Any Jeepers out there?
-
I'm roughing it in my Wrangler, I only have a 6" touch screen and completely separate controls for my environment controls. :ahhh
Def
-
:D lol our durango "only" had a 6" touch screen too, dont know how we ever got by. I figure the built in controls are only another thing to go wrong but as long as its under warranty and the wife is happy so am i.
-
Yeah, I got the extended electrical warranty on mine as there are almost as many buttons in it as there are in the average space shuttle. Seriously, I think there are more buttons on the steering wheel alone as there are in my whole TJ. In fact, if you don't count the preset buttons on my stereo, there actually are more buttons on the steering wheel of my JKU than there are in my TJ!
ef
-
I actually like those new Cherokees. It's has one of those faces that only a mother could love haha. I've actually heard good things about the trailhawk's off road capabilities. The owner of it actually traded in his jk for it. He said he ran a few of the same trails in both and although the wrangler made it through easier the Cherokee was no slouch.
As for the blinker mod I did the method you see online. Very easy to do. I used a weatherproof quick splice connector and a good amount of electrical tape. I like it a lot.
-
Anybody compared a newer 4WD car (offroader) with lots of electronic aids with an older (e.g., 20 year old) basic 4WD car with only locking hubs and a locking central differential?
Seeing the new Range Rovers (especially the new sport) I am intrigued by how easily they seem to overcome obstacles, on TV and still be like a normal car most of the time. Are the electronics that good nowadays or do they just make it as good as an ordinary offroad car. (The land rover electronics do have a very bad reputation, but they may be getting better)
EDIT: Here is what I mean. A mechanical offroader (it is a jeep but it could have been any other standard offroader) Vs the electronics of Rover. As far as I know the discovery does not have locking axles and neither, it seems , does the jeep.
-
That's a question that is debated a lot and I don't think has any real answer. The electronics in my new Jeep (JKU) make it easier to off road because it does all the thinking for you. Hill Descent Mode and skid control are two very helpful things to have, and that's why they were invented. If they didn't serve a purpose, they wouldn't exist.
HOWEVER, they also insulate the driver from the terrain, which isn't a good thing, and if something gets broken, they are impossible to fix at the side of the trail. My old TJ doesn't go anywhere unless you make it go there- you are very much a part of the process and you have to not only pay attention to what you are doing, but you have to make intelligent choices about how much to be on the clutch, whether to be in 2WD, 4HI or 4LO, you have to give it the gas and the brake, decide what gear to be in going in, and what gear to be in coming out, and the simple TJ gives you the freedom to decide how you want to do something.
All in all it comes down to driving style, what type of terrain you are on, and what your comfort and experience levels are.
In the woods I prefer my TJ because I like feeling connected to the ground under me, and I like to be forced to concentrate on what I am doing. I have friends who would rather just put it in gear and just steer the rest of the trip, letting the truck do the work.
Def
-
I do like the sense of achievement you get from doing the work yourself, but just pointing the car towards a hill with the electronics in auto and just watching it show you what IT can do must be fun too.
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
That's a question that is debated a lot and I don't think has any real answer. The electronics in my new Jeep (JKU) make it easier to off road because it does all the thinking for you. Hill Descent Mode and skid control are two very helpful things to have, and that's why they were invented. If they didn't serve a purpose, they wouldn't exist.HOWEVER, they also insulate the driver from the terrain, which isn't a good thing, and if something gets broken, they are impossible to fix at the side of the trail. My old TJ doesn't go anywhere unless you make it go there- you are very much a part of the process and you have to not only pay attention to what you are doing, but you have to make intelligent choices about how much to be on the clutch, whether to be in 2WD, 4HI or 4LO, you have to give it the gas and the brake, decide what gear to be in going in, and what gear to be in coming out, and the simple TJ gives you the freedom to decide how you want to do something.
All in all it comes down to driving style, what type of terrain you are on, and what your comfort and experience levels are.
In the woods I prefer my TJ because I like feeling connected to the ground under me, and I like to be forced to concentrate on what I am doing. I have friends who would rather just put it in gear and just steer the rest of the trip, letting the truck do the work.
Def
I agree, personally I'd rather not have the electronics do the thinking for me. I do prefer an automatic for offroading though. There are times when it's nice to be able to use your left foot on the brake, and right on the gas. For regular daily driving, I do prefer a standard though.
Some people do need the vehicle to do all the thinking for them though. Whether it's due to lack of skill, or knowledge, or laziness. I can see hill decent being a nice feature though, but I don't have it, and have done fine so far without, same with you in the TJ.
-
Hill descent almost killed me once. I decided to try it out on a hill but there's a lot more to it than just pressing the button. You have to be in 4WD, not touch the pedals, spin around three times and blow a kiss to a full moon for it to come on.
Anyways I apparently didn't do it all properly and I came barreling down a dirt hill, then when I tried to show down I started to slide, then started to go sideways. I was not amused.
I look at all of these devices as ways to try to recreate the benefits of a manual transmission. Hill descent mode in my TJ was called second gear, with one foot on the brake and the other on the clutch. Best part was, it wasn't difficult to activate. :D
It strikes me as false economy when I see them develop a new system to make things easier then have to develop three other systems to recreate the functionality of the initial, simpler system.
Like the "collision avoidance system" found in new cars that lights up on the dash when you are about to run into something. I remember when we used to use a windshield for that.
Def
Sent from a digital multitool
-
Did I ever mention I love my Jeep Patriot. Best snow machine I have ever owned. :D
-
@dks said:
EDIT: Here is what I mean. A mechanical offroader (it is a jeep but it could have been any other standard offroader) Vs the electronics of Rover. As far as I know the discovery does not have locking axles and neither, it seems , does the jeep.The Dicovery might not have locking differentials, but the electrickery was using individual wheel brakes to stop a spinning wheel from spinning, thus forcing the diff to transfer most of the torque to the other wheel on the axle (usually the one with more weight on it and therefore more traction). The Jeep obviously wasn't using axle diff locks, as every time it lifted a wheel that unweighted wheel would spin.
In effect the Discovery behaves as if it had diff locks (just that they are electronically operated on individual wheels). If the Jeep had functional diff locks it would have sailed up just as easy as the Discovery, or perhaps even slightly easier with no spinning wheels or hesitation at all.
Given the (well deserved) bad reputation Land Rovers (and Range Rovers) have for electrical failures I think I'd prefer more reliable mechanically operated diff locks for serious off road work. When I had Toyota Land Cruisers I ran a mix of Detroit Lockers and ARB air lockers. I preferred the ARBs because I could run with open diffs when I wanted (Detroit Lockers are always "on" and mess with steering response, even when they are in the rear diff).
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Hill descent almost killed me once. I decided to try it out on a hill but there's a lot more to it than just pressing the button. You have to be in 4WD, not touch the pedals, spin around three times and blow a kiss to a full moon for it to come on.Anyways I apparently didn't do it all properly and I came barreling down a dirt hill, then when I tried to show down I started to slide, then started to go sideways. I was not amused.
I look at all of these devices as ways to try to recreate the benefits of a manual transmission. Hill descent mode in my TJ was called second gear, with one foot on the brake and the other on the clutch. Best part was, it wasn't difficult to activate. :D
It strikes me as false economy when I see them develop a new system to make things easier then have to develop three other systems to recreate the functionality of the initial, simpler system.
Like the "collision avoidance system" found in new cars that lights up on the dash when you are about to run into something. I remember when we used to use a windshield for that.
Def
Sent from a digital multitool
Not touching the pedals wouldn't be an easy thing to get used to! I can always tell if someone is driving a standard on the trails, as their brake lights will seldom come on, where I'll be on the brakes quite a bit.
A lot of new systems are designed to remove the driver from the actual experience of driving. I mean, with systems that will slow you down if you're too close to the car in front of you, and will steer for you if you start to wonder out of your lane, and will parallel park for you automatically, they are taking the joys and responsibilities out of it.
@Chako said:
Did I ever mention I love my Jeep Patriot. Best snow machine I have ever owned. :DNo, I don't think you have mentioned it yet Dan.
:D 
EDIT: Here is what I mean. A mechanical offroader (it is a jeep but it could have been any other standard offroader) Vs the electronics of Rover. As far as I know the discovery does not have locking axles and neither, it seems , does the jeep.
The Dicovery might not have locking differentials, but the electrickery was using individual wheel brakes to stop a spinning wheel from spinning, thus forcing the diff to transfer most of the torque to the other wheel on the axle (usually the one with more weight on it and therefore more traction). The Jeep obviously wasn't using axle diff locks, as every time it lifted a wheel that unweighted wheel would spin.
In effect the Discovery behaves as if it had diff locks (just that they are electronically operated on individual wheels). If the Jeep had functional diff locks it would have sailed up just as easy as the Discovery, or perhaps even slightly easier with no spinning wheels or hesitation at all.
Given the (well deserved) bad reputation Land Rovers (and Range Rovers) have for electrical failures I think I'd prefer more reliable mechanically operated diff locks for serious off road work. When I had Toyota Land Cruisers I ran a mix of Detroit Lockers and ARB air lockers. I preferred the ARBs because I could run with open diffs when I wanted (Detroit Lockers are always "on" and mess with steering response, even when they are in the rear diff).
Yep, you don't need to have mechanical lockers to have the benefits of them. I actually really like systems that will brake the spinning wheel so the one with traction will get power. Even though it's electronicly activated, I'd prefer that over a lunch box locker, or air locker. For adding a locker though, I'd love to install ARB air lockers in my rig! The cost is pretty crazy for them though, so I'll never end up getting them. I could install Spartan or Aussie lockers front and rear for cheaper than doing just the rear with ARB.
-
I do sometimes drive a soft-roader with hill decent but I never really use it as it is, after all, a soft roader.
I believe that hill decent was introduced (in the freelander?) to help cars that did not have low gears get down hills (and then realise that they can not get up.. :D ).
On a regular offroader I just put the car in low, 1st gear, and let it slowly go down the hill. A good car should have the ability to go down mostly unaided.
It makes sense that you will go into 1st low before you start going down ;)
It is rarely needed to touch the breaks or the throttle (some obstruction, maybe wanting to go a bit faster/slower, slipping and trying to stop the slippage)
-
That looks pretty sweet!
Def
Sent from a digital multitool
-
To what you guys were saying about all the electronic aids and equipment, I personally think it is just over complicating the vehicles and making it even easier to have bad driving habits. These systems can't replace a skillful driver and a competent vehicle and yet it seems that is the way everything is progressing. Most of the new offerings from Jeep sort of make me sad(save for the wrangler of course, but there is rumors even that will have IFS soon). When I was younger I loved flipping through Four Wheeler magazine fantasizing about having my own jeep but I don't know where the tough and reliable brand I loved went. I know this is an advancing world and things are getting more technical and intelligent but to me it doesn't seem that it is getting better. I love the Jeep brand and would still love to own an early 2000s Cherokee but I wish they would come back towards what made them such an iconic brand because I would be at the dealership in a heartbeat. I wish I could say I was in the club too but I'm driving the Grand Cherokee's fat cousin, 2003 Durango SLT.
-
There's nothing wrong with a Durango- in fact, I had seriously considered getting one a few years ago. I like them a lot.
You are right, that a lot of this stuff just helps people with no skill get through rougher terrain than they would ordinarily, but it does come in handy sometimes for the experienced driver, and occasionally makes things easier for them as well. I'm a bit harsher on these functions simply because I am used to driving a Jeep that is about as raw as they come- my old TJ.
If the Wrangler ever goes IFS then this JKU will be the last Jeep I buy. I wasn't thrilled when they got rid of the old 4L engine and replaced with with the 3.8L, which was the wrong engine for the Wrangler. It was only after they switched to the 3.6L Pentastar (I know, same engine but better setup) that I considered a Jeep again. Even though I have two of them, I don't consider myself a Jeep Guy- I bought one only because there were no other options in the SUV market for a solid front axle. I guess I may have to go to a pickup next, but luckily I have a decade or so before I have to worry about that.
By the way, in three more days my JKU will be a year old. :D
Def
-
Oh, and a few thoughts on "Jeep" as a brand-
I like the Jeep brand, I do. I also like VW, Mercedes, Porsche, GM and Ford. I dislike "Jeep People" and there are two kinds of those that I dislike equally.
Type A is your typical "You can only offroad in a Jeep, and nothing else is a Jeep" type person. I wheel with a few of them, and the fact is, you can "wheel" in just about anything with varying degrees of success. Yes, the Wrangler is probably the best (if not pretty close to it) off roader out of the box, but these guys usually spend a good $10k on upgrades like lift kits, bigger tires, bumpers etc (which I will probably do too, eventually :P) to make it better. Personally I firmly believe that any car can be a good off roader with $10k worth of activity specific upgrades. These people however are "Jeep or nothin'" and don't realize that as good as the Jeep is, it's the person behind the wheel or it's the ditch. Jeep is simply a good tool for the job, but you can hammer a nail with a rock, and Jeep is not the Be All, End All.
On the flip side of the coin is the "Fashion Jeep Accessory" type people. I have a friend like this, although I won't mention who- she has a Jeep Patriot not because it's a decent truck in it's own right, but because she wanted a "Jeep" the same way she wants a Gucci or whatever the latest handbags are. If Jeep made a small hybrid hatchback she'd probably buy that just because it said Jeep on it and that was the bottom line for her. No other brand of truck would do, she needed to have a Jeep, and she wanted one as far away from a "real" Jeep (the Wrangler) as possible because she didn't like the way my old TJ rode. Admittedly my TJ is a very rough ride, but then, that's what a Jeep is all about. A rough vehicle is going to have a fairly rough ride. I don't see much point to buying something that is famous for being one thing, then buying something that has the name but none of the things it's famous for. (No offense to Chako here, who has a Patriot and loves it- he bought it because it was the right rig for him at the right price and at the right time, not just because it said Jeep on the front!)
I suppose technically these folks have the same issue, they just approach it in different ways. I appreciate a Jeep for what it is- inexpensive, capable and solid enough for the things I want (need) it to do for fun and work. If and when I replace my JKU I'll be looking at all of my options again, and if the Toyota FJ, Nissan XTerra or other vehicle became available in the price point I want with the features I want I'd seriously consider them as well, even though on the whole I don't like Toyota or Nissan. I may have a preference for Jeep, but I'd rather have the right tool for the job, regardless of what's stamped on the handle.
Rant over... :P
Def
-
I wouldn't say I'm a Jeep guy either. We bought the Grand Cherokee because we needed something that would haul our trail, and eventually something bigger, and I wanted something I could go offroading with. The Grand really was the only good option that was out there.
I don't like the type A Jeep people, which is why I have never been on a run with the Jeep Club. Just chatting on their forum was enough for me to know that even I, being in a Jeep, wouldn't be good enough because it wasn't a Wrangler or a Cherokee. I enjoy going with the Backcountry crew since there's always a good mix of different rigs. Toyota, Nissan, Jeep, Ford, Suzuki, Mercedes, Hummer, you name it, you'll see it, and no one cares what you drive.
I have no idea what my next rig will be. If we decide not to camp, and go to cottages instead, I'll probably buy either a TJ or JK. The biggest reason being parts availability, and capability. I'm not overly concerned with comfort, but I do have to say, the Grand is rather cozy through the rough stuff. :D
-
No offence taken. I don't do any offroading, nor do I have any interest for it. I do play a lot in the snow because of where I live. My biggest impetus for the Patriot...last year, I got stuck twice going to work in my Chevy Venture van. Sometimes, you don't have the time to clean the driveway to get to work on time. Being late twice pissed me off that I reckoned my next vehicle would be a better winter vehicle. After much research and time, I settled on a Patriot (I wasn't even looking at Jeep to be honest) because a co-worker loved hers. I was looking for a larger vehicle but I did like her Patriot. It grew on me. Once I saw that it had a lot more clearance than my van, and on/off 4x4, I was sold. That and the price was nice once I found one to my liking. I looked at a Compass but it was way far smaller than the Patriot with its boxy styling.
Things I don't like about my Patriot.
- CVT is a bit weird until you get used to it.
- Engine noise is a little more noticeable at times...but that is a very minor quibble. People pay big bucks to hear their hot rod engines. Me, I get to pretend I have one at times lol.
- Orange night lights on the front are off the bumper...meaning one has to clear the bumper of snow for others to see them. Another minor quibble. But if it was designed purely for winter climates, I know they would have placed them higher on the front...I hope.
Things I like about my Patriot.
- Lighted cup holders. That is a nice little touch.
- 4x4 for winter driving. This makes a huge difference. A friend of mine has a vehicle that has all wheel drive...but she hates it because it doesn't work all that well in wintertime. She doesn't get the traction when she needs it. I let her test drive the Patriot, and she told me that the Patriot is a perfect winter driver. I have to agree.
- The size. I was looking to downsize my vehicle from the larger minivan...but didn't know it at the time I was looking for a vehicle. The Patriot is just the right size.
- Heated side mirrors and seats. I thought the seats were gimmicky...but I have come to appreciate them on minus 30 Celsius days. Heated mirrors...every vehicle that drives in winter climates should have this as standard. Now if only I could get heated wipers...I would have it made.
- No hidden wipers. The old Chevy Venture van had hidden wipers designed purely for tropical climates. Oh how I hated those wipers when they got iced up etc. I made sure the new vehicle...whatever it was going to be, didn't have hidden wipers.
So there you have it. Why I bought a Jeep Patriot. I am very happy with it. I know a lot of Jeep "People" look down on it. It is no offroader by any accounts, but then, not many need that capability. :)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login