Cultural differences?
-
As everyone should know by now, I am a huge fan of documentary type TV shows. In particular, two of my favorites are Mythbusters and Top Gear- especially the challenge episodes.
What I find interesting is that while the Mythbusters might do more dangerous things on a more regular basis, they are usually hindered (often at the last second!) by their insurance company that won't allow them to do certain things, or they have to take so many safety precautions that I swear it eats up over half the experiment's budget.
On the flip side, it seems that Jeremy, Hammond and James May can (and often do!) just about anything they like with little to no safety concerns at all. I mean, if Jamie and Adam wanted to drive around with with a dead cow on top of an old, decrepit Camaro, they'd have to spend hours reinforcing the roof to contain the extra weight, installing a roll cage to protect them in the off chance that the balance of the car was offset enough that they rolled it over etc.
I wonder if it has more to do with net worth, insurance or perhaps cultural differences? I can't imagine Jamie or Adam is worth significantly more than Jeremy Clarkson, and in fact I have to think Clarkson is probably worth more than the Mythbusters as he's been at it an awful lot longer.
Still, I bet the Mythbusters would have a hell of a lot more fun if they were held to the relatively lax rules that the Top Gear presenters are!
Def
-
Well, the TG shows are sort of co-produced (co-owned maybe? BBC?) by Clarkson I think, so maybe he has a lot more say in what happens.
Also, a lot goes behind the scenes that we do not see...
-
Maybe, but I can't see Jamie and Adam ever testing the myth that you can get killed in Alabama by making fun of rednecks in a hick town. Not personally anyway... :ahhh
Def
-
Also, if Jeremy Clarkson is co-owner of the brand, you would think there would be a lot more protections in place to keep him from getting injured or killed. As I said, his net worth would be bigger, although I think Jamie and Adam have some ownership of Mythbusters too, don't they?
Def
-
I think its more of a image thing. Mythbusters always talk a lot about safety and doing things safely. While Top Gear and Jeremy especially makes a point of making fun of health and safety. In reality I dont think the top gear guys takes more risks than the Mythbusters guys. If you look closely at top gear, you will sometimes see that they have put in roll cages and other safety precautions in some of the cars, but they hide it well. Also top gear try to make it look like things are happening by accident, while most of the serious stuff is probably carefully planned and coreagraphed. But I wont hold that against them, they still make excellent TV

-
There is probably a lot more goes on behind the scenes on Top Gear than we see compared to Myth Busters ;)
The Health & Safety regulations used to be a lot more lax over here until they started taking tips from the U.S :D
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Maybe, but I can't see Jamie and Adam ever testing the myth that you can get killed in Alabama by making fun of rednecks in a hick town. Not personally anyway... :ahhh
Def
LOL, that was a great episode! I know I sure as hell wouldn't do what they did! :ahhh
Bear in mind that most TG episodes are now about as spontaneous and realistic as WWE wrestling

-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Maybe, but I can't see Jamie and Adam ever testing the myth that you can get killed in Alabama by making fun of rednecks in a hick town. Not personally anyway... :ahhh
Def
LOL, that was a great episode! I know I sure as hell wouldn't do what they did! :ahhh
Bear in mind that most TG episodes are now about as spontaneous and realistic as WWE wrestling

Hey, WWE IS REAL!!!! :D
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Maybe, but I can't see Jamie and Adam ever testing the myth that you can get killed in Alabama by making fun of rednecks in a hick town. Not personally anyway... :ahhh
Def
LOL, that was a great episode! I know I sure as hell wouldn't do what they did! :ahhh
Bear in mind that most TG episodes are now about as spontaneous and realistic as WWE wrestling

YOU are about as spontaneous and realistic as WWE wrestling!

:sak: -
Despite the fact that their scientific methodology is seriously flawed, I think the Mythbusters want to educate and despite everything want to be taken serious.
Top Gear on the other is doing its best to not convey any information (they weeded those parts out long ago), its all about horse power and fun, fun fun.So essentially it boils down to:
Mythbuster: Science Program
Top Gear: Car-Themed Comedy -
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Maybe, but I can't see Jamie and Adam ever testing the myth that you can get killed in Alabama by making fun of rednecks in a hick town. Not personally anyway... :ahhh
Def
LOL, that was a great episode! I know I sure as hell wouldn't do what they did! :ahhh
Bear in mind that most TG episodes are now about as spontaneous and realistic as WWE wrestling

Although I am not a fan of the show since it is more like a demo of personal skill than survival skill, I tend to think Bear Grylls does take a lot of risk doing all sort of stunts than these two shows.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login