did you ever see Solo "set to stun"? ::) He just blasts them. He defeats a rocket propelled bounty hunter whose dad had an entire intergalactic army modelled after him .... with a stick .... though he did have a bit of assistance from some spiky intestinal affair
Plus he has no qualms about shooting first (until some interfering old git tries to fudge the issue to pretend he didn't)Ship: The Enterprise is a big governmental ship. The Falcon outruns big governmental ships, then pretends to have disappeared by parking on one .... and they never notice
Not only does Solo win, he managed to achieve this reputation in only three movies, where it took Kirk a whole lot more movies plus TV series to be considered for the runner up position ;)
-
@MadPlumbarian said:
Hey you forgot one! JRWhat about,

He gets my vote...Cuba Libra on the rocks, steady as she goes

-
Solo!!!!! :D
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
<u>Romance</u>: Han got a princess. Kirk got a green woman.Excuse me? How on Earth do you make that a win for Han?!
Weapon: Solo packs a Blastech DL-44 heavy blaster pistol that burns through stormtrooper armor. Kirk uses a Federation issue phaser pistol that looks like an electric razor.
Enterprise is Kirk's weapon of choice, not some dinky hand weapon. And nobody has ever called down ortillery strikes from a Corellian cargo ship.
:D
-
Was there really any doubt Han Solo would take the lead?
-
-
I'd take green alien chicks over a princess of space dust any day. :o
-
Captain Kirk is better he defeated the god Apollo, although in a sad way.
-
Solo has a cooler buddy, ship and weapons but Kirk still go the chicks.
-
Kirk has a 'transporter' !!!
and he had a 'flip phone' before anyone else !
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login







