Which SAKs suck?
-
@gardenvalley said:
Yes, heresy I know, but for me the much-loved Minichamp is a suckfest because although its a triumph of getting many tools into a small format, 3 of them are superfluous. The little Wharncliffe blade, the sharp hooky thing and the spatula device only get in the way and I couldnt wait to move mine on and dont miss it. If these extra "tools" are so popular why arent they on more 58s. Would anyone buy a knife with just the spatula thing, sharp hooky thing and tiny blade on it?
I actually like the small Wharncliffe blade and the sharp hooky thing is great for opening clam shell/blister packaging. ;)
Victorinox Swiss Army The Hook Tool (aka Clamshell Opener) Available at KnifeCenter
-
Yes, heresy I know, but for me the much-loved Minichamp is a suckfest because although it
s a triumph of getting many tools into a small format, 3 of them are superfluous. The little Wharncliffe blade, the sharp hooky thing and the spatula device only get in the way and I couldnt wait to move mine on and dont miss it. If these extra "tools" are so popular why arent they on more 58s. Would anyone buy a knife with just the spatula thing, sharp hooky thing and tiny blade on it?
I actually like the small Wharncliffe blade and the sharp hooky thing is great for opening clam shell/blister packaging. ;)
Victorinox Swiss Army The Hook Tool (aka Clamshell Opener) Available at KnifeCenter
This. Which is why I'm now carrying a Vic Vagabond in Alox, made by our own HankSolon :)
-
Oh I forgot about the Tomo. I completely dismissed it when it came out since it looks well, dumb. Makes sense if its for advertising though.
-
I'd say that there are stupid tools, but never could I say that a SAK sucks. Maybe Tomo though... I've seen some hilarious posts about them here and now I forgot where :(
-
@papercut said:
Classics and Spartans (with the miniscrewdriver) are great gifts to non enthusiasts. Really great gifts, don't think of them as $1 and $3 TSA ebay knives, think of them as high quality swiss tools. BO would make them even better, but for someone looking at them from a HAIII custom alox perspective well, they come up a bit short.I've finished up a few Spartans that a lot of actual enthusiasts wanted for themselves...

It's my favorite celidor model for modding besides the Tinker.
-
every 91mm SAK without scissors

-
Oh another thing about the Tomo is has no T&T. So take a classic, remove T&T and make large weird not SAK looking plastic scales.
To be fair though it doesnt look like a SAK so I never really though of it as a SAK even though its make by Victorinox.
-
my vote goes to anything with the combo tool. I have a 84 mm waiter and I have had a hard time opening cans and it sucks as a screwdriver.
-
@Papa Rich said:
[quote author=Papa Rich link=topic=49170.msg819418#msg819418 date=1388168271]
Wenger is still alive and will be sold by Victorinox USA, using the Delemont name. Rich


A bit harsh for the guys second post Tosh. >:(
Not really Gareth
I suspect, like most of us did - Papa Rich has been with us for some time before joining.
Welcome to the forum Papa

You're gonna love it here!!

Thank you ! Are you laughing ?
[/quote]Welcome PapaRich!
I'm very happy to hear the news about Delemont knives. By any chance, are there any of the Ranger series in the catalogues? :D
Wow Tosh,
Looks like you're gonna take one for the team on this. ;)
Oh well, at least you got some very nice SAK's in the process and PapaRich may have helped you save your retirement investments. :D
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
Wow Tosh,Looks like you're gonna take one for the team on this. ;)
Oh well, at least you got some very nice SAK's in the process and PapaRich may have helped you save
your retirement investments. :DOuch!! That was low Mr Whippy
I think I may have OD on the Wenger's, just a little!!
Never mind, it'll curb my spending habits for the next........
10yrs 
As a wiseman once said
"money has no value unless you spend it" ;)REMEMBER : He Who Laughs Last Laughs Longest
-
-
-
Spartans and classics, you can't give them away.
I was surprised to see the Spartan and Classic mentioned in this thread. Two of my favorites, different strokes for different folks I guess.
Jim
I have to agree with Jim here.
I think the Spartan is a top-ten SAK: perfect form factor, every tool useful and time-tested, the direct descendant of the original SAK.
The Classic, true, comes off on the losing end of comparison with the Rambler and Manager, but it *is *the best selling pocketknife in the world.
The only problem with these two is they're so common. So, no sex appeal, no cachet. But, if the Galactic Overlords decreed that everyone must carry one and only one SAK, and they assigned me the Spartan, I'd be glad that's the one I got.
-
@tosh said:
REMEMBER : He Who Laughs Last Laughs LongestNope, only villains get to laugh long and hard

Thanks pal

Why do I get the feeling I'm digging myself a hole here.
I'm gonna live in denial!

So, the question is, which SAK is best for digging holes?
Probably something with the Pharmaceutical Spatula. but it would be slow going.

-
@Thunderpants said:
Thanks to ebay I now own a Spartan Lite. What a crummy knife!The inline Phillips is the reason I got it. It's lovely. The problem is the blob of gray plastic that makes up the "Lite." I guess this is news to no-one, but this thing is so dim the hubble telescope probably couldn't find it. Most black holes spill more photons than this piece of no-Watt garbage. It's plastic, it's ugly, it's a waste of space, and I can't for the life of me imagine why Victorinox tarnishes its good name with such a dismally unsuccesful gimmick.
This thing deserves to rattle around ebay for eternity.
I have to agree - I've avoided any SAK with a light and I'd recommend the Explorer Plus over that junk you got.
I bought a Manager recently and really like it, no way was I going to buy the Midnite Manager.
On my keyring with my Manager is also my Fenix L0D - The L0D would be eleventy times as good as whatever they put on the Midnite Manager!!!!!Apart from my Fenix L0D I also have an ITP A3 EOS and a Liteflux LF2XT which are also fantastic 1 x AAA lights. I have a bunch of fauxtons that I give away to friends that want a small & light keyring light - they cost very little and put out more light than what Victorinox use.
I don't have a SAK that I think sucks, but I have no SAKs with lights.
There are other SAKs that I've avoided buying for various reasons, not really that they suck, more that there are better options.
I don't own a Classic because I think for the size & weight (or close to it) the Rambler is much better or the Manager if a pen would be useful to have. The Classic is OK but is made much better by adding the combo tool with phillips screwdriver. Sure the Classic is a big seller, but the other options in that size range are so much better!Apart from my dislike of the crappy lite versions, it is hard to think of much wrong with the majority of Victorinox SAKs. They are great quality with a range of useful tools and you can always find a model that is the right compromise of size & weight vs utility.
-
The TOMO is terrible, but if you round off the corners and add T&T, then you'd have.... the Classic SD. ::)
Yeah, the TOMO was a complete waste of time.
-
Which SAK is best for digging holes? Why the TOMO of course. The Classic with its rounded edges would move less dirt with each scoop.
-
What's a TOMO?
-
See under Classic variations #7 for more info.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login