SAK... Why???
-
Who says S30V is an upgrade?
Harder? Maybe. Hold an edge better? Maybe.
More corrosion resistant? unlikely. Easier to resharpen, very unlikely.
More likely to fracture than bend? Most probably.
It's all give-and-take, and I think Victorinox has settled on the steels that give it the properties it desires most (within the constraints of cost).
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
Who says S30V is an upgrade?Harder? Maybe. Hold an edge better? Maybe.
More corrosion resistant? unlikely. Easier to resharpen, very unlikely.
More likely to fracture than bend? Most probably.
It's all give-and-take, and I think Victorinox has settled on the steels that give it the properties it desires most (within the constraints of cost).
Very true, but S30V is THE top rated steel available these days.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
Who says S30V is an upgrade?
Harder? Maybe. Hold an edge better? Maybe.
More corrosion resistant? unlikely. Easier to resharpen, very unlikely.
More likely to fracture than bend? Most probably.
It's all give-and-take, and I think Victorinox has settled on the steels that give it the properties it desires most (within the constraints of cost).
Very true, but S30V is THE top rated steel available these days.
I ran a thread querying exotic steels on pocket knives a few weeks back,and generally speaking most folks with every day needs found a 440 steel to be just fine! Admittedly there are jobs where something like S30V,or rust resistant steels are justified,but the majority of SAK owners and users are neither fanboys,nor heavy users. The bulk of SAKs live quiet lives in handbags and rucksacks,gloveboxes and trouser pockets,quietly coming to the rescue,but otherwise spend their time Clark Kent-ing.
There just hasn't been the need to upgrade!
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
Who says S30V is an upgrade?
Harder? Maybe. Hold an edge better? Maybe.
More corrosion resistant? unlikely. Easier to resharpen, very unlikely.
More likely to fracture than bend? Most probably.
It's all give-and-take, and I think Victorinox has settled on the steels that give it the properties it desires most (within the constraints of cost).
Very true, but S30V is THE top rated steel available these days.
I ran a thread querying exotic steels on pocket knives a few weeks back,and generally speaking most folks with every day needs found a 440 steel to be just fine! Admittedly there are jobs where something like S30V,or rust resistant steels are justified,but the majority of SAK owners and users are neither fanboys,nor heavy users. The bulk of SAKs live quiet lives in handbags and rucksacks,gloveboxes and trouser pockets,quietly coming to the rescue,but otherwise spend their time Clark Kent-ing.
There just hasn't been the need to upgrade!
I can see your point & agree to a point. I mean who really needs a can opener made of S30V?
But I'm leaning toward the Multi tool venue of the SAK line.. Like the Spirit, SwissTool Etc. Arguably these are premier MT's in their venue. Not bashing 440 or anything like that. But they sure aren't giving these things away. Even Leatherman has incorporated S30V into their "Juice" tools. I'm simply stating when paying premier prices for MT's shouldn't premier metals be used? -
S30V has been around for several years. Just because Chris Reeves used it does not make it the best for everything.
There are a lot fancier steels around nowadays. Have a look in BF for the latest trends in knife steels.
However the best depends on what you need it for, how easy it is to sharpen, you have to factor in toughness as well as hardness.
Have a look here: http://zknives.com/knives/steels/steelchart.php
-
Good point,but isn't only on the Surges you can find S30V blades?
Do any of the other MT mani factors offer exotic steels?
-
Good point,but isn't only on the Surges you can find S30V blades?
Do any of the other MT mani factors offer exotic steels?
My Charge has it as well as some of the Juice line.
Are you sure there was a juice fancy blade? The only s30v blade I know of leatherman does is on the Charge TTi. The ALX has a CPM 154, and ever other blade on every other tool is 420hc as far as i know.
SAK 440C beats LM 420 any day.
-
@kirk13 said:
Good point,but isn't only on the Surges you can find S30V blades?Do any of the other MT mani factors offer exotic steels?
What? I didnt know you can get it on the Surge! Is it an upgrade option somewhere?
@Dale said:
Very true, but S30V is THE top rated steel available these days.What about s110v, k390, cts-204p, etc? There are alot of "super" steels out there that are better than s30v nowadays! IMO.
-
Good point,but isn't only on the Surges you can find S30V blades?
Do any of the other MT mani factors offer exotic steels?
What? I didnt know you can get it on the Surge! Is it an upgrade option somewhere?
@Dale said:
Very true, but S30V is THE top rated steel available these days.What about s110v, k390, cts-204p, etc? There are alot of "super" steels out there that are better than s30v nowadays! IMO.
+1
-
As to the Juice. Not certain, A friend in another forum stated his Juice had S30V. Researching I cannot find any info that states it does...
-
@Dale said:
As to the Juice. Not certain, A friend in another forum stated his Juice had S30V. Researching I cannot find any info that states it does...No such thing in a stock model. So if that friend isn't called Metro or Evil510 I highly doubt it. ;) Do you have a link to that post/picture maybe.
-
As to the Juice. Not certain, A friend in another forum stated his Juice had S30V. Researching I cannot find any info that states it does...
No such thing in a stock model. So if that friend isn't called Metro or Evil510 I highly doubt it. ;) Do you have a link to that post/picture maybe.
RACER
I’m surprised to hear that
I’m surprised to hear that too. My Juice Xe6 has S30V and the steel on the Vics appears to be at least as hard. But I haven’t really put any of my new Vics to a serious test. Whatever it is, it appears hard enough to already be getting some serious use out of my Tinker’s Philips screwdriver. I’ve already used it on screws that would’ve given grief to cheap Chinese screwdrivers made of softer steel.Is there an easy way to test the steel without risking damage to it?
-
That's a stock Juice. No way is it S30V. Let me log in there. ;)
-
I looked & looked. The only one I can find for sure is the CHARGE TTI. That & I own one.
-
The juice tools and blades are for surw 420.
-
True.

To quote myself from BLF.
I'm surprised to hear that too. My Juice Xe6 has S30V and the steel on the Vics appears to be at least as hard. But I haven't really put any of my new Vics to a serious test. Whatever it is, it appears hard enough to already be getting some serious use out of my Tinker's Philips screwdriver. I've already used it on screws that would've given grief to cheap Chinese screwdrivers made of softer steel.
Is there an easy way to test the steel without risking damage to it?
Where do you get that info from? I have quite a few Juices and none of them has an S30V blade. Only the Leatherman Charges come with those. You can buy Leatherman S30V blades off of TTC on eBay for Waves/Charges but all the other stock Leathermans come with a 420HC blade as far as I know.
As for Victorinox, they use:
x55CrMo14 for blades
x39Cr13 for parts
x20Cr13 for backspringsVic steel is hardened at 1040°C and then quenched at 160°C so the blades get a RC hardness of RC 56. (RC = Rockwell C, unit for hardness)
The saws, scissors and nail files are hardened to RC 53, screwdrivers, can openers and awls to RC 52 and the corkscrews and backsprings to RC 49.
The metal saw is work hardened and hard chromed to achieve a hardness that can cut iron and steel.
I copy/pasted a few of my replies from a recent thread here. >:D
-
As far as the Penknife + venue goes. SAK has & always will have that venue on lock. In the multi-tool arena ? I'm not convinced. Not taking anything away from them. The Spirit X is a beautiful tool. Maybe my expectations are too high, Maybe I got used to the Leatherman I've carried all these years. Ease of access is a HUGE thing to me. Especially one handed access. Hanging off the back of log trailer in high winds... Letting go with both hands isn't possible. But who knows? I've recently discovered SAK... Maybe my perception will change.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


