Comic geek stuff: Watchmen
-
I first read the Watchmen as a collected work in 1988. I have read it a LOT of times, not just READ it, but scrutinized every detail of the artwork, looking for hidden messages, clues, hints, etc.
There are a lot of awesome details in it that freak me out at how well they're thought out. I've read a couple literary discussions on the work, and there's still at least one thing that I've never seen anyone mention.
Ozymandias, in his 'origin story' sites Ramses II as his inspiration. He even has a painting of him solving the Gordian Knot by slicing it with a sword. Rorschach repeatedly kicks in doors, held shut by locks made by the 'Gordian Knot Lock Company'. In effect, Rorschach's solution is exactly the same as Ramses II to the problem of the Gordian Knot. And of course, Ozymandias hates Rorschach.
Rorschach, in a journal, as a child, sites Eisenhower as a 'good man'. Eisenhower, who ordered the deaths of many to (presumably) save more. This is exactly what Ozymandias does, killing millions to save billions. And Rorschach hates Ozymandias.
The irony is beautiful.
A few other interesting bits.
On page 4 of the first chapter, when the detectives are looking over the Blake crimescene, you can see a model sailing ship on the shelf behind one of the detectives, nodding to the later 'tales of the black freighter' story element.
The first image of chapter 3, a closeup of a fall-out shelter sign, has smoke obscuring the sign. The upper portion of the smoke makes the shape of a skull, and the unobscured letters say 'All Hel'.
When the creature is teleported into New York, into the Institute for Spacial Studies, its green blood covers all of the letters of the name, except for 'Or Al Die'. In that same panel, there's a comic book fluttering in the wind, with a back cover like the old Charles Atlas bodybuilding ads, which reads 'The Veidt Method. I will give you bodies beyond your wildest imaginings'. And just below THAT, an electric plug-in, with the familiar smiley face and blood spatter.
Virtually every clock seen in the book is at a time within 11 minutes to midnight/noon, closer to midnight in each chapter (the scene of Dan and Laurie's failed attempt at lovemaking being about the only exception). The smear of blood on Comedian's smiley face button also looks like a clock hand at about 11 to midnight, and on several occasions, other images take on this shape. Laurie's wiping away dust on Dan's goggles. Dan wiping away fog on his kitchen window. The radar sweep that's the first image of chapter 10 (in fact, also a smiley-face), the opening image in chapter 11, of a glimpse into Veidt's antarctic dome, The disintegrating bodies of the newsvendor and comic-reading kid.
In chapter 5, 'fearful symmetry', it's loaded with symmetrical images, but one is a poster of the band Grateful Dead, for an album called Aoxomoxoa. The poster is symmetrical, and the name is a palindrome. The file number on Drake's murder case is 801108. Also, the panel layout of the entire chapter is symmetrical, front-to-back. Seriously. Crazy stuff.
There are a ton of other details, but I thought I'd just post these for the moment.
I have been told there is a 'tunnel' running through one of hte chapters, but I haven't figured it out yet.
-
Wow. I really like the book but I've got nothing on your level of scrutiny.

-
Hmm I must dig out my copy again and read it.
Lynn, have your read any Scott Sigler?
-
Nope. You have any recommendations?
-
-
have any of you watched the Watchmen motion comic? it is cool how they took each cell and spoke the words. pretty cool.
as I was grabbing a link for it from Amazon, I discovered it is on $3.66 right now
-
I haven't seen that. Very cool.
I have the oversized, hardcover edition, with a bunch of additional material in the back (called 'Absolute Watchmen'). It's also the recolored version, but the color follows the original release version very closely, and on checking the print info, looks like it was just color touchup work, done by the original colorist. It makes spotting some of the smaller details in panels a little easier.
-
here is the trailer, gives you an idea how it is made
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
Nope. You have any recommendations?Any and all of them! he's very cool in the fact that he releases everything thing he does as an unabridged podcast.
Sci-fi, horror, genetics gone wrong, he's got it all :D
-
Alexander the Great severed the Gordian Knot, not Ramses II?
Def
-
I've always felt that Moores V for Vendetta ,and League of Extraordinary Gentlemen are much better,but then I'm British,and V for Vendetta is a British book,where as Watchmen is a semi satirical salute to the Golden Age books and heros of the States. I do also tend to think Moore is over keen to show how much smarter he believes he is compared to the reader.
But then,I still think his finest hour was DR and Quinch in 2000AD!
As DR says,a kiss on the wrist can be quite continental,but tactical thermonuclear weapons are a boy's best friend
-
Alexander, yes. Sorry.
As for Moore's greatest work... hard to say for me, but visually, Watchmen is certainly the best he's worked on, IMO.
I loved V for Vendetta. I was not super impressed with League of Extraordinary Gentlemen. That might have strictly been the art style, which left me dead cold. I also loved his run on Swamp Thing.
He's one of those writers who I think is a smurf-hole, but still like their work.
I was very turned off initially by Gibbon's stiff art style, but his sort of mechanical precision allowed an absurd number of unspoken bits to be added to the story, which I loved.
Watchmen isn't, at least to me, satyrical. It has been called 'the deconstruction of the superhero myth', and I think that's fair. It is certainly the first time I'd seen 'superheroes' done in such utterly gray moral tones. It was a weird set of circumstances that the story started off with EC comics characters (The Question, Judo Master, Captain Atom, etc.), then Moore/Gibbons devised analogues, THEN DC bought up EC, and acquired the legal rights to the characters that had originally been intended, but by that time, the Watchmen characters had taken on a life of their own becoming (IMO) better characters.
Alan Moore has an ego problem. But then so does Frank Miller, Neil Gaiman, and if I thought about it, I could probably come up with at least another half dozen. Neil Adams and Todd McFarlane, for instance.
I was told once, correctly so, that artists can make art, but they can't tell people what those pieces of art MEAN. They can intend meaning, but that's it. Interpretation is always going to be from the side of the viewer. Moore seems to NEED people to get what he intends, and if they don't, then obviously they're dolts. Which... makes him a smurf-hole, IMO.
Doesn't stop me from loving some of his work, though.
-
Neil Gaiman would be a much better author if he learned some other colors.
The dark darkness darkened into the inky blackness..... I think the man has a brown suit somewhere for festive occasions. ::)
Def
Sent from a digital multitool
-
@kirk13 said:
I've always felt that Moores V for Vendetta ,and League of Extraordinary Gentlemen are much better,but then I'm British,and V for Vendetta is a British book,where as Watchmen is a semi satirical salute to the Golden Age books and heros of the States. I do also tend to think Moore is over keen to show how much smarter he believes he is compared to the reader.But then,I still think his finest hour was DR and Quinch in 2000AD!
As DR says,a kiss on the wrist can be quite continental,but tactical thermonuclear weapons are a boy's best friend
Alan Moore IS much smarter than most of us!
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login





