one hand challenge
-
Too easy. :P

-
Challenge accepted!
I tried the challenge on the following tools that usually see daily carry:
Belt Knife: no problems left or right hand (wasn't expecting any as I do this regularly)
Leatherman OHT: no problems left or right (wasn't expecting any but thought I should test to see if this tool really is one-handed and ambidextrous)
Gerber MP600: little finicky getting some of the smaller inside tools out, but doable due to the retention not being nail-breaking hard.
Vic Compact: difficult right-handed, very difficult left-handed. I don't see this as a primary tool and it is usually accompanying much more capable tools, so I'm not too worried.
Benchmade 915 Triage: blade was easy to open and close with both hands (no surprise as it's designed this way), hook was easy right-handed and not bad with the left hand, just needed to slow down and think it through.
Bic Lighter: easy enough with both hands (I've practiced this one before).
Leatherman ReCharge: Pliers and outside tools, no problem. Inner tools were more difficult but doable with some time.Interesting challenge. Glad to know what I can/can't access on the tools with one hand.
-
On my Charge ALX, alll outside tools are OHO-able WITH GLOVES ON.
Inside tools: The bit drivers are OHO-able and even doable with gloves on IF there's a seam that can catch the nubbin. I have never opened the can opener on the Charge. Just no need.
-
From most difficult to easiest for me...
Vic Farmer. The blade was dangerously difficult for me with either hand. Some work on 'technique' made it a little better, but I was afraid I was going to cut myself opening the blade. Everything else was doable either hand. Not easy, though.
Wenger Evogrip 17: No real problems on any tool, but I had to take multiple attempts on the cap lifter with my left hand for some reason. No real difference left or right.
Leatherman PST: Not hard really, just a little awkward getting some of the tools out. I had to switch grip on it a lot. no difference left or right.
Gerber MP600: A lot easier than I thought it'd be, both deploying the tools AND unlocking them one-handed. No difference left or right.
Leatherman Sidekick: The only problem was right-hand deploying the saw, and that was just because the tool is stiff. Even then, I'd prefer it to having to shift my grip so much on the PST. Only very slight difference left or right, due to the outside deployable tools.
Vic Spirit X: The all-outside-access tools, and the fact that the weight of the tool itself will pull a tool free once you grab it made everything on this tool easy to access, left or right handed.
Leatherman Wave: If I only counted the outside access tools, (the required blade/saw/file of the challenge), then this tool was miles better than any other to use, left or right handed. The can opener on mine is difficult to deploy, and that was the same either hand, but I could deploy any tool with either hand.
-
Mr Whippy makes an interesting point. Gloves.
I know I did this challenge with bare hands. If I was wearing light gloves, I'd probably be able to achieve similar results with most of the tools. Heavy winter gloves? Not so much and I think a lot less of the tools would be accessible.
-
That gloves part just might add the degree of difficulty to drive some people nuts
-
I tested some of my tools some time ago when I injured my left hand. The leatherman Crater is very easy to use one handed, so is the Gerber Octane and Buck xtract.
Sent from a device made from star dust using tapatalk
-
:whistle:
OK, an old video I did a couple of years ago. I never tried to OHO a SAK with gloves though. :D
- YouTube
Auf YouTube findest du die angesagtesten Videos und Tracks. Außerdem kannst du eigene Inhalte hochladen und mit Freunden oder gleich der ganzen Welt teilen.
(www.youtube.com)
-
SwissChamp ended the challenge like an ambidextrous Champ ...
although it prefers lefthanded OH corkscrew opening :DOne for all, all for one.

-
Too easy. :P
:whistle:
OK, an old video I did a couple of years ago. I never tried to OHO a SAK with gloves though. :D
it was like watching a magic show! :)
-
it might be slight off hand
-
Sidekick and Surge both passed :)
-
Ok. Tried the same tools with light and heavy weight gloves. Pretty well got the results I was expecting.
Belt Knife: no problems left or right hand (just needed to go slow as the traction plan on some of the gloves is a bit lacking)
Leatherman OHT: easy in the light gloves, more problematic in heavy gloves especially for the drivers and can opener.
Gerber MP600: light gloves performed about as well as bare handed. Heavy gloves made inner tools a pain, but doable by pulling out the longer tools and pressing the lock tab back against my leg to raise the inner tools a bit.
Vic Compact: impossible to one hand with gloves. Was expecting this result as I couldn't reasonably manage it with bare hands.
Benchmade 915 Triage: blade was no problems in either pair, just had to go slower with the heavy mitts. Closing was a bit trickier to engage the axis lock, but still doable. Hook wasn't bad at all with gloves as it was easy to catch the stud on the material. Closing was also easy as it is just a detent and no lock.
Bic Lighter: didn't do this one as the gloves would melt/catch fire that close to the flame and hot metal as they make my fingers much fatter than when bare handed.
Leatherman ReCharge: Pliers and outside tools were again no problem. Inner tools were difficult with light gloves and very difficult with heavy gloves. -
I failed miserably with heavy gloves. could be because they don't really fit but still failed.
good thing for this...

toolslinger, I missed what exactly is your ReCharge?
-
Do fingerless gloves count?
that's us mobile
-
OK, I dare you!


-
Fingerless gloves are basically bare hands for tool use. Boxing gloves would be pretty well impossible to get the tools out, let alone do anything with them once they were deployed. (I also don't have or know anyone who has boxing gloves...)
-
My ReCharge is a modified Charge TTi (old style handle scales).
Tool Load Out
ReBar plier head instead of standard plier head
S30v Plain blade
440c Serrated blade
Diamond File
Wood Saw
Large Bit Driver
Small Flathead from ReBar
Scissors
Large Flathead
Awl from ReBarI'm hoping to close a deal on a decent camera before the weekend. My last deal fell through. Then I can post a dedicated thread with pics
.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login