Which SAKs suck?
-
Spartans and classics, you can't give them away.
I was surprised to see the Spartan and Classic mentioned in this thread. Two of my favorites, different strokes for different folks I guess.
Jim
Nothing wrong with the spartan or classic quality wise. Its just when you end up with dozens of them and they have parts noone wants, its hard to figure out what to do with them. I think a new spartan is worth about $10. But shipping a spartan is about 10 bucks... so I cant sell 1 as it costs the same to ship one out. Maybe I should offer a 10 pack of brand new spartans for 100 shipped and they might move then.
Classics are so common again the value is so low its hard to move them.
@Papa Rich said:
They are called Delemont, and all have their own part numbers. Looks like the Very common fast movers are still going to be sold.Very interesting news about Wenger! We've been dying here to find out what models will continue and which will be gone. Are they just keeping the 85mm and the big 130mm? All the lines? Any and all info appreciated!
-
Yes, heresy I know, but for me the much-loved Minichamp is a suckfest because although it
s a triumph of getting many tools into a small format, 3 of them are superfluous. The little Wharncliffe blade, the sharp hooky thing and the spatula device only get in the way and I couldnt wait to move mine on and dont miss it. If these extra "tools" are so popular why arent they on more 58s. Would anyone buy a knife with just the spatula thing, sharp hooky thing and tiny blade on it?
-
Classics and Spartans (with the miniscrewdriver) are great gifts to non enthusiasts. Really great gifts, don't think of them as $1 and $3 TSA ebay knives, think of them as high quality swiss tools. BO would make them even better, but for someone looking at them from a HAIII custom alox perspective well, they come up a bit short.
-
I haven't owned a Swiss made sak I didn't like.
I have owned Chinese rip off Saks that where unbelievable crappy .
:)
-
The 85mm line, at least, stays.
taaaaaaapaaaaaaas
-
I'll be right back, I have to put a stake in the ground and lay out some firewood...
Honestly, I've got three answers.
-Wenger. Only thing they ever did revolutionary was the wrench, but I never saw an 85mm that didn't have smurftastic snap and most of them had funky fit and finish. The 115s were worse. Actually, they did their version of the Soldier pretty well, but they were copying a Vic design and matching the material specs as per a contract. Good riddence.-Anything made in a limited run of a few hundred, and they get suckier the closer the maximum number gets to fifty.
-The Tomo. Feels like drek and uses the weaker tools of the 85mm line.
-
@ironraven said:
I'll be right back, I have to put a stake in the ground and lay out some firewood...Honestly, I've got three answers.
-Wenger. Only thing they ever did revolutionary was the wrench, but I never saw an 85mm that didn't have smurftastic snap and most of them had funky fit and finish. The 115s were worse. Actually, they did their version of the Soldier pretty well, but they were copying a Vic design and matching the material specs as per a contract. Good riddence.-Anything made in a limited run of a few hundred, and they get suckier the closer the maximum number gets to fifty.
-The Tomo. Feels like drek and uses the weaker tools of the 85mm line.
TOMO: The idea of the Tomo is to have maximum space for a company logo. It is design as company gift... But yes its fugly. I have no idea how this knife could win a design prize.
WENGER: They also made the self-locking screwdrivers. The 120mm are great. 85mm with lock. SpeSmurfpillset tools (my favorit is the Bernina). But I agree their design and quality is never on par with Victorinox (The company that evolves slower than snails).
-
The TOMO is a beautiful design.
As for suckage...I have never seen a SAK that did this. How they possibly could get the vacuum part miniaturized to do this is beyond doubt, a major feat. Mind you, if they ever did make a SAK that sucked, I would be the first in line to buy one. :D
-
@gardenvalley said:
Yes, heresy I know, but for me the much-loved Minichamp is a suckfest because although its a triumph of getting many tools into a small format, 3 of them are superfluous. The little Wharncliffe blade, the sharp hooky thing and the spatula device only get in the way and I couldnt wait to move mine on and dont miss it. If these extra "tools" are so popular why arent they on more 58s. Would anyone buy a knife with just the spatula thing, sharp hooky thing and tiny blade on it?
I actually like the small Wharncliffe blade and the sharp hooky thing is great for opening clam shell/blister packaging. ;)
Victorinox Swiss Army The Hook Tool (aka Clamshell Opener) Available at KnifeCenter
-
Yes, heresy I know, but for me the much-loved Minichamp is a suckfest because although it
s a triumph of getting many tools into a small format, 3 of them are superfluous. The little Wharncliffe blade, the sharp hooky thing and the spatula device only get in the way and I couldnt wait to move mine on and dont miss it. If these extra "tools" are so popular why arent they on more 58s. Would anyone buy a knife with just the spatula thing, sharp hooky thing and tiny blade on it?
I actually like the small Wharncliffe blade and the sharp hooky thing is great for opening clam shell/blister packaging. ;)
Victorinox Swiss Army The Hook Tool (aka Clamshell Opener) Available at KnifeCenter
This. Which is why I'm now carrying a Vic Vagabond in Alox, made by our own HankSolon :)
-
Oh I forgot about the Tomo. I completely dismissed it when it came out since it looks well, dumb. Makes sense if its for advertising though.
-
I'd say that there are stupid tools, but never could I say that a SAK sucks. Maybe Tomo though... I've seen some hilarious posts about them here and now I forgot where :(
-
@papercut said:
Classics and Spartans (with the miniscrewdriver) are great gifts to non enthusiasts. Really great gifts, don't think of them as $1 and $3 TSA ebay knives, think of them as high quality swiss tools. BO would make them even better, but for someone looking at them from a HAIII custom alox perspective well, they come up a bit short.I've finished up a few Spartans that a lot of actual enthusiasts wanted for themselves...

It's my favorite celidor model for modding besides the Tinker.
-
every 91mm SAK without scissors

-
Oh another thing about the Tomo is has no T&T. So take a classic, remove T&T and make large weird not SAK looking plastic scales.
To be fair though it doesnt look like a SAK so I never really though of it as a SAK even though its make by Victorinox.
-
my vote goes to anything with the combo tool. I have a 84 mm waiter and I have had a hard time opening cans and it sucks as a screwdriver.
-
@Papa Rich said:
[quote author=Papa Rich link=topic=49170.msg819418#msg819418 date=1388168271]
Wenger is still alive and will be sold by Victorinox USA, using the Delemont name. Rich


A bit harsh for the guys second post Tosh. >:(
Not really Gareth
I suspect, like most of us did - Papa Rich has been with us for some time before joining.
Welcome to the forum Papa

You're gonna love it here!!

Thank you ! Are you laughing ?
[/quote]Welcome PapaRich!
I'm very happy to hear the news about Delemont knives. By any chance, are there any of the Ranger series in the catalogues? :D
Wow Tosh,
Looks like you're gonna take one for the team on this. ;)
Oh well, at least you got some very nice SAK's in the process and PapaRich may have helped you save your retirement investments. :D
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
Wow Tosh,Looks like you're gonna take one for the team on this. ;)
Oh well, at least you got some very nice SAK's in the process and PapaRich may have helped you save
your retirement investments. :DOuch!! That was low Mr Whippy
I think I may have OD on the Wenger's, just a little!!
Never mind, it'll curb my spending habits for the next........
10yrs 
As a wiseman once said
"money has no value unless you spend it" ;)REMEMBER : He Who Laughs Last Laughs Longest
-
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
