Any Jeepers out there?
-
I was having the parts discussion with a guy at work the other day. He has an old MGB, which admittedly is a bit different than most off roaders since, you know, it's not an off roader! :P
Still, the parts issue is the same for most European vehicles here, regardless of the brand or type- you have to go to the dealer (if there is one) or a specialty shop. The guy at work was saying "I have no problem obtaining parts- there's a company in Montreal I deal with."
Well, now that's excellent, except that Montreal is approximately 1,000 kms away from here, so it best not be a part I'm in a hurry for as the best I could get is obtaining the part tomorrow if I pay extra for overnight shipping. So, basically, pay extra to a specialty shop or dealer then pay extra for shipping or, in the case of my Jeep, go to Canadian Tire, UAP/NAPA, Parts Source, or even places like Sears, Costco or Wal Mart to buy parts (usually batteries or wiper blades) and walk out with what I need. All of these are within ten kilometers of my house- most much less. There's even a place called Action Car and Truck in that range that has all kinds of specialty truck parts for towing, lifting, adding lights and other custom touches. They are a bit pricier than some of the other places, but they are a specialty shop like the one in Montreal, but they are at least local.
I would imagine that in Europe, and especially the UK it's a lot easier to buy parts for Land Rovers than any Jeeps, just as it's easier to get Jeep parts here than Land Rover parts. That being said, I would love to have a Defender or other classic Land Rover. Sadly I am hearing rumors that the Defender is being discontinued, which I find tragic and upsetting.
Def
-
It really depends on where you live here as well. I'm just a few minutes from Boston so as you can imagine there isn't too many trails that close to me. So there is no offroad shop remotely close either :(. For most upgrade parts my only option is to go online, which isn't my first choice. Granted the Durangos don't have the best aftermarket following but it would be nice to have a few options as well as someone with a little more knowledge to talk to. Cupboard, why are small diesels so popular over there?
-
A Jeep isn't an off road vehicle, or at least not in the conventional sense that everyone thinks of- a Jeep, like many 4x4's is a vehicle that is all about options. It works well in the city- in fact, my TJ is perhaps the absolute best vehicle I have ever operated in any of the cities I've ever been to. The high degree of visibility, short wheelbase and significant visibility around you means there isn't a parking space in the world you can't squeeze into. The TJ is ideal for driving in the city as it is more nimble than most small commuter type economy cars. I'd put it against a Yaris or Fiat 500 in a city any day.
The benefit is that when the weather gets bad (as I'm sure you have encountered in Boston) the Jeep (or Land Rover, Durango, Suburban etc) is capable of operating when roads are somewhat flooded, or able to hop curbs when there's a large branch across the road (to say nothing of having the available torque needed to push or pull that branch off the road!) or even if there's more than six inches of snow and/or slush on the road.
Most of my so called "off roading" is done on the road, between bad weather days, major storms, construction and minor flooding, not to mention some of the places I work!
A 4x4 isn't just an off roader- it's a multitool with wheels. :D
Def
-
That last statement couldn't be more true, I personally don't think I will ever buy a vehicle that doesn't have 4WD. I definitely don't have the nimble factor going in my favor(steers like a barge) but it has been used for every task from towing to wheeling to road trips and everything in between. Having 4WD is great piece of mind, it doesn't ensure your safety in bad conditions but it sure does give you a better chance of making it out. I haven't had to shovel out a parking spot in over a year of owning my truck, I think that is worth the price of the vehicle:D. Not to mention it is pretty fun when you get them off the beaten path and see what they really can do.
-
@Higgins617 said:
Cupboard, why are small diesels so popular over there?Because they can do everything you need them to. A current Defender has a 2.2 diesel, from about 2007 it had a 2.4 and from 1999 to then it had a 2.5, 5 cylinder. Before the TD5 both the 200Tdi and 300Tdi with 2.5l with around about the same power. You're looking at 120HP-ish and that means they're not particularly quick but you can still get to the speed limit eventually. Discoveries seem to be most common with around a 3l these days and they're much quicker. Most "normal" pickups and 4x4s seem to have 2.5-3l, 4- or 6- cylinder diesels because they do the job without costing the earth to run.
Move to something like a BMW X5 or a Porshe whateveritscalled or even a Range Rover and you'll have a bigger and more powerful engine, but that's a completely different class of vehicle. They're luxury cars rather than utility vehicles.
IMO on small roads your speed is limited by your brakes and visibility, and on big roads you're limited by the speed limit. Once you have enough power, any more doesn't really get you far. It depends what you want the vehicle for really.
In the UK you can't have a trailer of more than 3500kgs until you're towing it with the next class up vehicle with the next class up license, and you can tow a 3500kg trailer with a Defender, Discovery and Isuzu D-Max. The Defender's off-road ability is at the top of its game and combined with the towing ability is why we have one on the farm. There's nothing else out there that can do everything we use it for. A larger engine with more power wouldn't increase the towing ability, wouldn't increase the off-road ability and would increase the weight and fuel consumption.
My only personal car at the moment is a little tin box with a 1.4 petrol but for what I do I don't need anything more. In this part of the world I'm very unlikely to get properly stuck with a LTB and it's a compromise I'm willing to make for the sake of a few pennies. I am after a 110 hard top as more of a fun vehicle.
@Grant Lamontagne said:
A 4x4 isn't just an off roader- it's a multitool with wheels. :DDef

You're quite right. And for someone like you and everyone that's been part of this thread they're a great asset.
Go in to London and they're just a menace, again IMO.@Grant Lamontagne said:
Sadly I am hearing rumors that the Defender is being discontinued, which I find tragic and upsetting.Def
Yup, 2015 springs to mind. There are some emissions regulations coming in that outlaw it.
The DC100 concept they released looks, to my mind, rather more like a Wrangler. Not really the out and out commercial vehicle that the Defender is. -
I've never driven in London, but I do watch a lot of Top Gear... :P
seriously, my TJ is perfect for roads in old cities. Halifax is one of the oldest cities in North America (which I realize makes it very new compared to London! :P) but we also suffer from narrow roads and limited parking, and that was one of the things I loved about my TJ the most. The new JKU is longer and has less visibility thanks to the added length, headrests on the back seats and smaller windows and I really notice the difference in driving downtown.
For comparison, my Jeep TJ has a much narrower turning circle than my VW Golf, so if you can drive a Golf in London the Jeep wouldn't be a problem. Provided you have an older two door... :D
Def
-
Being that we mostly have gas engines in passenger vehicles here( though more and more are available with small diesels) I'm pretty confident that my towing capability would suffer greatly from a smaller engine. My fathers Liberty with the 3.7l V6 has to work overtime to move our 18 foot bowrider. My truck on the other hand hardly breaks a sweat. But my MPG is barely into the double digits. So I can see where a small torquey diesel would be a good fit. Grant, Top Gear is by far my favorite TV show so I'm there with you.
-
Ignore this

Sent from my iPhone 5 using Tapatalk
-
I wish we had Diesel engines available in more vehicles here. Not just for 4x4s, but everything. Our old 02 Jetta was diesel, and 5spd, and it was a dream to drive. Even on the steepest hills, you could release the clutch some, than then brake, and it would pull you right up. On level ground, you could start out in 2nd without having to give it any throttle. You just plain and simple can not beat the low end grunt of a diesel.
Sent from my iPhone 5 using Tapatalk
-
Yeah they make better low end torque than any comparable gas engine does, I don't know personally but from what I've read the new diesels available in the Grand Cherokees and Rams are supposed to be pretty solid work horses. 420 Ft/Lbs of torque in the Grand with a turbo which is good for 7200Lbs towing for the 4x4.(3265kg for you silly metric people :D) I don't personally want one but it sounds like a great other option.
-
The main issue with diesels is that you can not take a good run at a hill, something that the US based people with their V8s seem to be able to do easily.
We just have to be slower and use better technique rather than try to blast up the hills.I have had situations where i wanted to take a good run up a hill (soft mterial/steep hill) and I just run out of steam halfway up the hill, and had to slowly go down in reverse.
Maybe a bigger diesel would have made it too, but the taxes on them are killers.
-
I guess that isn't completely a bad thing if it can teach better technique than just white knuckling it up the hill. The big diesel market here is much bigger, but almost always as heavy use towing rigs so there wouldn't really be any full throttle runs in that.
-
I recently discovered that a lot of the trucks I thought were Land Rover Defenders here are actually a spanish copy by Santana...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Santana_Motor



:ahhh
-
Hahahahaha well that is a pretty good copy. It happened a lot with the original jeeps as well. I'm not positive its actually stopped to be honest. Numerous countries borrowed the design, unfortunately I don't have any pictures of them.
-
@Higgins617 said:
Yeah they make better low end torque than any comparable gas engine does, I don't know personally but from what I've read the new diesels available in the Grand Cherokees and Rams are supposed to be pretty solid work horses. 420 Ft/Lbs of torque in the Grand with a turbo which is good for 7200Lbs towing for the 4x4.(3265kg for you silly metric people :D) I don't personally want one but it sounds like a great other option.Over here, we have three engine options for the Grand Cherokee, a 188HP 3l V6 diesel with 440Nm torque, a 247hp 3l V6 diesel with 570Nm (that's your 420ft/lbs figure) torque and a 461hp 6.4l V8 developing 624Nm torque but at twice the RPM.
The V8 weighs more, has over 1/2 a ton less towing capacity (3500kg for the diesel, 2949kg for the V8), it has less ground clearance, worse approach and departure angles, uses about twice as much fuel and has half the service intervals. It will do 0-62 in 5 seconds instead of 8 seconds but who cares?
Given that, you might see why the diesel would be more popular and that's ignoring what I think would be a pretty huge tax bill on the V8.
Comparing it to a Discovery (I think that's the best to compare it to really) you get 256hp and 600Nm out of another 3l diesel giving about the same fuel economy and performance as the diesel Jeep. So fairly comparable I think.
-
I'm not saying one is better than the other so I hope I'm not coming across that way Cupboard, I really like talking to someone who knows more about things than I do. It makes me feel like I'm learning something, the only real upside to gas over diesel engines seems to be the higher end power and they are more refined(at least in the past that was the case, not as much now). But I think that is why we are starting to see and increase in small diesel options over here as well. Don't they have a harder time with cold conditions though, I always remember this guy on my street trying to get his old diesel Mercedes warmed up for at least half an hour each day. I do enjoy how easily my V8 can shuffle the Durango along though, very well matched for the size.
-
Diesels also have issues at -30 to -40C. :ahhh
I have a few friends with diesel Jettas and Passats and they are always complaining about them in the cold. Of course much of that could have to do with these cars also being 20 year old beaters that these guys bought for next to nothing and hold together with bailing wire and spit.
Def
-
Higgins, does your Durango have the 4.7 in it? I believe the Durango and Grand Cherokee share the same engine, but I'm not 100% sure. My Grand has no problem scooting along, that's for sure. :)
Our 2002 Jetta diesel would start in -20c weather no problem without needing to be plugged in. Any colder and we'd have to cycle the glow plugs a few times, but it would always fire up. I'm pretty sure most newer diesel engines have no troubles at all starting in cold weather.
EDIT We never had to plug the car in for it to start. I miss that car!! :'(
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Diesels also have issues at -30 to -40C. :ahhhI have a few friends with diesel Jettas and Passats and they are always complaining about them in the cold. Of course much of that could have to do with these cars also being 20 year old beaters that these guys bought for next to nothing and hold together with bailing wire and spit.
Def
I had one of those. My 88 Diesel Jetta would not start unless being plugged in if it was below freezing. The car also was pretty much all original with over 400,000 on it. Whenever we would go out and it was cold, we'd just leave the car running and hope it was still there when we got back to it. :D
-
Yup, 4.7l Magnum. Which should be the same as the one in your Jeep, I believe the engines called the Powertech or something like that and apparently was on the list for the top 10 engines back when it came out in 1999. They make the most of the size they have, I always used to get jealous when I saw the R/Ts since they came with the 5.9l but it turns out that the 4.7 only makes around 20 less horsepower. I'm very happy with it other than the gas mileage
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login