The Star Trek thread
-
I always felt like they did that in Atlantis because they decided fans would want to see more connection to SG-1, a way to keep SG-1 fans watching the new show. Hence Carter joining the show. It's stupid, sure, but it's something you see in spin-off series in all genres all the time because executives are afraid to take anything resembling a risk: "This new Stargate show is too far removed from SG-1, we might lose fans, I demand you connect the two series right now!"
Then when Stargate Universe tanks because it's boring, that same exec can point at it and say "See! It's because it wasn't connected to SG-1, I told them they couldn't do that!" and he gets a raise.
-
the Stargates were the only connection needed tbh.
I feel there is a definite lack of Space SciFi atm, be it trek, BSG, or otherwise.
-
I liked the go uld , fake god angle in SG1.
Atlantis was ok but started falling flat
Universe was boringSent using Tapatalk
-
@Mike, Lord of the Spammers! said:
I know I've said it a million times but bring back Firefly!!!Is there a word for "I totally agree with the sentiment, but I feel the moment has passed"? :)
Also, I really wouldn't call Firefly SF. It's another ensemble driven Whedon series about created family,but a really great one. And it's the best space cowboy series ever!
That said, there was absolutely no real exploration angle in Firefly, but it's probably the best example mentioned till now about the concept of "no backup, no second chances" that I was saying I missed from SF on television now.
-
@Mike, Lord of the Spammers! said:
I know I've said it a million times but bring back Firefly!!!
Is there a word for "I totally agree with the sentiment, but I feel the moment has passed"? :)
Also, I really wouldn't call Firefly SF. It's another ensemble driven Whedon series about created family,but a really great one. And it's the best space cowboy series ever!
That said, there was absolutely no real exploration angle in Firefly, but it's probably the best example mentioned till now about the concept of "no backup, no second chances" that I was saying I missed from SF on television now.
The thing is Whedon has said many times that he pretty much wrapped up everything he wanted to do with it with Serenity. Sure, you could jump to a point in time after Serenity, but you'd need a whole new angle for the show I just don't think it would feel the same. Sure it could be interesting, but just not the same.
-
@RoboYeti said:
I don't get the hate for DS9 here. I've only seen bits and pieces of Babylon 5, but the plot doesn't seem very similar to what DS9 did, other than that they are both on space stations. I agree DS9 definitely had some problems in the beginning (not as bad as Next Generation though, which I love, but which was god-awful for the first season at least). The characters are not likable, the episodes are kind of boring, but once the writers learned how to tie the episodes together to tell larger stories (which other Trek series almost never do) and to develop the characters over time it gets good. No other Trek has anything as epic as the Dominion War stuff.I'd agree with this, DS9 vastly improved in later series. Babylon 5 was a better show overall, but that doesn't mean DS9 was bad IMO.
I have to make a guilty announcement here though: much as I liked and watch TNG, DS9 and Voyager (not so much Enterprise), I don't feel the need to ever watch them again. :-[ Every time I have tried I am struck by just how dated they feel. Also it always feels like I am watching people walking down sets, not corridors, interacting with props, not 'real' devices. I'm sure it's just something to do with the way it's shot but I just don't seem to be able to immerse myself and feel that it's a real world.

-
More Firefly would be great, I feel like there's a whole lot of story left for them to do... hell if Stargate SG1 could beat a dead horse for 10 seasons, surely there's material for at least another 10 proper seasons worth of Firefly :D
I rewatched Space Above And Beyond a few years ago, and that's another one that got the axe too soon. I don't think they could revive it... maybe a reboot like BSG did.
They really need a new Star Trek series, otherwise where's Apple going to steal the next big thing idea from?

-
@Gareth said:
I have to make a guilty announcement here though: much as I liked and watch TNG, DS9 and Voyager (not so much Enterprise), I don't feel the need to ever watch them again. :-[ Every time I have tried I am struck by just how dated they feel. Also it always feels like I am watching people walking down sets, not corridors, interacting with props, not 'real' devices.Yeah, that's a good observation. I have some of the same feeling. The sets felt like sets, not worlds, even when I watched TNG when it was new, though. Also for DS9. Didn't watch Voyager before it was already dated, so not sure how I would have felt there. TOS is so dated it feels like a time capsule though, so it has a different kind of charm. I don't think the ST sets feeling fake has much to do with age, though, more the way they were designed. B5 still feels "real" when people walk down the corridor, even though we get a cut scene with extremely dated CGI.
-
True :D
Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk 2
-
@Steinar said:
Yeah, that's a good observation. I have some of the same feeling. The sets felt like sets, not worlds, even when I watched TNG when it was new, though. Also for DS9. Didn't watch Voyager before it was already dated, so not sure how I would have felt there. TOS is so dated it feels like a time capsule though, so it has a different kind of charm. I don't think the ST sets feeling fake has much to do with age, though, more the way they were designed. B5 still feels "real" when people walk down the corridor, even though we get a cut scene with extremely dated CGI.It goes back to star trek tend to be "cartoony", bright colors, clean surfaces, the design of things just doesn't match things we see everyday. Voyager is the worst, I mean look at the uniforms, clean large patches of singular bright color, people with slick makeup, it feels like watching a bunch of dolls playing dress up party. Also in a firefight, the new trend in the future is apparently hold and fire the rifle from your hip without aiming, walk directly toward your enemy standing tall and not seek any covers while dressed in a cotton shirt.
Enterprise is more in line with everyday things and it feels different.
-
You didn't ever need to aim in any of the Star Trek franchises. Unlike most sci fi where the laser beam fires out in line with the gun barrel like a projectile weapon, phasers often shot out at whatever angle they needed to in order to hit the target dead on. :D
Def
Sent from a digital multitool
-
Agreed. I remember years ago Whoey and I sitting in our tiny underground apartment in London waiting for that show to come on. We were devastated when it was canceled.
Long live Chiggy Con Richthofen!
Def
Sent from a digital multitool
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
You didn't ever need to aim in any of the Star Trek franchises. Unlike most sci fi where the laser beam fires out in line with the gun barrel like a projectile weapon, phasers often shot out at whatever angle they needed to in order to hit the target dead on. :DDef
Sent from a digital multitool
Except in narrow corridors with nowhere to go and 15 meters away, then the laws of phaser demands that the beam shall hit both walls, ceiling and floors without landing a single shot on target. :P
-
I have to give it to Star Trek for phasers really. Everyone else uses lasers, which would travel at the speed of light (seeing as how it is light) so you wouldn't see the beams. The idea of phasers were that they were like lasers, but you could see them on TV. Not important really, but an interesting detail.
I would have also thought that it would be virtually impossible to miss with a laser, as the impact to target would be instantaneous and unaffected by wind, distance etc. Of course, if everyone is using lasers, maybe that's why everyone else wears shiny coveralls- I'd imagine it would be great reflectivity!
Def
-
the "precision" of phasers is worthy of imperial stormtroopers

-
I think the Klingons and stormtroopers went to the same shooting academy.

Other than Picard's frequent costume changes this is pretty good!
Def
-
IT Crowd.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login