The 30 Day Victorinox Huntsman Challenge!
-
@RDaneel said:
I've been a lurker/member for a year, but this challenge pulled me out of my nest. A fantastic test, write-up and analysis. My Huntsman has been with me during this while Vicky was undergoing her test. I even bought another one, a pre-1991 version at the Flea Market last weekend - because I knew this was a great multi-tool.Now I need a name for my blue Huntsman... :)
Dean
Welcome to the world outside the closet Dean!
Chalk up another victory to Vicky!
-
@comis said:
I don't no longer have my original SAK that I owed 20+ years ago to compare, but recently I acquired a Wenger Director and Manager from a window display, and both of them seems to have fully extended for a very very long time(massive amount of dust builtup in the grooves). The minute I tried to close the blades, I already knew their springs were really really weak. I am not 100% sure it was due to prolonged opening, but I do suspect so.Is there a significant difference between Victorinox and Wenger for the design and steel use?
Wenger used to be regarded as second fiddle to Victorinox regarding quality, especially the backsprings, IIRC, the later years people have said the quality is pretty much the same. If the blades were fully opened, the problem was not how they were stored, though. Also, it is the cycle of bending and straightening which is the real problem, just keeping the steel in tension should normally not be that much of a problem.
-
@Dean
Welcome to MT.O, in the light of this thread, how about naming the blue huntsman Victor?
@Steinar said:
Wenger used to be regarded as second fiddle to Victorinox regarding quality, especially the backsprings, IIRC, the later years people have said the quality is pretty much the same. If the blades were fully opened, the problem was not how they were stored, though. Also, it is the cycle of bending and straightening which is the real problem, just keeping the steel in tension should normally not be that much of a problem.I think the groove dust probably just feed into my theory of the blades might have been opened for a long time. So it is more about the cycle than the actual staying opened? That does make sense to me, kinda like if I bend a strip of metal in one direction vs bending it back and forth until it breaks.
Now if only we have an automatic open-and-close machine to test how many times it opens/closes vs the back spring strength, it would be interesting.

-
@comis said:
I think the groove dust probably just feed into my theory of the blades might have been opened for a long time. So it is more about the cycle than the actual staying opened? That does make sense to me, kinda like if I bend a strip of metal in one direction vs bending it back and forth until it breaks.Yes, it is the same thing. Also, when the blade is fully opened, like when it is used, the backspring is not in tension, the same when the blade is closed. (I.e. it is in very low tension, some tension there obviously is.)
Now if only we have an automatic open-and-close machine to test how many times it opens/closes vs the back spring strength, it would be interesting.

Complete with an oildrip for the joint.

-
Well, sports fans, I could probably keep rocking Vicky as my main carry forever, but a deal's a deal. One month of hell = retirement! Vicky is now the only shelf queen SAK I own.
Now I carry Diana!

This is officially the only non-challenge tool I've ever named. It feels weird.P.S.—I do have one or two challenges in mind, but that sort of thing will have to wait until I'm completely moved and at least partly settled in my new town.
-
-
@Dean
Welcome to MT.O, in the light of this thread, how about naming the blue huntsman Victor?
Hmmm....Victor/Victoria springs to mind :ahhh
I'll point out here that I never once (as far as I can remember) used a gendered pronoun for Vicky. What was Vicky really short for?
-
Except on the book cover. Smugness undone!
-
@Jothra said:
I'll point out here that I never once (as far as I can remember) used a gendered pronoun for Vicky. What was Vicky really short for?@Jothra said:
And so ends the fabled story of long ago—we can close the covers on the Epic Tale of Vicky the Huntress!I think the last line of the story reviews that it's a she, so Vicky might stand for 'Victoria' as kirk suggested?
I did a quick search on google for 'huntress', the top two results yield:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Huntress_(comics)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Huntress_(Helena_Bertinelli)They both look bad asses and tough cookies, and probably what Vicky would look like if personified. :D
-
Fair call, comis. Besides, I think we all knew, really.
-
Fantastic challenge, and a great read!

-
@comis said:
I did a quick search on google for 'huntress', the top two results yield:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Huntress_(comics)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Huntress_(Helena_Bertinelli)They both look bad asses and tough cookies, and probably what Vicky would look like if personified. :D
Roman Mythology would add Diana, goddess of the hunt, to the list. Usually considered the original 'Huntress'.
In any event, the word 'Huntress' has a pretty excellent connotation.
Jothra, while I'm excited to think of upcoming 30-day challenges, I have to wonder if leaving the construction trade will still afford the same kind of tool-torture activities that are required to REALLY stress-test tools. Please don't feel like you have to one-up yourself in your reviews.
Also... SEE? I TOLD you all that fricking flathead was an awesome tool! :D
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
Roman Mythology would add Diana, goddess of the hunt, to the list. Usually considered the original 'Huntress'.That's why I stole that name for my new Huntsman from the original challenge idea list, even though I'm usually more excited about Greek mythology. Besides, Wonder Woman!
@Lynn LeFey said:
Jothra, while I'm excited to think of upcoming 30-day challenges, I have to wonder if leaving the construction trade will still afford the same kind of tool-torture activities that are required to REALLY stress-test tools. Please don't feel like you have to one-up yourself in your reviews.I appreciate that. More challenges are certain, but their exact parameters are a bit fuzzier. We'll see what's what!
@Lynn LeFey said:
Also... SEE? I TOLD you all that fricking flathead was an awesome tool! :DAin't it just? You might appreciate what it means that the bottle opener/screwdriver blew my expectations right out of the water.
-
I had to read through the entire review as I was gone after Day 9 so I missed the thrill of waiting to see what's next. Oh, the agony of witnessing the horrors Vicky went through in just one read! Thank you for your time and copious efforts Jothra, this was a very interesting thread. It managed to restore my faith in Victorinox -I'm running a long-term test on a beater Vic Ranger at home and I'm getting mixed impressions. I'm looking forward to your future tests.
I'll second that and I'm sure kids will appreciate these qualities. Good luck to you.
PS: Maybe you should post all these uses of the multipurpose hook in the related thread

-
Fun read, thanks Jothra. It inspired me to give mine a bath and lube as the poor thing gets used a lot with no TLC.
-
@Magic Bus said:
Fun read, thanks Jothra. It inspired me to give mine a bath and lube as the poor thing gets used a lot with no TLC.Vicky got a thorough cleaning and lubing early on (after a nice dirt bath), and it made a huge difference. I guess I shouldn't be surprised that more use means more attention to cleaning.
-
You know that if Victorinox see a spike in the sales of the Huntsman,it'll be down to you and Vicky?
-
@Magic Bus said:
Fun read, thanks Jothra. It inspired me to give mine a bath and lube as the poor thing gets used a lot with no TLC.
Vicky got a thorough cleaning and lubing early on (after a nice dirt bath), and it made a huge difference. I guess I shouldn't be surprised that more use means more attention to cleaning.
Cleaning mine brought back all the snap to the tools. It's now snappier than a snappy thing.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login