Wave or Supertool?
-
I see from your other thread that this tool might be needed for farming, and based on what I have, a wave and a ST300. I think the ST300 might be a little more 'robust' for the task. Here are what I value in these two tools
ST300 over Wave
stronger piler with replaceable cutters
all tools self-contained
more beefyWave over ST300
One hand opening blade/saw
weight
adapter for various kind of bits -
Have you considered a Surge?
-
For user purposes, the 300. Pure practicality.
For collection purposes, the Wave. Clever design, probably too clever for its own good. My Wave has gone back twice, and needs to go back again for a fairly minor problem.
-
Hi Razor. The Wave and Supertool couldn't be more different in terms of form. Since the ST has the same form as your Rebar you may want to try something different .. the Wave :)
-
For me the wave.
The super tool is better but I find it too heavy, big and awkward to carry (just my pref) -
I had a ST200 which I gave to my brother when I upgraded to a Wave (original model).
From that, you cam probably guess that I prefer the Wave if picking between those two.
But even the Wave is now on backup duty to my SwissTool which is my frontline MT now.
-
I have a ST200, and a Charge. I know the Charge is not a Wave, but it's pretty damn close. For heavy work, I'd trust the ST more, but the outside opening tools of the Charge/Wave are really nice to have.
If you are use to the inside tools on the Rebar, then you might not mind the ST200/300, but if they bug you, then I'd say try a Wave out. Oh, and I'd also go for a ST300 over a 200 just for the replaceable cutters.
-
soon we should see a Surge that has replaceable wire cutters. if you can hold out for that you will have the strength and size of s super tool in a layout that is like the wave. I love my surge, and it has yet to fail me at any task
-
I've never done any farming myself, but I would imagine the OHO blades and outside accessible saw and file could be fairly handy as sometimes you may have one hand holding something in place or whatever. Plus, since you have the Rebar (awesome tool by the way :D), you may not want to go with the ST300 since it's basically a bigger version. Or you could do like many of us here and just get both ;)
-
Surge ftw! You get the best from both worlds with a Surge.
sent from my mobile
-
Actually, the Wave isn't that much bigger than a Rebar, mainly just a different design.
Seeing you want a bigger tool, I agree with the people calling out the Surge. It's larger, has the outside opening tools, -and- the adapter you like about the Wave, plus the Blade exchanger, making it possible to switch sawblades. I will advise you to wait for the updated Surge to come out, though, as it has a fix that makes the blade exchanger better for after-market blades, and it has the ST300-plierhead ;)
-
I love my wave so I am biased but that being said, in another thread you mentioned you had a swisstool? might I suggest get a wave and use your swisstool instead of getting a LMST300? the outside accessible tools and the blunt(ish) plier head seem unstoppable. not sure if you would use the wire cutters so that may be a deal breaker.
so my humble suggestion is to get a wave and some bits and use your currently held swisstool.
-
If I had to choose between the ST300 or the Wave, the Supertool always wins, I like the old style screwdrivers, the simplicity of the design, the fact that it's a beefy tool and last but not least, the plierhead.
Now, since you already own a Rebar, buying the ST300 would mean that you're buying another Rebar, but this time the X-large version. On the other hand, if you want a larger tool than your Rebar, you would have to get the ST300, because the Wave is exact the same size as the Rebar (in length that is, the Wave is a bit thicker and with the OHO tools on the outside, the Wave is also a bit wider).
Maybe you should get a ST300 and a Leatherman Crater (that way you would have a beefy tool and a OHO knife to go with your Rebar or ST300 ;)).
P.S. Seeking advice from a bunch of tool addicts is not always a good idea, most of us have a real problem when it comes to choosing just one tool, some of us (the worst cases) even have a weekly schedule to organize which tools they are going to carry
. -
@Top-Gear-24 said:
If I had to choose between the ST300 or the Wave, the Supertool always wins, I like the old style screwdrivers, the simplicity of the design, the fact that it's a beefy tool and last but not least, the plierhead.Now, since you already own a Rebar, buying the ST300 would mean that you're buying another Rebar, but this time the X-large version. On the other hand, if you want a larger tool than your Rebar, you would have to get the ST300, because the Wave is exact the same size as the Rebar (in length that is, the Wave is a bit thicker and with the OHO tools on the outside, the Wave is also a bit wider).
Maybe you should get a ST300 and a Leatherman Crater (that way you would have a beefy tool and a OHO knife to go with your Rebar or ST300 ;)).
P.S. Seeking advice from a bunch of tool addicts is not always a good idea, most of us have a real problem when it comes to choosing just one tool, **some of us (the worst cases) even have a weekly schedule to organize which tools they are going to carry **
.Wow, some people are nutcases huh? Wait a minute
........HEY 

-
oddly enough I have a harder time deciding what to carry on my days off. work days are a combination of what's planned and what may come up and that's been very easily handled by my wave. now that I have a swisstool and its squared away with bits, I can rotate these two or bring both on days I may need the extra set.
-
Sounds like I need a Wave, ST300 and a Surge! May try to get all of them and see which one I like the best, if I could get this dam divorce over with. Taking all my money. Wonder when the new Surge will come out?
-
When in doubt buy both, but in this case "boths"?!?

-
I have both the ST300 and the Charge AL (functionally same as Wave). For everyday use, the charge wins hands down. I didn't appreciate the outside opening tools until I got one. Very comfortable in my hands.
The replaceable cutters are very nice on the ST300. FWIW, a friend gave me a mint original SuperTool. And while I like how the design and functionality of Leatherman tools have evolved, the build quality of the original SuperTool is just a whole different level of Wow. The plierheads and screwdrivers are fully ground the entire length - no casting/forging seams. The blades have a highly polished surface (not like a mirror, but very refined) compared to the grainy satin finish on many of the newer tools. I suspect this more porous surface may make the newer tools like the ST300/Rebar more prone to rusting.
Elisabeth
-
@ToolDiva said:
... a friend gave me a mint original SuperTool. And while I like how the design and functionality of Leatherman tools have evolved, the build quality of the original SuperTool is just a whole different level of Wow. The plierheads and screwdrivers are fully ground the entire length - no casting/forging seams. The blades have a highly polished surface (not like a mirror, but very refined) compared to the grainy satin finish on many of the newer tools. I suspect this more porous surface may make the newer tools like the ST300/Rebar more prone to rusting.Elisabeth
I agree with you on the original Supertool being on a different level of build quality than the ST300, in my opinion my original Supertool comes close to Victorinox Swisstool fit and finish standards, the ST300, while being one of my all time favorites for "getting a tough job done" doesn't reach that same level.
And you're also right about the polished finish, I really like the polished finish on the old ST, I just wish they would make a ST300 with that kind of polishing.
<a href="http://s739.photobucket.com/user/Rikske77/media/Leatherman Supertools/057.jpg.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="http://i739.photobucket.com/albums/xx39/Rikske77/Leatherman Supertools/057.jpg" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a>
-
... a friend gave me a mint original SuperTool. And while I like how the design and functionality of Leatherman tools have evolved, the build quality of the original SuperTool is just a whole different level of Wow. The plierheads and screwdrivers are fully ground the entire length - no casting/forging seams. The blades have a highly polished surface (not like a mirror, but very refined) compared to the grainy satin finish on many of the newer tools. I suspect this more porous surface may make the newer tools like the ST300/Rebar more prone to rusting.
Elisabeth
I agree with you on the original Supertool being on a different level of build quality than the ST300, in my opinion my original Supertool comes close to Victorinox Swisstool fit and finish standards, the ST300, while being one of my all time favorites for "getting a tough job done" doesn't reach that same level.
And you're also right about the polished finish, I really like the polished finish on the old ST, I just wish they would make a ST300 with that kind of polishing.
well said.
I have abused my ST300 more than any other tool, and while it can certainly take a beating and still get the job done, the fit & finish just isn't in the same league as on the older versions.very nice picture, too -- really highlights the difference well.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login