What next?
-
Spirit.
End of.
-
I have both. While the power assist is a neat tool and fun to play with, they such in actual use.
Sent from my DROID BIONIC using Tapatalk
-
Between those two, I would go with the Spirit. I have one and it is a great tool, regardless of the flaws Cupboard mentioned (even though they are valid ones, depending on your usage). I have never handled the SOG though, so I can't comment on its quality, etc.
-
A big part of what drew me to the SOG initially was the V-Cutter. At the time it was something I could use at work to cut through seat belts and helmet straps. I have found serrated blades are often just to what they are cracked up to be. I only ever used the LM serrated for rope and straps and its performance declined over time. I know why now and I'm sure you all know how much fun it is to sharpen them. I will admit the SAK soldier now has an OK blade but its no Spyderco. I just wanted your individual feelings on the matter and why.
-
I find that if something like that (your strap cutting needs) is an important part of my function, I'll carry a separate tool for that and let the multitool take care of the rest. For example I normally have a clipped knife for quick tasks whether my MT has a blade or not. Maybe it would be worth you looking at stand alone cutters such as a KERT, Res-Q-Me or Z Rex

-
Well I have brought up this topic before and ultimately you are right 50. However when I carried a resqme for some reason I always forgot about it. As soon as I found my shears would not be up to the job I went straight for the LM, which always sat at the 4 o'clock position on my belt. For big incidents I have a parachute knife strapped to my helmet.
Today I got me a Spyderco for that role. -
I agree with all the people yelling Spirit

I think the SOG V-cutter is nice, but, if you need it in a situation like cutting a seat belt, I suppose there's some hurry involved, and tools in the SOG aren't exactly easily accessible (open MT, open tool cover, take out tool, close tool cover, close MT, cut). Might be something to think about...
-
@bmot said:
I agree with all the people yelling Spirit
I think the SOG V-cutter is nice, but, if you need it in a situation like cutting a seat belt, I suppose there's some hurry involved, and tools in the SOG aren't exactly easily accessible (open MT, open tool cover, take out tool, close tool cover, close MT, cut). Might be something to think about...
Good point well made

-
@Cupboard said:
Except the wire cutters are crap, it doesn't have a OHO blade, its Phillips driver isn't as good as the Leatherman'sPeople don't like the Phillips driver on the Spirit? I think it's one of the best I've seen in an MT, which is almost surprising since it works so well while still being polished.
I really dislike the bit driver LM goes with now. Changing a doorknob with a bit-driver LM seems to fall into the category of either 'doing this sucks' or 'this isn't going to happen.'
I've owned a powerassist (and now own a powerlock,) they're really nice tools. Also own a Spirit. Some thoughts starting with the SOG:
-The Phillips driver is an odd hybrid. It'll work with smaller phillips screws than a LM or SwissTool, though not quite as well with proper #2 Phillips screws (still well enough for the task at hand. I'd still take them over the LM bit driver given the reach.)
-The pliers are worlds above that in the Spirit. The Spirit pliers are great for the size but simply don't compare to SOG pliers. The cutters are tighter and you can exert (obviously) a lot more force on a cutting area. You won't cut pennies up for fun with a Spirit (though a fullsized Swisstool will...)
-You can't put scissors in one and SOG scissors aren't great anyways, so don't count on doing so. Though you can cut paper with the incredibly tight pliers and tell yourself that this somehow makes up for it.
Regarding the Spirit:
It's smaller and looks a heck of a lot more refined. Short of a diamond file, somehow sticking full sized scissors into it, and tightening up the pliers, there's just not much to refine on the tool. I hardly carry it, but it's impressive enough that you should hold one in your hands.
Both are good tools. The Spirit is a no-brainer for refined goodness. The SOG is a no-brainer for ridiculously good pliers and quick access blades.
Dem
-
@Monrogue said:
I have one and it is a great tool, regardless of the flaws Cupboard mentioned (even though they are valid ones, depending on your usage).I have one, and it's a great tool regardless of the flaws that I mentioned. But I'm always going to play Devil's advocate and point out the flaws in something when someone's trying to make an informed decision about something.
@Dem said:
People don't like the Phillips driver on the Spirit? I think it's one of the best I've seen in an MT, which is almost surprising since it works so well while still being polished.I really dislike the bit driver LM goes with now. Changing a doorknob with a bit-driver LM seems to fall into the category of either 'doing this sucks' or 'this isn't going to happen.'
The Phillips driver is nice and long and fits reasonably well in screws (but not as good as the LM #2 Phillips bit I carry). The problems with it that I see is that despite having had less use and abuse than the Leatherman bits it's noticeably marked on the end. That's not affecting performance yet but it's a little concerning to me and given the same amount of use again (3 weeks which saw a lots of screwdrivering) I think it might be a proper problem. Still, I have put a lot of torque through it and it isn't tool steel so I can't hold it against it too much!
That's not to say LM is perfect, it has its own faults but this isn't the time or place.
-
@Cupboard said:
Except the wire cutters are crap, it doesn't have a OHO blade, its Phillips driver isn't as good as the Leatherman's, the file isn't as good as the Wave/Charge/Surge... etcIt's good, but it's not the best. Still, I'd go for it over the Powerlock. It's smaller and light than the SOG too isn't it?
I could forgive the Spirit all its other faults if it wasn't for the wire cutters' inability to cut most of the stranded wire I frequently cut with my Wave.
I'm going to have to disagree with you on the Swisstool's Phillips vs a Wave Phillips. The Swisstool's driver has decent length to it and I find that there are often situations where I need a driver with some length. The Waver driver is way to short, it's great that you can change the bits but all of the bits are short.
-
Some of the bits come in long too.

-
Exactly - I've removed the saw which gives a nice slot to hold the long bit. Horses for courses - I never used the saw and I use the driver a lot.
There's a good bit of thread derailment right there!
In my previous posts, please read Powerlock as Powerassist ::)
-
@Cupboard said:
Except the wire cutters are crap, it doesn't have a OHO blade, its Phillips driver isn't as good as the Leatherman's, the file isn't as good as the Wave/Charge/Surge... etcIt's good, but it's not the best. Still, I'd go for it over the Powerlock. It's smaller and light than the SOG too isn't it?
I could forgive the Spirit all its other faults if it wasn't for the wire cutters' inability to cut most of the stranded wire I frequently cut with my Wave.
Not that your opinion isn't valid, but I don't understand this statement. My first Spirit was a very well worn example and I can remember trying it with stranded wire using the forward soft wire notch. It cut the stranded wire easily
My new Swisstool also cuts stranded wire easily, using the forward notch. On the other hand, I had a Wave which didn't make a brilliant job with this type of wire. The Wave in question had a minute amount of play in the plier head. Go figure :) -
back in 5 minutes, just going to raid some cable from work ;)
Edit: I think I'm going to add this to the stranded wire test, it's going to be a bit huge. The first test on some 0.2mm 1000V cable was that the Juice, Wave, Rebar, Skeletool, Wingman and Squirt all passed, Dime and Spirit failed. My Spirit is in better condition than the comparable Leathermans.
Link: http://forum.multitool.org/general-tool-discussion/stranded-wire-cut-off-test/msg793123/#msg793123
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login