Sharpening SAKs for Dummies?
-
@Quartz said:
How does the Sharpmaker work exactly, and which Lansky are you talking about (I'm seeing a bunch of different ones on Amazon)?An earlier post answered the Lansky question.
The Sharpmaker has no moving parts, the idea is that it is easy to "cut" straight down. That way the need for any guide to keep a consistent angle is eliminated. It really is as simple as a couple of hones sticking up at an angle from holes in a board. A neat idea, I think.
-
I use the same Lansky set that Sparky posted, and I love it. Pretty much foolproof.

-
@Quartz said:
Given a person with no workshop/tools/skills, what's the easiest, simplest, most fool-proof way to sharpen the blades on a Vic or Wenger? Do handheld sharpener gizmos like these actually work? I need to help out a relative who isn't a handyman but I'm not sure what to tell them.Okay, you don't have to buy a thing. You already have one of the best SAK sharpening tools in your kitchen. Go and find a large coffee mug with a nice unglazed ring on the bottom of it. If the ring is a little rough, smooth it out with a little bit of green scotch brite.
Then you strop the blade on the unglazed ring. To find the right angle. hold the knife blade on the mug like your gonna saw right down through it. Then Tilt the blade over one half way to horizontal. Now it's at 45 degrees. Tilt it again so it;s half that distance. You're there. Now just strop the edge on the rough unglazed ring on the mug. Back and forth, alternating sides. In a few minutes it will be very sharp. Finish by stropping on the back of an old belt. Don't worry about exact angle, micro bevels and all that other stuff people get bogged down with. With a little practice and a good coffee mug and an old belt, you will be able to get your SAK shaving sharp with very little gear. The less you think about it, the better you'll do.
Google Youtube; "Instinctive knife sharpening". Pay attention to the guy in the gray flat cap.
-
@Steinar said:
The Sharpmaker has no moving parts, the idea is that it is easy to "cut" straight down. That way the need for any guide to keep a consistent angle is eliminated. It really is as simple as a couple of hones sticking up at an angle from holes in a board. A neat idea, I think.That..... doesn't really answer my question though. Assuming it works like a sharpening rod, I guess you hold the knife vertically and slide it down? I tried to look up a video on youtube but I couldn't find any good ones. This might work I guess, you'd be surprised how many people can't hold something straight though.
-
Here is a link to the spyderco sharpmaker training video.
-
I am very interested in this thread, as I am new to knife sharpening. I have the Sharpmaker, and have had mixed results in my limited experiences so far. I have a Cadet that I was able to get sharp enough to shave hair, but then I struggled to sharpen a Soldier. I sometimes check the sharpness as I go by trying to cut a piece of paper. Sometimes it seems like I go backwards when I try to use the flat edges of the triangles. When I use the flat edges I have a hard time keeping the blade flush with the stone throughout the entire motion. This especially happens near the end of the motion as I get near the curve of the blade.
I am sure that I just need more practice and the key seems to be keeping your wrists locked and using a steady motion.
-
@Saluki said:
I have a hard time keeping the blade flush with the stone throughout the entire motion.Yeah, this is the sort of thing I'm afraid of with someone who isn't a "knife person". I think a lot of people who mess around with knives and tools on a regular basis forget how hard it can be for someone with no experience to do otherwise basic stuff like sharpening.
Thanks for the suggestions. I think the Lansky looks like the best option, so that's what I'll suggest.
-
It's probably as simple as the blade not being reprofiled to the exact angle of the Sharpmaker yet. An easy helper is use a sharpie to blacken the cutting edge. On a blunt edge, the hones won't reach the actual edge, and the black mark will stay even after pulling the knife across the hone. So, when the marking is gone, the edge has the correct shape. If you have the money, get the diamond sticks to do the initial reprofiling. Reshaping an edge with ceramic hones is extremely time consuming.
Edit: This was meant as a response to Saluki, </post/738374>
-
@Steinar said:
It's probably as simple as the blade not being reprofiled to the exact angle of the Sharpmaker yet. An easy helper is use a sharpie to blacken the cutting edge. On a blunt edge, the hones won't reach the actual edge, and the black mark will stay even after pulling the knife across the hone. So, when the marking is gone, the edge has the correct shape. If you have the money, get the diamond sticks to do the initial reprofiling. Reshaping an edge with ceramic hones is extremely time consuming.Edit: This was meant as a response to Saluki, </post/738374>
Steinar, thanks for the suggestions. The SharpMaker seems like a great setup and is widely respected, so I probably just need more practice with it.
I do have a question for you or anyone else about the proper angle to use. In the SharpMaker instructional videos they say that 40 degrees is the angle to use under normal circumstances when sharpening a knife, and that the 30 degree setting is for back beveling a blade that has been sharpened several times and needs to have some extra metal removed to get down to a decent cutting edge. However, I believe in one of your earlier posts you mention the SAKs coming from the factory with a 30 degree edge and using that setup to sharpen a SAK. For a SAK that is relatively new and has not been resharpened previously, what would be the proper angle to use on the SharpMaker?
-
This is from the Victorinox USA web site. Apparently anything between 30 - 40 degrees is ok.
"Q. How do I sharpen my blade?
A. You can sharpen using a whetstone at an angle of 15° - 20°. This will result in a cutting angle of 30° - 40°. If sharpening on a grinding wheel, always cool with plenty of water to avoid excessive temperatures."http://www.swissarmy.com/us/app/content/customerSupportVictorinoxSwissArmyKnives
For what its worth I use the 40 degree slots on my Sharpmaker, since that's what Spyderco recommends.
-
@Saluki said:
I do have a question for you or anyone else about the proper angle to use. In the SharpMaker instructional videos they say that 40 degrees is the angle to use under normal circumstances when sharpening a knife, and that the 30 degree setting is for back beveling a blade that has been sharpened several times and needs to have some extra metal removed to get down to a decent cutting edge. However, I believe in one of your earlier posts you mention the SAKs coming from the factory with a 30 degree edge and using that setup to sharpen a SAK. For a SAK that is relatively new and has not been resharpened previously, what would be the proper angle to use on the SharpMaker?Both 30 and 40 will work just fine. It's just a choice. If adding a 40° edge to the blade, you will experience slightly worse cutting performance, but the edge will be somewhat more resistant to edge rolling. 40° edge is something you need for more brittle/lower ductility steel than what's in a SAK. I think that's why Spyderco recommends it, it is a safe choice. On low carbide and carbon steels I never bother with the 40° edge myself, and just use 30°.
If you choose 30°, you may have to sharpen a while to get a good result on a new SAK. Let's say the knife is ground 30.4° from the factory, and you sharpen with 29.5°, you will really have to shape a new edge, while with 40° you start sharpening the edge right away. As I said, it's just what you variables you think are the most important for your own use.
It's really not that important what the exact angle is, as long as it is consistent.
-
To me lasnky is a good overall choise and I often use it when I don't whant to bother with maintaing corner myself (watchin tv and sharpenin). Cause Sak's steele appear to be about soft, a good natural stone and any sistem that helps angle-controlling, ie a paintone pencil or a spring-clips strong enaught, may do the job. Arkansas, Italian natural wather stones from Alpi region, or the very small but effective falkniven D stone would be fairly good.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login