SAK's - Corkscrew or Phillips?
-
@Huntsman said:
Hmm - Might have to rethink Phillips backspring allegiance and/or EDC!!
I don't like coming across every day tool challenges/jobs that my SAK cannot fix!!Owning and having carried both, it is my belief that the Vic analogue to the Wenger Traveler, the Climber, is a superior option. The only feature I sometimes miss from the Traveler is the nail file. Traveler vs. Climber...perhaps an idea for another thread, if it hasn't already been done.
-
@nate j said:
Hmm - Might have to rethink Phillips backspring allegiance and/or EDC!!
I don't like coming across every day tool challenges/jobs that my SAK cannot fix!!Owning and having carried both, it is my belief that the Vic analogue to the Wenger Traveler, the Climber, is a superior option. The only feature I sometimes miss from the Traveler is the nail file. Traveler vs. Climber...perhaps an idea for another thread, if it hasn't already been done.
Oh that would be a good thread
I have neither of those SAKs, but I do have the EvoGrip 16, which is the same as the Traveler, only with the Phillips instead of the corkscrew. I'm not a fan of the T-handle Phillips though, and while the can opener is nice and pointy/sharp, I prefer the Vic's due to it's use as a phillips. However, I do like having the nailfile on the EG16. Overall though, I think I'd have to agree with the Climber having the edge there. -
Neither
I rarely need a corkscrew (about once every light-year) and besides there are many ways to open a wine bottle without a corkscrew.
The Phillips I find practically useless due to its position.
And I always us the knife when I need a tiny screwdriver.It seems that a lot of people like the corkscrew for its capability to hold the eyeglass screwdriver and not really the corkscrew by itself.
-
Corkscrew for me. Apart from the disadvantages I see in the backspring Philips -not much pressure/torque possible, limited access due to T-handle, doesn't fit many screws- it seems "normal" to me that every SAK has a corkscrew. I found out they make them with the backsping Philips about two years ago.
-
Phillips.
-
Another corkscrew preference here. Love being able to carry the eyeglass screwdriver. And so many models have the can opener with the driver that can handle many philips screws.
-
ALOX ALL THE WAY!
But if I’m going with celidor, then the corkscrew because it holds the eyeglass driver. The corkscrew can also can be used to loosen knots, or serve as a pokey thingy.
A T-mounted phillips is pretty useless. The darn thing collapse when you use it, and the T-handle limits your ability to reach screws. Example: screws on a doorknob asembly.
-
Very - I find the tendency of the backspring philips to buckle under pressure more of a nuisance than the fact that it doesn't have much reach. But that certainly doesn't help.
-
Corkscrew and an inline philips. I tend to carry the Swisschamp so I have the best of both worlds.
If I take my Spartan then I make sure I have some other tools on me.
-
The corkscrew is more versatile. That's one of the reasons I didn't switch back to my Evo s18 after ths Huntsman challenge.
-
Both , this is why my Explorer is my SAK of choice
-
@kmanct3 said:
Both , this is why my Explorer is my SAK of choiceYes but who needs to carry a flipping magnifying glass? The Explorer looks pretty useful, but it looks like something 12 year old boys get for Xmas.
I don't know why Victorinox are so hostile to Philips screwsdrivers. Flat head screws are a thing of the past. Nobody since 1950 has willingly purchased a pack of them. Every single item in the modern world is held together with Philips head screws (or Torx). Yes, sometimes you can just about get by with some other tool... but seriously. Victorinox is being very complacent here. I for one would welcome a SAK that didn't look like it was designed for the kids in an Enid Blighton novel.
-
While I can't say I need to carry a mag glass, it has been useful to me a few times. Once it was a big help in reading a semi worn out serial number on a file cabinet lock that I needed to determine its corresponding key to unlock it. That sort of thing doesn't happen often, and I don't always have a mag glass SAK on me, but I was damn glad I had it that time
I get what you're saying about it being like a toy as well, because I also use it for fun :D -
When it comes to pocket tools, versatility is the name of the game. It turns out that almost any non-recessed Phillips screw will come out via one Victorinox slot driver or the other, and until you spend some real time doing demo it's hard to fathom the ubiquitousness of slot screws.
-
Both , this is why my Explorer is my SAK of choice
Yes but who needs to carry a flipping magnifying glass? The Explorer looks pretty useful, but it looks like something 12 year old boys get for Xmas.
I don't know why Victorinox are so hostile to Philips screwsdrivers. Flat head screws are a thing of the past. Nobody since 1950 has willingly purchased a pack of them. Every single item in the modern world is held together with Philips head screws (or Torx). Yes, sometimes you can just about get by with some other tool... but seriously. Victorinox is being very complacent here. I for one would welcome a SAK that didn't look like it was designed for the kids in an Enid Blighton novel.
Valid point , BUT, I personally do find the mag glass useful, I mean this is the whole purpose of a SAK isn't it ?
-
@Thunderpants said:
Yes but who needs to carry a flipping magnifying glass? The Explorer looks pretty useful, but it looks like something 12 year old boys get for Xmas.I don't know why Victorinox are so hostile to Philips screwsdrivers. Flat head screws are a thing of the past. Nobody since 1950 has willingly purchased a pack of them. Every single item in the modern world is held together with Philips head screws (or Torx). Yes, sometimes you can just about get by with some other tool... but seriously. Victorinox is being very complacent here. I for one would welcome a SAK that didn't look like it was designed for the kids in an Enid Blighton novel.
Vic offers an inline Phillips on the Champ and Explorer, the tinker series has a t-mounted Phillips driver, the can opener tool can just about fit into any Phillips screw out there, and the Cybertools and Swisstools have torx and Phillips bits. I’m not sure how one could see Vic as being hostile towards Philips screws.

And a magnfying glass? I use one quite often when removing splinters. :)
-
I think I had a Tinker once -- I definitely remember the Philips snapping shut on my fingers most of the times I tried to use it. As others here have pointed out, the T shape is nobody's dream configuration for a screwdriver. In many situations it is unusable.
The can opener as Philips is great, as a last resort. No way would I want to do anything like put an ikea shelf together using the can opener. It's an emergency measure and not a serious solution to anything.Most of the other Vic tools do their job really well so it is surprising to find people so tolerant of the second-rate solutions they have for handling Philips screws. As far as I can see, two SAKs have usable philips drivers... and neither of them are particarly skinny.
I love everything about the knives I've got and am constantly stunned by the quality of the tools you can get for pennies. It just baffles me that in all these years Victorinox has consistently shunned the most useful tool of them all , the philips head screwdriver.
Having said that, I have a Swisstool Spirit, which is so good I probably don't need anything else. But a Spartanesque cellidor with a usable philips would be a dream. I'd swap the big blade for it, any day.
-
I once assembled an entire cube shelf with nothing but an Outrider. The can opener was a great Phillips screwdriver. It was getting the nails in that took some effort.
The only problem with an in-line Phillips is that it is more or less a one-trick pony. If that's the only trick you need, then fine -- but sometimes it's worthwhile giving up some specialization in exchange for versatility.
Besides, it's worth noting that here in Canada we use an awful lot of Robertson screws.
-
@Jothra said:
Besides, it's worth noting that here in Canada we use an awful lot of Robertson screws.What on earth...! I've never even heard of Robertson screws. You have screws with a square slot? The only time I've seen this in Europe is on trains. They have big square slots on knobs they don't want passengers to mess with...
-
With the exception of drywall screws and electronics screws, Robertsons are basically the standard up here, and have been for a very long time. They are far harder to strip than Phillips screws.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login