Livarno, Romisen, C8, Small Sun cheap HID torches
-
Thank you Gareth.
They are only cheap torches and unlike my multitools, knives, SAKs they are *all * users. I seem to need torches a lot more than Multitools, in everyday life :D.Some have also been gifted to family members.
I am sure there are many people here with a lot more and fancier torches that do not feel the need to bore people by posting about them.. :)
-
19.99 Euros from LIDL
My halogen spotlight seems to only have 1/2 the original capacity so this seemed interesting



No real heatsinking; plastic construction


The LED looks like a CREE model



the old spotlight


compared

Comes with an adaptor and can be run from the car.
2200mAh Liion battery located in the handle so,
very light as the body tube is empty.
Also has two clusters of smaller LEDs.The main LED gives 180 Lm, for 2 hours
OK, but a bit expensive I think.
-
b]MXDL SA-16[/b]
After hearing about it at BLF I jumped in and got this, all the way from the Far East, for a total of $5 :D . (http://budgetlightforum.com/node/13671 )
It arrived quickly in a white box in a padded envelope from Kaidomain.

Specifications:
Material Aluminium alloy
Emitter Brand CREE
Number of Emitters 1
Color BIN White
**Emitter Type XR-E
Emitter BIN Q5 **
Voltage Input 3.7 V
Battery Configuration 1 x 18650 battery
Circuitry 1000mA
Brightness 350 lm
Runtime 1~2 hour
Number of Modes 3
Mode Arrangement Strong / Weak / Flash
Mode Memory No
Switch Type Button
Switch Location Bottom
Lens Glass
Reflector Aluminum Smooth
Strap Included Yes
Clip Included YesI have to say it: it is a beautiful torch! Decent finish, nicely rounded, no rough edges,, sexy rear button, silver button "frame"....
The front and back ends are silver, making a nice contrast with the brown main body:


Sizewise it is a bit smaller than a C8 type torch.

Comes with **both a clip and a nice strap ** (see 1st picture)
The Cree XR-E is centred ok

The pill is screwed nicely in the head. The tailcap unscrews very smoothly!
There was a blue X on the plate attaching the spring to the pill.. The plate is a bit wonky.

Gets a bit warm on high, as is to be expected.
Tailstands, so it can be used as a room light in a blackout!

The beam, because of the silver aluminium ring securing the glass lens to the head, has a noticeable outer ring.

The torch is more of a thrower, with limited spill (enough to use).
For $5 it is definitely worth it. I am happy with it.
-
I have become a bit fond of Maglite LED torches lately and since I was repairing a 2AA Non-LED Maglite I did a quick beam comparison between the Maglite and a couple of small, cheap torches.
Now the Maglite is unused and had batteries in, but had some oxidation from that lack of use in its contact point between the spring and the bottom screw-cap which meant no connection. I cleaned it (was a pain) put in two LSD batteries and took pictures. It will be returned to its owner later today.
**Maglite Vs Small sun ** on an AA alkaline (or 25+ euro Vs 2 euro..) The Small sun claims 100 Lumens but it is more like 30, the Maglite claims 14, shown here in "tight beam mode"


Maglite Vs Tank007 E09 on LiIons, on high
tight

wide

-
Another cheapy.

Hming, 3W (has a police 3W label)Claims 300Lm but looks more like 20.
Has one of these LEDs, Cree apparently, that you find on all the cheapest Cree torches.

$2.69 with some discount.
Plastic lens, thin walls, decent finish and beam.Runs on 1 AA. Good to just leave somewhere in a room/car until it is needed. I will just put it in the basement and forget about it.
Still a lot brighter than most regular low Watt LED torches.

-
Cheap torches comparison.



I got a free Dimco, Cree LED 1 AA torch, utilising the standard cheap Cree most decent cheap torches use and decided to do a quick comparison with 2 other similar 1 AA torches.

The Small Sun ZY-571 and the Hming.

The two older ones cost around $3 and the Dimco one possibly twice that much (I got it free but I think it was on sale for 5-6 euro…).
Sold/branded by: http://www.1-light.eu/one_light_productsall.php?catID=18&subcatID=358The small sun has a side button and they are all single mode.
The Small sun is the longest by about 1/2cm and it is also the widest (head).
The Dimco came with a rubberised grip collar, a clip and a glow in the dark button.
The small sun has knurling and the Hming has a squared body tube. None feels like it would slip out of your hands.The Dimco has a matt black colour and the other two a shiny black colour.
The Dimco has nice thick threads and the small sun is also good in that area. The Hming feels and is the cheapest. It also has a dirty/scratched front lens. Both the Dimco and the Hming have these stupid attack bezels that make them dangerous to users, especially small children.


None can tailstand, though the Small Sun should be able to, if you remove the lanyard.
As seen in the pictures the Dimco has the brightest hotspot and also appears brighter(35Lm claimed).


The Small sun seems a bit less bright. Because of their bezels the Dimco and the Hming have a non-circular beam pattern.
The Dimco draws, depending on the battery used, up to 0.35A, the Small sun 0.30A and the Hming 0.12A. On a similar Duracell battery both the dimco and the Small sun drew 0.30A. Going to a different, fresh battery made the Dimco draw 0.35 but the small sun stayed at 0.30. The Hming too stayed at 0.12A. Thus the Dimco is brighter and may even draw more current with eneloops.
Note that the fact that it draws more current is not necessary a good thing. Maybe the other two have more resistance but, maybe, they are just better regulated. Not very likely though as I assume they are all direct drive. The Hming should, however, last longer.
-
I wanted a new headlight and I bought this KStools, Cree Zoom Torch.

100Lm are claimed.

The beam looks similar to my MXDL zoom torch (on the right) and they are probably using similar LEDs too.

Gold plating:

Wide beam (Ugly....):

Spot (Cropped picture):

Unfortunately the back does not close properly when you put batteries in, so I will get a replacement on Monday, thus I am not testing it.
-
It is cheap for an HID so I decided to put it here
45/65/85 Watt settings, typical Ebay HID, 8500Lm claimed.
It was shipped using DHL so it arrived quickly.
Huge, long and thick. Makes you look stupid going around with it. Not to heavy.




Came in a box with 4 filters and an 8700mAh battery with two chargers (I charged the battery before using it)


The light bulb


In pieces


The beam can be focused using a system similar to Maglites. It seems to give the best throw with the reflector as far out as possible.
The beam is ringy and a bit green in the middle. This is only really noticeable in small distances. The bulb is a 4300K one (my choice).

You do notice the 3 different power settings but in actual use they all look very bright.
Using it close to you really messes your vision, making you see bright spots.
Definitely brighter than my other torches. Does not get too hot.
There are also 2 hidden flashing modes.
The main problem with these models is that the reflector is a bit small so you get a lot of spill.
-
These arrived today worthy of this, low cost, thread.
Ultrafire E05, blue and red.
Similar to the Fenix E05 in both size and look but with a claimed output of about 150lm, compared to the 30lm of the Fenix.
They arrive in a nice box with a battery.


Cree XP-E LED, Aluminium body, single (twisty) mode. Polished reflector.
The price is about half that of the Fenix.
I did a quick comparison with the Fenix E05 and my gold standard, the Tank007 E09.
The Fenix and the Ultrafire are, supposedly, only able to run on AAA batteries whilst the Tank007 can also run on LiIons. The Tank007 has 3 brightness modes.Size:


Weight:

Consistent weight!



A surprise on the pill…
It is marked as Tank007, something that makes me happy about its quality.

The 3 pills:

Difference in the reflectors and lens between the fenix and the Ultrafire:

What this means to the output beam:


Both Ultrafire torches together:

Fenix, Ultrafire, Tank007


The Ultrafire and the Tank007 seem to produce the same volume of light, but the beam is more focused in the ultrafire, which makes it a decent enough thrower for its size, in my night tests.
The finish for all 3 torches (when new) looks very good, though the fenix feels and looks more expensive.
They are all smooth to operate when new However I was disappointed by some intermittent problems that the Fenix has developed, that I was not able to fix (It was a gift that I gave and have replaced with a Tank007 now). I carry the Tank007 as it has proven bomb-proof, has 3 modes and can run on Li-Ions too.Price wise the Tank007 is between the Fenix and the Ultrafire.
However it is larger than the other two.Overall the Ultrafire seems like a good, bright and cheap torch, with a Tank007 pill that should serve you well. Due to its power it can be used a “proper” torch, on abike, for a walk in the forest etc.
However, it may be too bright for some, whereas the Fenix excels as a lower brightness reading light. It also has a longer runtime. The Fenix is the only one not to get warm when it is on for some time.
-
Ultrafire S6

I got this as it was cheap and really small for an 18650 LiIon torch.
It also looks nice, Cree Q5 LED, polished reflector, glowing reflector rubber ring, claims of 500lm, though it must be around 300lm.
It has 3 modes (high, low and disco).
Size wise it is similar to an AA torch.Compared to another smallish cheap 18650 ultrafire torch (501-B) you see how much smaller and leaner it is.


The quality is good but the rubber washers are not very tight and there is some rattling from the battery (like a Maglite..)



The beam is nice, but a bit white, which some like.
Here is a comparison with the other cheap Ultrafire (XML T6).

Overall, for the low price, you get a very nice, small but powerful and sexy looking torch.
-
Great comparison, thanks for sharing!! I've been thinking about getting a smaller light, so this could be very helpful to me.

-
@dks said:
...
A surprise on the pill…It is marked as Tank007, something that makes me happy about its quality.

...Now that's cool.
The first thing I noticed in the above pic and I had the same thoughts regarding quality.
I may see myself ordering one of those at one point. I think I might like a more floody version of it better but that's easily fixable with a bit of scotch tape. :D -
It is rare to find anything with a Cree LED at a reasonable price here so after a bit of thinking I got this.

It has a 5W Cree LED (claimed, unspecified) and by the size of the reflector it should be a thrower. It is currently being charged as I was not able to test it during the day, too much.
Price 19.99 euros.
Specifications:

The Reflector

The reflector is made from polished aluminium, nice, and the lens is plastic.

Inside:

The LED. Looks like an XP-G.

The main problem with these type of low cost spotlights tends to be the battery. Usually they do not last long and die after a few charges.
Some beam shots will come later. -
No beamshots across the town?

That thing looks like a real thrower. :ahhh
-
I took a few quick pictures, using my usual target a building about 300m away.
I compared the Romicsen RC-T601, a halogen spotlight and the new LED spotlight.
I did not use a tripod so the speed I could use was 1/100, full zoom.
The illumination produced by the other two was too low to show using the camera but the new one was visible and noticeably brighter.
Here is the new one in action (look above the window, to the right)
I will try and take some better pictures with a tripod.
The beam was:

I have a lightmeter App on my phone so I made some comparison readings of the reflected light, beam reflected by the ceiling, in a dark room to see how bright the spotlight was (this is a simple techniques use to measure the total output, both throw and spill..
On full, readings in LUX:
Romisen RC-T601 = 160
Jetbeam BA20 = 101
Halogen Spotlight = 160
New LED spotlight 101 to 160(moved between these steps). (and 40 on low)
Trustfire TR3T6 403-640(moved between these steps)As seen the readings are in steps, so whereas you can not see exactly what the reading is you get a good idea, especially when comparing. I would say that the new one is not as bright s the Romisen (better LED in that one) but noticeably brighter than the Jetbeam.
I will try and take some more readings......
-
If anyone in the UK wants one of the focusable headtorches that were mentioned earlier, you can buy identical ones from CPC for not very much money. They munch through batteries at a rate of knots though.
They're often on special offer if you get their special offer catalogues.
-
Bought as a joke. Looks like a sex toy. $12.59.
It is 30cm long, normally but extends to 40cm or any length in-between these. To extend you unscrew it by a quarter turn, extend (there is a spring too that pushes it out by a bit at the beginning).


I assumed that it would look like a regular torch when contracted and like a baton when extended but it just looks like a smaller baton when contracted and a larger one when extended. comes with a clip so as to be hanged from your belt etc.

It is quite solid and reassuringly heavy; this could cause damage if such a need arose. Will it last? I do not know.

Cree Q5, looks like an XR-E or XP-E (there are other models with better LEDs available too). It has a plastic, highly convex, lens so you get a uniform, wide beam in regular use, which lights a large area. When you extend it you get the image of the LED, but it still works as a torch.

It is not very bright. The overall machining and finish is good. Low, high and disco modes.
Fun! -
Bought from Wallbuys.
I got 3 of these as they were on offer at the time and I wanted some really small AA powered torches.
2 gold, 1 black

They are zooms, similar to the SK68 style torches and cost $3-$5
They have no branding at all, outside or inside.. ???
Work with AA and 10440 batteries.
Cree XPE LED.
Glass convex lens.
They are all 3 mode High, low, disco.
They produce around 100Lm though they are, surprisingly , advertised as producing 20.
They are reasonably bright.
All 3 have uniform beams; a good sign for QC.On the left you see the output with LiMh AAs and on the right with 10440


They are not as bright as the SK68 style ones.
All 3 are well made and the zooming is easy. The finish is good and they come with a pocket clip.
Here is a comparison with two other AA torches
The gold one is extended (long throw) and the black one is contracted (spread)

Overall they are definitely worth the money and are really small for AA torches, especially ones that zoom.
-
Another wallbuys buy.
Ultrafire A3
130Lm
Good finish, good feel to the switch.
Cree Q5 (possibly the same as the one used in Tank007 E09)
Orange peel reflector (deeeeeep)
Tank007 driver. :D (again)

Cheaper than similar Tank007 models.
Surprisingly long, as shown in the comparison photographs.


With an AA torch:

It has a tail button but some of the extra length is from the head.
Here is a comparison with the Tank007 E09 (beams)

The Ultrafire is on the right and the beam, despite the similar emitters, is a lot more focused.
The outputs are similar.
Although it is not stated, based on my testing, it runs on Li-Ions too.

Tank007 on a budget :D
-
A sexy little thing, the Tank007 E10

Bought from eBay for under $14 total cost. (Tank007 models have doubled/tripled in price lately)
I got this because of the brand, the price I found it at and because I wanted a good qaulity small torch with a clip and sexy looks.120Lm, 3 mode, rear button, smooth reflector, Cree XP-E LED.

Came in the usual box

In the box you find two rubber rings and a manual




Stainless steel head and rear button; aluminium body


There was a rough, sharp, spot on the head's grooves that I filed down a bit.

Otherwise the finish was very good - sexy little torch..

Some comparison shots



NOTE: the Ultrafire has an XR-E LED instead of the XP-E used by the tanksBeam shots
E09 to the left, E10 to the right

Note the shape of the beam of the E10, a result of its head shape.E10 to the right, E09 in the middle and A3 to the left (note the XR-E ring)

The overall light volume is similar.
Did I say it is a sexy light?
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login